Watching immersive 3D videos of icy Arctic scenes helps to relieve burning pain and could hold hope for treating chronic pain, a study has found.
Scientists from Imperial College London have found that using virtual reality headsets could combat increased sensitivity to pain, by immersing people in scenes of icebergs, frigid oceans, and sprawling icescapes.
In a small proof-of-concept study, published in Pain Reports, a team from Imperial used VR video to reduce peoples’ scores of perceived ongoing pain as well their sensitivity to painful stimuli.
According to the researchers, the findings add to the growing evidence for the potential of VR technology to help patients with chronic pain.
Beyond the distracting effect, they think immersing patients in VR may actually trigger the body’s own inbuilt pain-fighting systems – reducing their sensitivity to painful stimuli and reducing the intensity of ongoing pain.
Dr. Sam Hughes, from the MSk Lab at Imperial and the first author on the paper, said: “One of the key features of chronic pain is you get increased sensitivity to painful stimuli. This means patients’ nerves are constantly ‘firing’ and telling their brains they are in a heightened state of pain.
“Our work suggests that VR may be interfering with processes in the brain, brainstem, and spinal cord, which are known to be key parts of our inbuilt pain-fighting systems and are instrumental in regulating the spread of increased sensitivity to pain.”
Virtual reality has been trialed as a method to distract patients from the pain, with some success in minor dental procedures requiring local anaesthetic. But the latest study looked to see if it could work in a simulated model of chronic pain.
Modelling chronic pain
In the trial, 15 healthy volunteers were given a topical cream on the skin of their leg containing capsaicin – the fiery compound in chilis that makes your mouth burn. The capsaicin sensitized the skin, making the area more sensitive to painful stimuli (a very small electric shock) and mimicking the heightened sensitivity of people with chronic pain; such as lower back pain, arthritis, or nerve pain.
Participants were then asked to rate the pain caused by the capsaicin cream on a scale of 0-100 (from ‘no sensation’ to ‘worst pain imaginable’) while either watching a VR scene of arctic exploration through a headset (see embedded video), or looking at a still image of an Arctic scene on a monitor. They were also asked to say when a stimulus applied directly to the sensitized skin area is perceived as painful.
The team found that ongoing pain was reduced following VR immersion, and that sensitivity to painful stimuli on the skin was also reduced. However, the same effect was not seen in people who looked at still images of the polar environment, showing immersion is the key factor.
They explain that while the initial findings are encouraging, the study is limited by the small number of healthy participants, without chronic pain. Future randomized controlled trials with chronic pain patients could also help to confirm its potential benefit for patients.
Alternative therapy
However, the researchers believe VR could hold the potential to treat patients with chronic pain who often have deficient inbuilt pain-fighting systems. They suggest that using VR may provide an alternative therapy for some chronic pain conditions by improving activity in brain regions involved in these pain-relief systems.
The team, which included Dr. Paul Strutton from the Department of Surgery & Cancer and MRes Biomedical Research student Ms. Hongyan Zhao, now plans to further investigate the pathways involved in the VR dampening effect, including whether a dosing regimen would work – such as 30 minutes, four times a day – and if the effects would be cumulative or remain temporary.
“The aim of this study was to show VR has the ability to change the pathological processing associated with chronic pain,” added Dr. Hughes. “Using this approach does seem to reduce the overall intensity of the ongoing pain as well as the response we get on the skin. We think there could be changes in the body’s pain relief system which can affect how pain sensitivity is processed in the spinal cord.”
He added: “There are still many things to figure out, but one exciting aspect of our study is that the VR design we used is completely passive – meaning patients don’t need to use their arms. Potentially, it could mean that patients who are bed-bound or can’t move their limbs, but with chronic pain, could still benefit from this approach.”
Reference: “Attenuation of capsaicin-induced ongoing pain and secondary hyperalgesia during exposure to an immersive virtual reality environment” by Sam W. Hughes, Hongyan Zhao, Edouard J. Auvinet and Paul H. Strutton, 22 October 2019, PAIN Reports.
DOI: 10.1097/PR9.0000000000000790
it’s the soft hippie version of punching you in the arm to distract you from your headache.
As someone with chronic nerve pain (damage to my trigeminal nerve from a dental implant) for over 18 years I find the fact that this study is even published as claiming to “help ease people’s pain” as extremely insulting and disturbing. I have spent the majority of these 18 years trying to find treatments that would allow me to get off opioids as I do not like taking them, however, so far, this is the only treatment that helps ease my pain. Reading this article and how this study was done is truly insulting to someone with chronic pain. To imply that applying capsaicin to the leg would mimic the feeling of chronic nerve pain is laughable. Then there is the fact that there were only 15 participants in the study, none of which even had chronic pain. I realize that researchers have to start somewhere, but that doesn’t mean they have to publish everything they do. This entire “study” should have been kept in the files and when they actually have something important to share that’s when they should contact the press. This information is just insulting and I’m shocked you printed it.