The Dead Sea Scrolls, discovered some seventy years ago, are famous for containing the oldest manuscripts of the Hebrew Bible (Old Testament) and many hitherto unknown ancient Jewish texts. But the individual people behind the scrolls have eluded scientists, because the scribes are anonymous. Now, by combining the sciences and the humanities, University of Groningen researchers have cracked the code, which enables them to discover the scribes behind the scrolls. They presented their results in the journal PLOS ONE on April 21, 2021.
The scribes who created the scrolls did not sign their work. Scholars suggested some manuscripts should be attributed to a single scribe based on handwriting. “They would try to find a “smoking gun” in the handwriting, for example, a very specific trait in a letter which would identify a scribe,” explains Mladen Popović, professor of Hebrew Bible and Ancient Judaism at the Faculty of Theology and Religious Studies at the University of Groningen. He is also director of the university’s Qumran Institute, dedicated to studying the Dead Sea Scrolls. However, these identifications are somewhat subjective and often hotly debated.
That is why Popović, in his project The Hands that Wrote the Bible which was funded by the European Research Council, teamed up with his colleague Lambert Schomaker, professor of Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence at the Faculty of Science and Engineering. Schomaker has long worked on techniques to allow computers to read handwriting, often from historical materials. He also performed studies to investigate how biomechanical traits, like the way in which someone holds a pen or stylus, would affect handwriting.
In this study, together with PhD candidate Maruf Dhali, they focused on one scroll in particular: the famous Great Isaiah Scroll (1QIsaa) from Qumran Cave 1. The handwriting in this scroll seems near-uniform, yet it has been suggested it was made by two scribes sharing a similar writing style. So how could this be decided? Schomaker: “This scroll contains the letter aleph, or “a”, at least five thousand times. It is impossible to compare them all just by eye.” Computers are well suited to analyze large datasets, like 5,000 handwritten a’s. Digital imaging makes all sorts of computer calculations possible, at the microlevel of characters, such as measuring curvature (called textural), as well as whole characters (called allographic).
“The human eye is amazing and presumably takes these levels into account too. This allows experts to “see” the hands of different authors, but that decision is often not reached by a transparent process,” Popović says. “Furthermore, it is virtually impossible for these experts to process the large amounts of data the scrolls provide.” That is why their results are often not conclusive.
The first hurdle was to train an algorithm to separate the text (ink) from its background (the leather or the papyrus). For this separation, or “binarization,” Dhali developed a state-of-the-art artificial neural network that can be trained using deep learning. This neural network keeps the original ink traces made by the scribe more than 2,000 years ago intact as they appear on the digital images. “This is important because the ancient ink traces relate directly to a person’s muscle movement and are person-specific,” Schomaker explains.
Dhali performed the first analytical test of this study. His analysis of textural and allographic features showed that the 54 columns of text in the Great Isaiah Scroll fell into two different groups that were not distributed randomly through the scroll, but were clustered, with a transition around the halfway mark.
With the remark that there might be more than one writer, Dhali then handed the data to Schomaker who then recomputed the similarities between the columns, now using the patterns of letter fragments. This second analytical step confirmed the presence of two different. Several further checks and controls were performed. Schomaker: “When we added extra noise to the data, the result didn’t change. We also succeeded in demonstrating that the second scribe shows more variation within his writing than the first, although their writing is very similar.”
In the third step, Popović, Dhali, and Schomaker have produced a visual analysis. They created “heat maps” that incorporate all the variants of a character across the scroll. Then they produced an averaged version of this character for the first 27 columns and the last 27 columns. Comparing these two average letters by eye shows that they are different. This links the computerized and statistical analysis to human interpretation of the data by approximation, because the heatmaps are neither dependent nor produced from the primary and secondary analyses.
Certain aspects of the scroll and the positioning of the text had led some scholars to suggest that after column 27 a new scribe had started, but this was not generally accepted. Popović: “Now, we can confirm this with a quantitative analysis of the handwriting as well as with robust statistical analyses. Instead of basing judgment on more-or-less impressionistic evidence, with the intelligent assistance of the computer, we can demonstrate that the separation is statistically significant.”
In addition to transforming the paleography of the scrolls — and potentially other ancient manuscript corpora — this study of the Great Isaiah Scroll opens up a totally new way to analyze the Qumran texts based on physical characteristics. Now, researchers can access the microlevel of individual scribes and carefully observe how they worked on these manuscripts.
