A Genetic Paradox: Inbreeding Can Be Beneficial in the Long Run

Red Blue DNA Strand

The Svalbard reindeer, despite significant inbreeding and low genetic diversity, boasts a robust population of over 20,000, having adapted to Arctic conditions with unique traits like smaller size and the ability to digest mosses. Although they have evolved rapidly to past environmental changes, scientists fear the pace of current global warming may outstrip their capacity to adapt, posing a serious threat to their survival.

Reindeer have endured for over 7,000 years on the Arctic archipelago of Svalbard. Will they be able to withstand climate change?

Despite the challenges of inbreeding and limited genetic diversity, the Svalbard reindeer have remarkably adapted to harsh living conditions in an extraordinarily short period, a situation researchers term a genetic paradox. However, the question remains: can they withstand the impacts of climate change?

“Of all the subspecies of reindeer found in the high north, the Svalbard reindeer has the most inbreeding and the lowest genetic diversity,” says Nicolas Dussex, a postdoc at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology’s (NTNU) Department of Natural History.

It was only 7000-8000 years ago that the first reindeer migrated to Svalbard, most likely from Russia via Novaya Zemlya and the islands of Franz Josef Land. Perhaps there were no more than a few animals that established themselves on the Arctic archipelago. Evolutionary theory suggests this is a poor starting point since inbreeding can quickly lead to an accumulation of harmful mutations and genetic variants followed by disease and death.

Svalbard Reindeer Eating Moss

Among their many adaptations to life on the Svalbard, reindeer have developed the ability to digest moss instead of lichen. Credit: Bart Peeters

Rapid adaptation to an extreme environment

But this has not prevented the Svalbard reindeer from evolving into what is today a viable population of more than 20,000 animals.

“Despite the low genetic diversity, they have managed to develop a number of adaptations to life in the High Arctic. They are, for example, smaller in size and have shorter legs than other northern reindeer and caribou subspecies,” says Dussex.

The ability to digest mosses in the absence of lichens, and to adjust their circadian rhythm to the extreme seasonal variations on Svalbard, are also traits the Svalbard reindeer have developed over the relatively short time they have lived isolated on the archipelago. Now, researchers at NTNU and collaborating institutions have analyzed genetic samples from 91 reindeer to see how they differ from their relatives on the mainland.

Svalbard Reindeer

Svalbard reindeer. Credit: Bart Peeters

“Populations living on isolated islands are often small and are well-suited to studying genetic problems. The Svalbard reindeer has been isolated for at least 7000 years and has a very high degree of inbreeding. In addition, they were nearly extinct in the early 1900s due to excessive hunting,” says Michael D. Martin, a professor at NTNU’s Department of Natural History.

Getting rid of harmful mutations

This near-extinction, where only a few individuals with their unique genetic variants survive, is called a bottleneck in population biology.

“In this case, we are dealing with a population that suffers from a high degree of inbreeding, which is usually bad news for a small population. But inbreeding can also help a population to get rid of harmful mutations, a phenomenon technically called ‘purging’,” says Martin.

Mathilde Le Moullec

Mathilde Le Moullec, a postdoc at NTNU, has collected “sub-fossil” bone samples from reindeer on Svalbard. The bones can be used to study how the genetics of the reindeer have changed over the centuries. Credit: Brage Bremset Hansen, NTNU

In a population with a high degree of inbreeding, offspring are more likely to inherit harmful mutations from both mother and father. Therefore, these “dangerous” mutations more quickly manifest in the form of genetic diseases and poorer health. Offspring carrying these mutations become less “fit”, and they will either die before they have the chance to reproduce or they will have fewer offspring. Consequently, these dangerous mutations are less likely to be passed on to subsequent generations.

“Paradoxically, in the long run, inbreeding can be beneficial,” says Dussex.

Punctuated evolution or steady and continuous?

Similar phenomena have been observed elsewhere in nature. In New Zealand, Kakapo parrots (Strigops habroptilus), which had lived isolated on the islands for at least 10,000 years, became endangered after the arrival of non-native species brought to the islands by humans. In 1995, there were only 60 individuals left, but today the population has grown to around 200. Here too, Dussex and his colleagues found that harmful genetic variants had disappeared from the population thanks to a long period of inbreeding.

“This is important knowledge when it comes to population management. The fact that the Svalbard reindeer is in relatively good genetic condition considering harmful mutations, is good news,” says Brage Bremset Hansen, professor of conservation biology at NTNU’s Department of Biology and Center for Biodiversity Dynamics. Hansen is also a senior researcher at the Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA).

This knowledge about the Svalbard reindeer can also change the way researchers study the effects of genetic bottlenecks, Dussex said.

“What we still do not know enough about is how quickly such harmful mutations are selected against. We will continue to work on this, using DNA samples collected from bone remains and antlers of animals that lived several thousand years ago. This way, we can see whether these mutations have disappeared quickly over a few centuries or if it has happened gradually over several thousand years,” he said.

The researchers are also very interested in examining the development of beneficial mutations, which have allowed the Svalbard reindeer to adapt to the unique ecosystem.

“This is a ‘work in progress’,” says Martin, who also worked closely with researcher Mathilde Le Moullec, who over past years did the fieldwork to collect most of the bone samples from various locations on Svalbard.

Climate change may be too fast

It is far from certain that the Svalbard reindeer will be able to adapt as well to the rapid changes that result from global warming. The adaptations the reindeer have developed for the extreme arctic climate may fall short as the archipelago is now rapidly warming, which is changing both snow cover and vegetation.

“Global warming is causing Svalbard’s climate to change faster than anywhere else in the world. Even though our results show that the Svalbard reindeer managed to adapt relatively quickly to a completely new environment after they colonized the islands, they might have trouble adapting to today’s rapid warming. They may have simply lost too much genetic variation,” says Hansen.

This also applies to other terrestrial animals that have limited opportunities to move as climate change makes life difficult for them.

“But this work now provides us with a better basis for understanding how quickly species can adapt to new environments,” says Martin.

Reference: “Adaptation to the High-Arctic island environment despite long-term reduced genetic variation in Svalbard reindeer” by Nicolas Dussex, Ole K. Tørresen, Tom van der Valk, Mathilde Le Moullec, Vebjørn Veiberg, Ave Tooming-Klunderud, Morten Skage, Benedicte Garmann-Aarhus, Jonathan Wood, Jacob A. Rasmussen, Åshild Ø. Pedersen, Sarah L.F. Martin, Knut H. Røed, Kjetill S. Jakobsen, Love Dalén, Brage B. Hansen and Michael D. Martin, 1 September 2023, iScience.
DOI: 10.1016/j.isci.2023.107811

2 Comments on "A Genetic Paradox: Inbreeding Can Be Beneficial in the Long Run"

  1. “Inbreeding Can Be Beneficial in the Long Run”

    This isn’t news to dog breeders.

  2. The riendeer will be fine. The sun’s gonna take a nap around 2030 for the next decade or so. Warming isn’t on the agenda.

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.