“Great Unconformity” Puzzle: Geologists Dig Into Grand Canyon’s Mysterious Gap in Time

Grand Canyon Landscape

A new study led by the University of Colorado Boulder reveals the complex history behind one of the Grand Canyon’s most well-known geologic features: A mysterious and missing gap of time in the canyon’s rock record that covers hundreds of millions of years.

The research comes closer to solving a puzzle, called the “Great Unconformity,” that has perplexed geologists since it was first described nearly 150 years ago.

Think of the red bluffs and cliffs of the Grand Canyon as Earth’s history textbook, explained Barra Peak, lead author of the new study and a graduate student in geological sciences at CU Boulder. If you scale down the canyon’s rock faces, you can jump back almost 2 billion years into the planet’s past. But that textbook is also missing pages: In some areas, more than 1 billion years’ worth of rocks have disappeared from the Grand Canyon without a trace.

Geologists want to know why.

“The Great Unconformity is one of the first well-documented geologic features in North America,” Peak said. “But until recently, we didn’t have a lot of constraints on when or how it occurred.”

Horseshoe Bend Grand Canyon

Now, she and her colleagues think they may be narrowing in on an answer in a paper published this month in the journal Geology. The team reports that a series of small yet violent faulting events may have rocked the region during the breakup of an ancient supercontinent called Rodinia. The resulting havoc likely tore up the earth around the canyon, causing rocks and sediment to wash away and into the ocean.

The team’s findings could help scientists fill in missing pieces of what happened during this critical period for the Grand Canyon—today one of North America’s foremost natural wonders.

“We have new analytical methods in our lab that allow us to decipher the history in the missing window of time across the Great Unconformity,” said Rebecca Flowers, coauthor of the new study and a professor of geological sciences. “We are doing this in the Grand Canyon and at other Great Unconformity localities across North America.”

Beautiful lines

It’s a mystery that goes back a long way. John Wesley Powell, the namesake of today’s Lake Powell, first saw the Great Unconformity during his famed 1869 expedition by boat down the rapids of the Colorado River.

Peak, who completed a similar research rafting trip through the Grand Canyon in spring 2021, said that the feature is stark enough that you can see it from the river.

“There are beautiful lines,” Peak said. “At the bottom, you can see very clearly that there are rocks that have been pushed together. Their layers are vertical. Then there there’s a cutoff, and above that you have these beautiful horizontal layers that form the buttes and peaks that you associate with the Grand Canyon.”

The difference between those two types of rocks is significant. In the western part of the canyon toward Lake Mead, the basement stone is 1.4 to 1.8 billion years old. The rocks sitting on top, however, are just 520 million years old. Since Powell’s voyage, scientists have seen evidence of similar periods of lost time at sites around North America.

“There’s more than a billion years that’s gone,” Peak said. “It’s also a billion years during an interesting part of Earth’s history where the planet is transitioning from an older setting to the modern Earth we know today.”

A continent splits

To explore the transition, Peak and her colleagues employed a method called “thermochronology,” which tracks the history of heat in stone. Peak explained that, when geologic formations are buried deep underground, the pressure building on top of them can cause them to get toasty. That heat, in turn, leaves a trace in the chemistry of minerals in those formations.

Using this approach, the researchers conducted a survey of samples of rock collected from throughout the Grand Canyon. They discovered that the history of this feature may be more convoluted than scientists have assumed. In particular, the western half of the canyon and its eastern portion (the part that tourists are most familiar with) may have undergone different geologic contortions throughout time.

“It’s not a single block with the same temperature history,” Peak said.

Roughly 700 million years ago, basement rock in the west seems to have risen to the surface. In the eastern half, however, that same stone was under kilometers of sediment.

The difference likely came down to the breakup of Rodinia, a gigantic land mass that began to pull apart at about the same time, Peak said. The researchers results suggest that this major upheaval may have torn at the eastern and western halves of the Grand Canyon in different ways and at slightly different times—producing the Great Unconformity in the process.

Peak and her colleagues are now looking at other sites of the Great Unconformity in North America to see how general this picture might be. For now, she’s excited to watch geologic history play out in one of the country’s most picturesque landscapes.