Popović: “This is very exciting, because this opens a new window on the ancient world that can reveal much more intricate connections between the scribes that produced the scrolls. In this study, we found evidence for a very similar writing style shared by the two Great Isaiah Scroll scribes, which suggests a common training or origin. Our next step is to investigate other scrolls, where we may find different origins or training for the scribes.”
In this way, it will be possible to learn more about the communities that produced the Dead Sea Scrolls. “We are now able to identify different scribes,” Popović concludes. “We will never know their names. But after seventy years of study, this feels as if we can finally shake hands with them through their handwriting.”
Reference: “Artificial intelligence based writer identification generates new evidence for the unknown scribes of the Dead Sea Scrolls exemplified by the Great Isaiah Scroll (1QIsaa)” by Mladen Popović, Maruf A. Dhali and Lambert Schomaker, 21 April 2021, PLOS ONE.
Digital images of the Dead Sea Scrolls and of the Great Isaiah Scroll were kindly provided by Brill Publishers and the Israel Antiquities Authority (the Leon Levy Dead Sea Scrolls Digital Library).
I am curious whether the researchers considered whether the original writer could have had a physical issue develop approximately half way through the scroll. Anything from physical body injury to other ailments that may impact writing. With so many other characteristics in writing style being the same, its seems compelling to consider this possibility.
It is important to note that these are not original manuscripts: these are copies of prior manuscripts. The original as written by Isaiah, or his scribe or scribes, were long since gone when these were made. We need to distinguish carefully between “author” and “scribe.”
There is no evidence for prior texts, and the 1Qsaa was the oldest [ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_Sea_Scrolls#Scrolls_and_fragments ].
We must distinguish carefully between evidence of “prior manuscripts” and hypotheses of prior manuscripts. In this case there were none, the languages used were literary developed at the time (oldest Hebrew text).
Remember the author is God Himself and scribes simply write what they are told. All of it is a story of God’s redemption and foretelling of Jesus Christ His Son.
“The author is God”
No. The author(s) is/are humans that thought they were inspired.
This is either superstition or good trolling of it.
I agree with James. It’s possible the same individual could write with their non dominant hand and have heard of people who write a lot do this. Not to mention an injury that would still allow the writer to write with the same hand or perhaps old age or taking a break for a long while before continuing. My writing has changed over the years significantly. The way I used to write my “W”s for example changed from similar to 2″v”s to more like 2 “u”s. This happened as I found it to look nicer.
I don’t see the relevance since the Dead Sea Scrolls were fragmented over texts, authors and even languages [ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_Sea_Scrolls#Scrolls_and_fragments ].
Dam, You guys cant just read your bible and leave things alone can you. You guys can just look at the sky and enjoy the fact its blue. Or even just enjoy the day infront of you can you.
A life unexamined is not worth living. Alternatively, deep appreciation for the nuanced, awe-inspiring complexities of the splendor of creation can be a form of worship of its Creator. Either way, ease up
Ha, yeah, Mark, researchers really need YOUR advice…
Yeah, I dont think they really care about anyone’s advice. Almost like they put this out here for people to read and shut up. Who would have thought about that?
Seems the Sunday worshipers are a little upset by the fact that this scribe could be more than one which is no big deal because it was written between 3rd bce and after. Just centuries after the duo wrote 40-55 and 56-66 oops I mean Isaiah himself no I mean Lord of hosts did…..
I’m Rocking with Norm 💪🙏😉
Thomas, some people find such discussions enjoyable. There is nothing wrong with enjoying education or scrutiny. The bible teaches us to seek wisdom and understanding and to be prudent.
I find this subject interesting. I also find the comments of possible explanations for the subtle changes in handwriting interesting.
A myth text teach – by definition – nothing.
It can be amusing of course.
We have but one lifetime on this earth, spend it thanking and praising our creator and his son, sent for our redemption. Lets walk with them!
This is either superstition or good trolling of it.
Wow. These comments made so far show that not one of the authors has a clue about handwriting forensics or more than a 5th-grade aptitude.
? More like no one was interested in the science and what was found.
It confirms that the Dead Sea Scrolls were fragmented over texts, authors and even languages [ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_Sea_Scrolls#Scrolls_and_fragments ].
