“Smoking Gun” Evidence That Mammals Were Not the First To Be Warm-Blooded

Warm Blooded Mammals

A warm-blooded mammal ancestor breathing out hot hair in a frigid night. Credit: Luzia Soares

Karoo fossils provide “smoking gun” to when warm-bloodedness evolved in pre-mammalian ancestors.

The ability of mammals and birds to generate their own body heat and control their body temperature is called endothermy, or warm-bloodedness.

This significant distinction from cold-blooded reptiles underpins the ecological dominance of mammals in practically every ecosystem globally. It was not known exactly when endothermy originated in mammalian ancestry — until now. A team of international scientists has found the smoking gun of this key evolutionary event in the inner ears of fossils from South Africa and around the globe.

New research suggests that endothermy appeared in mammalian ancestors about 233 million years ago, well before the origin of mammals, which occurred about 200 million years ago. This study, titled “Inner ear biomechanics reveals Late Triassic origin of mammalian endothermy” was published on July 20 in the journal Nature. Researchers from the University of the Witwatersrand (Wits University) in Johannesburg, South Africa were part of the international team of scientists that conducted the study.

“For the first time, we are able to trace through evolution the direct consequence of the origin of endothermy on the skeletal anatomy of our pre-mammalian ancestors,” says Dr. Julien Benoit, Senior Researcher in Palaeontology at the Evolutionary Studies Institute at Wits University. “This is an exciting time for our field of study.”

The intuition

In addition to being the organ of hearing, the inner ear also houses the organ of balance: the semicircular canals. The inner ear’s three semicircular canals are oriented in the three dimensions of space and are filled with a fluid that flows in the canals as the head moves and activates receptors to inform the brain of the exact three-dimensional position of the head and body. For the balance organ to efficiently detect head rotation and aid balance, the viscosity, or runniness, of this fluid (called the endolymph) is of critical importance.

Similar to other fluids, the viscosity of the endolymph changes with body temperature, just as a chunk of butter turns from solid to liquid in a warm pan. Because of this physical property, the evolution of a higher body temperature would cause the viscosity of the endolymph to be altered. However, this change of viscosity cannot be left unchecked, otherwise, the balance organ would no longer work properly. The semicircular canals of the inner ear must adapt to the new viscosity imposed by higher body temperature: they have to change their geometry.

Size differences between inner ears (in grey) of warm-blooded (on the left) and cold-blooded (on the right) mammal ancestors. Inner ears are compared for animals of similar body sizes. Credit: Romain David and Ricardo Araújo

The key intuition of the two lead authors of the discovery, Dr. Ricardo Araújo (University of Lisbon) and Dr Romain David (Natural History Museum of Paris), was to realize that this change in the semicircular canals shape would be easy to trace through geologic time using fossils. Pinpointing the species in which this change of geometry occurred would work as an accurate guide to when endothermy evolved: the smoking gun identifying when mammalian ancestors transitioned from cold-blooded to warm-blooded.

“Until now, semicircular canals were generally used to predict locomotion of fossil organisms. However, by carefully looking at their biomechanics, we figured that we could also use them to infer body temperatures. This is because, like honey, the fluid contained inside semicircular canals gets less viscous when temperature increases, impacting function. Hence, during the transition to endothermy, morphological adaptations were required to keep optimal performances, and we could track them in mammal ancestors,” says Dr. Romain David, Post-Doctoral Researcher at the Natural History Museum and Lead Author on the paper.

The contribution of Karoo fossils

The researchers found that the inner ear canals geometry adapted to a relatively abrupt change in endolymph viscosity some 233 million years ago, indicating that the overall body temperature of mammal ancestors became warmer at this time.

Fossils from the South African Karoo played a key role in this discovery, in part because of the wealth of fossils of mammal ancestors that the Karoo-aged rocks have produced in more than a hundred years of study.

