Some Startling Statistics & Should Most Fatal Drug Overdoses Be Considered Suicide?

SIM Rates

New research from Ian Rockett, professor emeritus of the WVU School of Public Health, shows that suicides among blacks, Hispanics and women are under-reported. Credit: Jennifer Shephard/West Virginia University

To classify a death as a suicide, medical examiners and coroners rely on hard evidence, perhaps a suicide note or a gun near the body. 

But research led by Ian Rockett, professor emeritus of the West Virginia University School of Public Health, applied a wider lens on how suicides and drug deaths that implicated self-injurious behaviors could be categorized. Should most non-homicide opioid- and other drug-intoxication deaths, intentional or not, be reported as self-injury mortality (SIM) along with all detected suicides?

Rockett believes they should. 

By examining trends in suicide and non-suicide drug self-intoxication deaths by race/ethnicity and sex, Rockett and his colleagues uncovered some startling statistics:

  • SIM rates for blacks jumped 109 percent between 2008 and 2017, compared to a 55 percent increase for whites.
  • The use of SIM exposed excesses in female deaths by substance poisoning, reflecting that suicides are underreported for females because they employ methods less obvious (especially drug self-intoxication) than those of men (notably gunshot and hanging).
  • The burden of early deaths due to self-injury is heaviest among Hispanics, who are projected to have lost 43 years of life versus 37 years for whites and 32 years for blacks. 

As implemented in this study, SIM then encompasses not only all detected suicides but drug deaths that implicate repeated self-harming behaviors. 

“Impeding prevention, the opioid epidemic and the more silent suicide epidemic are usually treated as distinct phenomena by researchers, clinicians, public health professionals and the mass media,” said Rockett, whose research was published in the peer-reviewed medical and public health journal Injury Prevention.

Ian Rockett, West Virginia University

Ian Rockett, professor emeritus of the WVU School of Public Health, has studied suicide rates and trends for several years. His research indicates that self-imposed drug overdoses, whether intentional or not, should be categorized as suicides. Credit: West Virginia University

“Even if most people dying by drug poisoning did not intend to die on their day of death, descriptively speaking their preceding behaviors were consistent with self-harm or self-injury. Moreover, correctly characterizing and labeling these deaths as self-injury should intensify the urgency for prevention, and for the identification and treatment of high-risk individuals.”

Rockett explained that blacks and Hispanics are less likely than whites to have their suicides detected due to unequal health care access, a source of serious health data disparities. Consequently, less is known about their psychological/psychiatric histories and they also leave fewer evidentiary suicide notes behind. 

Contrasting with their male opposites, the research shows that women, whether black, Hispanic or white, are more likely to die from a self-administered drug overdose than from more violent means. 

Rockett’s study used national mortality data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s Injury Statistics Query and Reporting System, for the period 2008-2017. 

Ultimately, Rockett hopes the study findings will shed more light on the magnitude of the national mental health crisis. 

“Suicide kills more than twice as many Americans annually as homicide, even ignoring the greater susceptibility of suicides to undercounting,” Rockett said. “Medical examiners and coroners are much more under-resourced by society for conducting suicide investigations than homicide investigations.

“However, widespread adoption of the SIM concept would place less emphasis on the very costly process of postmortem inference of decedent intent, and more emphasis on accurately characterizing fatal self-injury from a behavioral perspective – for the primary purpose of improving prevention. We need unified population and clinical approaches to prevention that will view drug deaths and suicides as profoundly overlapping components in our national mental health crisis. 

“A societal imperative is that coalitions of the willing must strive to place mental health on an equal footing with physical health, as inter-connected phenomena, in order to reverse the disturbing trend of declining life expectancy in the U.S. population.”

Co-authors include Eric Caine, University of Rochester; Hilary Smith Connery, McLean Hospital; Kurt Nolte, University of New Mexico; Paul Nestadt, Johns Hopkins University; Lewis Nelson, Rutgers University; and Haomiao Jia, Columbia University

Reference: “Unrecognised self-injury mortality (SIM) trends among racial/ethnic minorities and women in the USA” by Ian R H Rockett, Eric D Caine, Hilary S Connery, Kurt B Nolte, Paul S Nestadt, Lewis S Nelson and Haomiao Jia, 24 September  2019, Injury Prevention.
DOI: 10.1136/injuryprev-2019-043371

Be the first to comment on "Some Startling Statistics & Should Most Fatal Drug Overdoses Be Considered Suicide?"

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.