It fits well with a hypothesis that the invention of this particular superstition was caused by the Hellenistic conquest of the area. The real funny is that the invented priest author Manetho which similarly made up Egypt history after the Roman conquest (likely under Ptolemy II) dug up a real event, the South West Asian (“semite”) conquest of Egypt under the Hyksos rule. In that case there were written history and it seems to be evidenced by archeological finds (AFAIK), and that – in the “religio-history” tradition – could be the root to the still existing antisemitism 3.5 kyrs later! To borrow from the shunned group: “Oy vey!” Religion is the inventor of “evil”, indeed.
GOD is ALL that Matters. All known matter in the universe is GOD/unconditional love! Matter does not discriminate, we do. Matter does not hold back, or choose sides, we do. The imbalance between matter/GOD and antimatter is an application issue on our own part each and every one of us. Our entire economy and all injustices are a result of antimatter that we create individually by way of greed and intollerance. Just because it can’t be observed doesn’t mean it doesn’t exsist! Antimatter gives people an advantage over one another. Commonly referred to as “the run around” in order for the balance of antimatter and matter to be restored every individual would have to conduct themselves with the utmost of integrity. Be honest and upright at all times like matter is. If someone asks you for food and you have the ability to give it to them, but you respond with a rock or say “may God bless you” what glory is that to God? You just turned into antimater. Here is your sign.
Superstition, claiming non-existing magic exist. Show us the money!
I think it is impossible to name the scribes who wrote the text, but finding out that more than one scribe wrote a particular section is interesting indeed. I see it no different than a coin collection of a certain coin, of a certain year from all the different Mint’s that produced them. Useful, I don’t know. Satisfying, to some it is very satisfying.
Handed down thru time, this is the essential of what this ia all about. We all know the content but to know how it was penned is a great knowledge to obtain. Every lil step in understanding how to investigate can only help in the long run investigating other ancient manuscripts. Very cool article! Thanks
It’s debatable. First it is an unproven AI system that isn’t fully tested, and second with the way things are going in the world between the new fusion technology, and the FTL tech that NASA is working on. I think I will just wait until they create a time machine so I can just go back in time and ask for myself what the true translation is.
Yep I also agree with James. Ya know I have noticed that when I’m in a hurry or bothered by something my hand writing is always different. Parkinson disease or something close to that nature could play a huge roll in this and I believe this person might have been left handed probably ? Never know really… Also for the ones who think we should leave this stuff alone an stick with the bible. I suggest you pray for a more opened mind because the things that are about to unravel will make the dead and living flip the hell out… Imagine passing over to the other side to find out your life and everyone else have simply been lied to and as a matter of fact the whole world was lied to. People could not handle the truth. Just like the moon and Lucifer and Jesus Christ and when you die hell isn’t what you think nor is heaven… People are going to flip out… So as I had to come out of my comfort zone which is The Best Thing To Do and prepare yourself for change. People can not accept change so prepare for it because it’s going to happen regardless if you like it or not. I was born into Christian beliefs but I do not call myself a Christian ANYMORE… I’m blessed to see and know what I know now. I would become a evil monster people call demons if I died not knowing what I know now…
Since a couple folks want to take an opportunity to bash the Bible. Bash this. If the Bible is bullsh*t your life, this world, and everyone in it is. Too. We are part of a giant stagnating seemingly unending dumpster of Evil, pain, and despair.
But I’m thankful folks WILL BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE FOR THEIR DEEDS, INCLUDING MINE.
Without a final judgement nothing makes sense. The Bible tells us all about that
Thanks to woke and blm , nothing matters , history is being rewritten, in this socialist society, christ and god dont exist , wake up people
So, why is it that this AI only cracked the code of the dead sea scrolls. Why notany other ancient text?
That proves this is an agenda to help keep the man made Bible looking like it’s the word of “God”, when it’s actually a false doctrine created to control people.
Show me how intelligent this AI truly is by using it on other ancient text other than that bs book created by the white man.
What about numerical code.
Each identical symbol represents a digit 1-50 or the number of symbols specifically.
Maybe orders for goods, or like the underground railroad numbers of people any system that relied on numbers could use this type of vode
A N N U N A K I
Have you considered the possibility that it is the same scribe, but in the instances where they differ the scribe may have been ‘automatically-wriying’. As in- the Holy Spirit was writing for him using his hand. Wouldn’t you think it would slightly change?
