“Mushballs”: Exotic Ammonia-Rich Hailstones Shed New Light on Jupiter’s Weather

The central part covers an area of 3200 x 3800 km (2000 x 2400 mi). White clouds of ammonia can be seen, rotating anticlockwise. Clouds rising as much as 15 km (9 mi) above the others (based on the shadow they cast) are visible in several places, especially in the upper central part of the cyclone. These storms are thought to contain a kind of water-ammonia hail (‘mushballs’) specific to Jupiter’s atmosphere, which drags the ammonia down into the deep atmosphere and may explain the presence of shallow lightning flashes. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/SwRI/MSSS/Kevin M. Gill

Water is a key substance in the meteorology of planets and is believed to play a key role in their formation. Terrestrial storms are driven by water dynamics creating lightning storms thought to be connected to regions where multiple phases of water co-exist (solid, liquid, and gas). As on Earth, Jupiter’s water is moved around by thunderstorms. Those are thought to form within the planet’s deep atmosphere, around 50 km (31 mi) below the visible clouds, where the temperature is close to 0°C. When these storms are powerful enough, they carry crystals of water-ice into the upper atmosphere.

In the first article, researchers from the US and the Laboratoire Lagrange suggest that when these crystals interact with gaseous ammonia, the ammonia acts as an anti-freeze, changing the ice to a liquid. On Jupiter as on Earth, a mixture of 2/3 water and 1/3 ammonia gas will remain liquid down to a temperature of -100°C (-148°F). The ice crystals which have been lofted high into Jupiter’s atmosphere are melted by ammonia gas, forming a water-ammonia liquid, and become the seeds for exotic ammonia hailstones, dubbed ‘mushballs’ by the researchers. The mushballs being heavier then fall deeper into the atmosphere until they reach a point where they evaporate. This mechanism drags ammonia and water down to deep levels in the planet’s atmosphere.

Measurements by Juno discovered that while ammonia is abundant near Jupiter’s equator, it is highly variable and generally depleted elsewhere to very deep pressures. Prior to Juno, scientists saw evidence that parts of Jupiter’s atmosphere were depleted in ammonia to relatively shallow depths, but this had never been explained. To explain Juno’s discovery of ammonia’s deep variability across most of Jupiter, the researchers developed an atmospheric mixing model that is presented in a second article. Here they show that the presence of thunderstorms and the formation of water-ammonia mushballs dry out the deep atmosphere of its ammonia and account for the variations observed by Juno as a function of latitude.

In a third article, the researchers report observations of Jovian lightning flashes by one of Juno’s cameras. The small flashes appear as bright spots on the cloud tops, with sizes proportional to their depth in Jupiter’s atmosphere. Unlike previous missions that had only observed lightning flashes from deep regions, Juno’s proximity to the planet enabled it to detect smaller, shallower flashes. These flashes come from regions where temperatures are below -66°C (-87°F) and where water alone cannot be found in the liquid state. Yet the presence of a liquid is thought to be crucial to the lightning-generation process. Juno’s detection of “shallow lightning” storms at the altitudes where liquid ammonia-water can be created is observational support that the mushball mechanism may indeed be at work in Jupiter’s atmosphere.

Understanding the meteorology of Jupiter and of other as yet unexplored giant planets such as Uranus and Neptune should enable us to better comprehend the behavior of gas giant exoplanets outside our own Solar System.

Read NASA’s Juno Spacecraft Reveals Jupiter’s Unusual Electrical Storms: “Shallow Lightning” and “Mushballs” for more on this research.

References:

“Small lightning flashes from shallow electrical storms on Jupiter” by Heidi N. Becker, James W. Alexander, Sushil K. Atreya, Scott J. Bolton, Martin J. Brennan, Shannon T. Brown, Alexandre Guillaume, Tristan Guillot, Andrew P. Ingersoll, Steven M. Levin, Jonathan I. Lunine, Yury S. Aglyamov and Paul G. Steffes, 5 August 2020, Nature.
DOI: 10.1038/s41586-020-2532-1

‘Storms and the Depletion of Ammonia in Jupiter: I. Microphysics of “Mushballs”’ by Tristan Guillot, David J. Stevenson, Sushil K. Atreya, Scott J. Bolton and Heidi N. Becker, 5 August 2020, Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets.
DOI: 10.1029/2020JE006404

“Storms and the Depletion of Ammonia in Jupiter: II. Explaining the Juno Observations” by Tristan Guillot, Cheng Li, Scott J. Bolton, Shannon T. Brown, Andrew P. Ingersoll, Michael A. Janssen, Steven M. Levin, Jonathan I. Lunine, Glenn S. Orton, Paul G. Steffes and David J. Stevenson, 3 August 2020, Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets.
DOI: 10.1029/2020JE006403