The bony inner ear of a squirrel monkey (in blue) and the soft tissues inside it (in red). Relations between bony and soft tissue structures have been studied in extant species to infer inner ear function in fossils and infer whether they were cold or warm-blooded. Credit: Romain David

South African fossils offer an unbroken record of the evolution of life during an interval of almost 100 million years, documenting the transformation from reptilian-like animals (the therapsids) to mammals in exquisite detail. Additionally, because the Karoo was situated closer to the South Pole at that time as a result of continental drift, the warmer body temperature suggested by the geometry of the inner ear cannot be due to an overall warmer climate.

“As the South African climate was colder on average, the change in inner ear fluid viscosity can only have been caused by a generally warmer body temperature in mammalian ancestors,” says Benoit.

Using cutting-edge CT-scanning techniques and 3D modeling, the researchers were able to reconstruct the inner ear of dozens of mammalian ancestors from the South African Karoo and elsewhere in the world, and managed to point out exactly which species had an inner ear anatomy consistent with a warmer body temperature, and which ones did not.

A change of paradigm

Until now the general expectation was that endothermy arose very close to the Permo-Triassic boundary, about 252 million years ago, or perhaps closer to the origin of mammals 200 million years ago. The new results suggest that endothermy appeared in mammalian ancestors some 233 million years ago. This new date is consistent with the recent findings that many of the traits usually associated with “mammalness,” such as whiskers and fur, also evolved earlier than previously expected. More importantly, the results support that the evolutionary transition to warmbloodedness was unexpectedly fast.

“Contrary to current scientific thinking, our paper surprisingly demonstrates that the acquisition of endothermy seems to have occurred very quickly in geological terms, in less than a million years,” says Dr. Ricardo Araújo, Junior Researcher at Instituto de Plasmas e Fusão Nuclear, Instituto Superior Técnico, University of Lisbon and Lead Author on the paper. “It was not a gradual, slow process over tens of millions of years as previously thought, but maybe was attained quickly when triggered by novel mammal-like metabolic pathways and origin of fur.”

“The origin of mammalian endothermy is one of the great unsolved mysteries of paleontology,” says Dr. Kenneth D. Angielczyk, MacArthur Curator of Paleomammalogy at Field Museum of Natural History, USA and Senior Author on the paper.

“Many different approaches have been used to try to predict when it first evolved, but they have often given vague or conflicting results. We think our method shows real promise because it has been validated using a very large number of modern species, and it suggests that endothermy evolved at a time when many other features of the mammalian body plan were also falling into place.”

Reference: “Inner ear biomechanics reveals a Late Triassic origin for mammalian endothermy” by Ricardo Araújo, Romain David, Julien Benoit, Jacqueline K. Lungmus, Alexander Stoessel, Paul M. Barrett, Jessica A. Maisano, Eric Ekdale, Maëva Orliac, Zhe-Xi Luo, Agustín G. Martinelli, Eva A. Hoffman, Christian A. Sidor, Rui M. S. Martins, Fred Spoor and Kenneth D. Angielczyk, 20 July 2022, Nature.
DOI: 10.1038/s41586-022-04963-z

University of The Witwatersrand

Recent Posts

Dinosaur-Killing Asteroid Triggered Monstrous Global Tsunami With Mile-High Waves

Sixty-six million years ago a miles-wide asteroid struck Earth, wiping out nearly all the dinosaurs…

October 5, 2022

NASA, SpaceX Proceeding to Crew-5 Launch to International Space Station

NASA will provide live coverage of the upcoming launch activities for the SpaceX Crew-5 mission…

October 5, 2022

Even Moderate Exercise Can Greatly Increase Brain Size

The effects are more pronounced in brain areas with high oxygen demand. Exercise keeps both…

October 4, 2022

Caltech’s Breakthrough New Nanophotonic Chip “Squeezes” More Out of Light

Electronic computing and communications have advanced significantly since the days of radio telegraphy and vacuum…

October 4, 2022

Parallels to HIV: Another Fatal Monkey Virus Could Be Poised for Spillover to Humans

Evoking parallels to HIV, authors are calling on global health community to be vigilant. According…

October 4, 2022

Scientists Show Transmission of Epigenetic Memory Across Multiple Generations

Changing the epigenetic marks on chromosomes results in altered gene expression in offspring and in…

October 4, 2022