“There are just so many things there that aren’t present anywhere else,” she said. “It’s a really amazing natural lab.”

 Reference: “Zircon (U-Th)/He thermochronology reveals pre-Great Unconformity paleotopography in the Grand Canyon region, USA” by B.A. Peak, R.M. Flowers, F.A. Macdonald and J.M. Cottle, 12 August 2021, Geology.
DOI: 10.1130/G49116.1

Other coauthors of the new study included John Cottle and Francis Macdonald of the University of California, Santa Barbara.

9 Comments on "“Great Unconformity” Puzzle: Geologists Dig Into Grand Canyon’s Mysterious Gap in Time"

  1. Clyde Spencer | August 21, 2021 at 5:57 pm | Reply

    “Peak explained that, when geologic formations are buried deep underground, the pressure building on top of them can cause them to get toasty.”

    The construction of the sentence suggests that the heat (i.e. “toasty) is a product of the lithostatic pressure. However, the thin layer of sediment laid down one year gets equilibrated with the water it is settling in before another layer is added. The same is true the following year, ad infinitum. That is to say, any heat from compression gets dissipated into the water and subjacent and superjacent rocks.

    I think that what is being observed is that the thicker the sediments, the more insulation it provides to geothermal heat, from the Earth’s interior, moving outwards towards the surface. Think of it as resistance to the movement of the geothermal heat. It is not unlike tossing more blankets on the bed in the Winter to retain body heat.

    The thicker the sedimentary ‘blanket,’ and the longer it is in place, the hotter the bottom of the sedimentary pile gets. If erosion removes part of the sequence, then heat can be radiated into space and conducted away by flowing water and air.

    I hope that the results of the research aren’t dependent on the interpretation of the source of the heating of the rocks.

  2. The authors are forming theories and conclusions of geological history, but, the foundation data, from ppl like Powell, is flawed.

    Ppl from 150years ago, never had a view of the Earth from space, and, never had the imagination to realise a geological feature could be many kilometres wide.

    So they single out a specific geo-point (usually curved or vertical lines in rock formations) and try to best fit their theories and conclusions to explain what they see.

    The authors are making the same mistakes.

    Until you understand precisely how the Earth was formed, any attempt at theory construction will only produce additional flawed data.

    • Clyde Spencer | August 22, 2021 at 6:49 am | Reply

      “Ppl from 150years ago, never had a view of the Earth from space, and, never had the imagination to realise a geological feature could be many kilometres wide.”

      You are selling historical geologists short and showing your ignorance. While the synoptic view offered by satellites has been valuable to geologists, maps were created precisely to provide a synthesis of local observations into the ‘Big Picture.’ Do you know what a melange is, or a low-angle thrust fault? Probably not or you wouldn’t have said what you did. You do, however, seem to be very familiar with fruit cake conglomerates!

  3. Lol. The grand csnyon was made like most of earths geology from eletrical storms like that of Jupiter today. Where welded tuff is created from ionized layers of dust forming from violent storms. Andrew hall. Electric geology can open your eyes to the truth.

    • Clyde Spencer | August 22, 2021 at 6:41 am | Reply

      “Electric geology can open your eyes to the truth.”

      Or blind you to the truth with its dogma!

      Welded tuffs have a unique chemistry and mineralogy that can be traced to the eruption site. There are historical observations of eruptions that create welded tuffs. On the other hand, the electrical storms of which you speak have never been observed on Earth.

      Your electric ‘religion’ is a variation of catastrophism and is a violation of the Uniformitarian Principle and of Occam’s Razor. It is easy to fool those who know nothing!

  4. You all just make sh*t up to get grants. You would never admit it, but that’s what you all do.

  5. Electric storms ! Ha ha !

  6. Duh, great flood.

  7. Paul The Same | August 23, 2021 at 4:42 pm | Reply

    Clyde Spencer seems to know what he’s talking about. I just wish that scientific journalism would not use expressions such as ‘toasty’.

Leave a Reply to Paul The Same Cancel reply

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.