Geologists Discover That NASA Rover Has Been Exploring Surface Sediments, Not Ancient Lake Deposits

Sedimentary Rocks Composing Mount Sharp

An image taken by the Curiosity Rover MastCam instrument shows layered sedimentary rocks composing Mount Sharp. The rover has been driving from the floor of Gale crater up through the rocks within these hills in order to understand how the rocks change from lower in the section (older) to higher in the section (younger). The rover have traversed rocks over >400 meters of elevation from the beginning of the mission. Credit: NASA’s Mars Curiosity Rover

In 2012, NASA landed the rover Curiosity in the Gale crater on Mars because the crater was thought by many scientists to be the site of an ancient lake on Mars more than 3 billion years ago. Since that time, the rover has been driving along, carrying out geological analyses with its suite of instruments for over 3,190 sols (martian days, equivalent to 3278 earth days). After analyzing the data, researchers from Department of Earth Sciences, the Faculty of Science at The University of Hong Kong (HKU), have proposed that the sediments measured by the rover during most of the mission did not actually form in a lake.

The researcher team suggested that the large mound of sedimentary rocks explored and analyzed for the last eight years actually represent sand and silt deposited as air-fall from the atmosphere and reworked by the wind. The alteration minerals formed by the interaction between water and the sand did not occur in a lake setting. The “wet” environment, they propose, actually represents weathering similar to soil formation under rainfall in an ancient atmosphere that was very different from the present one.

These images show Gale crater in High Resolution Stereo Camera (HRSC) images, with elevation colorized in blue. The image on the left shows the standard model where Gale crater is generally assumed to have been a large lake (flooded to at least an elevation of ~4,000m). The image at the right is the model proposed by Liu et al., in which only very small, shallow lakes existed on the floor of Gale crater (with the crater flooded only to an elevation of approximately ~4,500m). Most the sediments were deposited from the atmosphere as air-fall deposits and later weathered from precipitation or ice-melt. A star marks the rover’s landing site. Credit: ESA/HRSC/DLR

The discovery was published recently in Science Advances in a paper led by research postgraduate student Jiacheng Liu, his advisor Associate Professor Dr. Joe Michalski, and co-author Professor Mei Fu Zhou, all of whom are affiliated with the Department of Earth Sciences. The researchers used chemistry measurements and x-ray diffraction (XRD) measurements, in addition to images of rock textures, to reveal how compositional trends in the rocks relate to geological processes.

“Jiacheng has demonstrated some very important chemical patterns in the rocks, which cannot be explained in the context of a lake environment,” said Dr. Michalski. “The key point is that some elements are mobile, or easy to dissolve in water, and some elements are immobile, or in other words, they stay in the rocks. Whether an element is mobile or immobile depends not only on the type of element but also on the properties of the fluid. Was the fluid acidic, saline, oxidizing, etc. Jiacheng’s results show that immobile elements are correlated with each other, and strongly enriched at higher elevations in the rock profile. This points toward top-down weathering as you see in soils. Further, he shows that iron is depleted as weathering increases, which means that the atmosphere at the time was reducing on ancient Mars, not oxidizing like it is in the modern day, rusted planet.”

Understanding how the Martian atmosphere, and the surface environment as a whole, evolved is important for the exploration for possible life on Mars, as well as our understanding of how Earth may have changed during its early history. “Obviously, studying Mars is extremely difficult, and the integration of creative and technologically advanced methodologies are necessary. Liu and co-authors have made intriguing observations via the utilization of remote sensing techniques to understand the chemical composition of ancient sediments that inform on their early development. Their data present challenges to existing hypotheses for both the depositional environment of these unique rock formations and the atmospheric conditions that they formed under – specifically, the authors show evidence for weathering processes under a reducing atmosphere in a subareal environment similar to a desert, rather than formation in an aqueous lake environment. Indeed, this work will inspire new and exciting directions for future research.” Assistant Professor from Department of Earth Science Dr. Ryan McKenzie added.

China successfully landed its first lander, Zhurong, on Mars in May this year. Zhurong is currently roving the plains of Utopia Planitia, exploring mineralogical and chemical clues to recent climate change. China is also planning a sample return mission likely to occur at the end of this decade.