Yeah,superstition that’s all it is right? I mean that’s like them saying you can give air an identity I mean really there’s no Air there’s no Oxygen floating around that you can’t see show me it I don’t see it right Larson there can’t possibly be any thing floating out there that says we need it cuz I can’t see it and then they’re going to want me to believe there’s actually something out there come on. And religion inventing evil wow yeah I can relate to that I mean because let’s be real it’s always been there but just because someone gave it an identity their responsible for creating it yeah that sounds logical to me right religion invented evil come on man.
Dwight Yokem said it best in Slingblade.
Not arguing for or against whether they were divinely inspired, but if an executive asks his secretary to write a letter of recommendation, including a few specific details, but leaving the rest up to the secretaries judgement, and then signs his name to the letter, who was the author of the letter?
I always laugh when people try to look for codes in Holy Texts. The whole book is written on the premise that God wants to share His Truth with the entire world. If he had this book written for this purpose, why would he add hidden codes that would further dilute or confuse his message?
Where’s the puke?
So all of that and we still didn’t find out what it says 🙄
Your images and captions do not resize you fit smaller screens.
I think it would be very enlightening if they could figure out the meaning. There are a lot of massages and languages that have been hidden from us. With the coming of AI we can possibly find out the true meaning of life and maybe people will begin to live different with a better understanding of life.
Making rushes at what he considers wealthy to steal. But My God forgives me.
Atheists dissing religion make me chuckle. Atheism is a religion. Membership is easy. It only requires a closed mind, condescending arrogance and a touch of narcissm …. hallelujah
Hi, Congratulations! This side is helpful. There is much to learn here. We can fix our mistakes from here. Thank you for this post shearing me.
Maybe two people took turns because their hand started to hurt after a while.
Remember to remember that if you forget to remember what you’ve remembered then it’s been forgotten.
They might have been autistic. Also, consider the frequency. Symbols are LITERALLY a reflection of what someone sees in their Eye
The idea that these dead sea scrolls tell anything is like going thru a landfill pulling bits of newspapers out and trying to answer the question of life with it.. it processor disproves nothing
There’s a lot of nutty comments down below. Used caution if you decide to read them
I don’t know why people who don’t understand the value of this are chiming in. It’s an odd social anomaly that seemed to develope with the anonymity of the whole thing I guess… sad what that reveals about human nature. I digress before I begin… anyway.. I think this is not some big mystery like it is being presented. The truth is there were Jewish communities within MANY nations. Not one person but all jews are responsible to study the word. Not on a superficial level mind you but on a brush stroke by brush stroke level. Figuratively of course before it was written it was by title and jot. Sorry biblical Hebrew joke. Anyway of course MANY educated Jews chose to put portions to pen. The dead sea scrolls are some of the oldest found. Old enough that some portions were never seem in the original tongue. But instead from a translation to Greek. In many instances this presents no problems. But in some instances slight or major mistranslations (maybe better to say partial incomplete translations of words) led to misunderstanding that persists to this day. That is the importance of finding any old biblical texts in the original tongue. As for the reason the want to know the scribe it is because they do not realize that many were educated and had reason to put it to parchment or because they wish to find some connection to actual biblical figures. Either way there is always value in pursuit of biblical truths.of study of the word. May those of you who come to tease and strike at those you would mock I offer love as my risen master would desire. But I also offer advice. Know that God is NOT the peaceful easily manipulated and petty tyrant you assume. He is rather an all consuming fire. That fire can be the fire of spiritual growth and joy or the fire of wrath. Why make an enemy where there only exists one who would offer you love if you could only see. I wouldn’t risk HIS wrath if I were you. Said with love not some form of imaginary wrathful feeling in your direction. Shalom.
The first question to ask yourself is whether or not God almighty whatever he may be is even aware of us. Maniacal humans disputing scrolls and God’s word seems silly. Why would God want/need to speak to us. He would command is if required or if it mattered. Get it?
Ok so why not really focus on what is written. Rather than try and pin point the author. Obviously there were no such thing as NY times best seller list back then so nobody was expecting fame or fortune otherwise they would have signed it. Consider that many wanted these destroyed must mean it has truth behind it. Just look at today. Speaking truth will get you banned especially if your are going against what the “office of the worshipful master” wants. I’m sure he has tried to get his hands on theses scrolls to destroy it. And no coincidence that one the first scrolls were found tech and knowledge has increased. Can’t remember who told who to go hide this in the bible.. oh. Daniel 12:9