About the research team at HKU:

The Department of Earth Sciences, Research Division for Earth and Planetary Science and the Laboratory for Space Research specializes in the applications of traditional Earth and environmental science techniques and skills for modern space science challenges. Dr. Joe Michalski operates the Planetary Spectroscopy and Mineralogy Laboratory at HKU, and is the Deputy Director of the Laboratory for Space Research.


View Comments

  • We now know that we can Produce oxygen on other plants with a CO2 atmosphere, as the perseverence has succesfully provenzalisches. WOW!

  • Time scale. Time scale. Time scale... MAYBE BOTH scenarios apply, one following the other, more recent Discovery discovery... Is that REDUNDANT?

  • Wow the hight of stupidity. Billions of dollars down the dry hole.
    That lake is the crater from a lightning strike not your imaginary water lake. Go to the Electric Universe and get educated.

    • Where is the "dry hole" when the article present science results.

      And instead you propose pseudoscience with no results at all.

    • Gale crater is approximately 96 miles wide. Not sure what kind of lightning strike it would take to create a 96 mile crater there buddy.

    • You misunderstand! The Point of the Discovery mission was to find out such things. Too bad your standards aren't as high when it comes to incredulous speculations about the power of electricity. You could use some education yourself.

  • Wow the hight (sic) of exploration. Billions of dollars spent on an ongoing effort to do things people could only dream of for a very long time. That deposit may be redistributed, but it will help in identifying future spots so they can be prioritized. Do the Electric Slide and get down.

    • Thanks for your question. HKU is The University of Hong Kong.

      It was in the byline, but we should have included it in the body of the article. That has now been fixed.

      • And, who might you be? I don't find your name listed with the SciTech editorial board, or mentioned in the article.

  • If the planet surface is three billion years old, it doesn't matter if the eroded sediments have been redistributed or not, they are still that old. On Earth if early Archean sediments are eroded into a lake they are still 3.5 billion years old even if the lake bottom is Cenozoic in age. An atmosphere without oxygen is not automatically reducing but if it is life is precluded by virtue of lacking protection from the Sun's damaging UV radiation. The iron minerals on Mars are oxidized. Iron depleted sediments are not the same as reducing. The absence of laminated, fissile shales on Mars is more telling. No liquid water for very long to synthesize clay minerals that would then be eroded. And no dark colored sediments that would indicate the presence of organic matter.

    • Lake waters are UV-protective. The early sediment deposits are under exploration - the wind deposits on top looks to be km thick (c.f. Gale mound).

  • I would have like to know their feeling on discovering they were actually on a different form of sediment and if that would change things in any way moving forward,

  • They say earth and Mars are something a like but I do think mars has gravity like earth so where is gravity it has to be oxygen some where on Mars lol

  • Wouldn't 'rainfall:' pool. And if enough and enclosed, form a lake? Jeez even a puddle can be called a micro-lake.

The University of Hong Kong

Recent Posts

Just Like Humans – More Intelligent Jays Have This Characteristic

Similar to humans, more intelligent jays display more self-control.  According to recent research, Eurasian jays…

December 3, 2022

Ride Along With Artemis Around the Moon [Official NASA Video]

Cameras on NASA’s Space Launch System (SLS) rocket and Orion spacecraft give us amazing views…

December 3, 2022

What Lies Beneath Yellowstone’s Volcano? Twice As Much Magma As Thought

Researcher’s expertise, energy, and empathy leave a legacy. Late MSU researcher Min Chen contributed to…

December 3, 2022

New Innovative System Evaluates the Habitability of Distant Planets

A computerized system categorizes planet atmospheres and determines which are viable for future settlement by…

December 3, 2022

New Catalyst Can Turn a Smelly Gas Byproduct Into a Cash Cow

A catalyst activated by light converts hydrogen sulfide into hydrogen energy in one step. Engineers and…

December 3, 2022

Scientists Discover That Binge-Eating Sweet Treats Is Influenced by Gut Microbiome

Gut Microbes Influence Binge-Eating of Sweet Treats in Mice We have all been there. You…

December 3, 2022