Evolutionary Origin of the Human Hand Revealed by Ancient Fish Fossil

An ancient fossil found in Canada reveals new insights into how the human hand evolved from fish fins.

An ancient Elpistostege fish fossil found in Miguasha, Canada has revealed new insights into how the human hand evolved from fish fins.

An international team of paleontologists from Flinders University in Australia and Universite du Quebec a Rimouski in Canada have revealed the fish specimen, as described in the journal Nature, has yielded the missing evolutionary link in the fish to tetrapod transition, as fish began to foray in habitats such as shallow water and land during the Late Devonian period millions of years ago.

This complete 1.57 meter long fish shows the complete arm (pectoral fin) skeleton for the first time in any elpistostegalian fish. Using high energy CT-scans, the skeleton of the pectoral fin revealed the presence of a humerus (arm), radius and ulna (forearm), rows of carpus (wrist) and phalanges organized in digits (fingers).

Complete E. watsoni Specimen

Complete specimen in dorsal view. Scale bar, 1 m. b, Camera lucida drawing of the postcranial anatomy of the specimen; pectoral fins have been illustrated in their position, although they are only visible ventrally. c, Reconstruction. an.fi, anal fin; cau.fi, caudal fin; op, opercular; pec.fi, pectoral fin; pel.fi, pelvic fin. Credit: Nature

“Today we announce in the journal Nature our discovery of a complete specimen of a tetrapod-like fish, called Elpistostege, which reveals extraordinary new information about the evolution of the vertebrate hand,” says Strategic Professor in Palaeontology at Flinders University Professor John Long.

“This is the first time that we have unequivocally discovered fingers locked in a fin with fin-rays in any known fish. The articulating digits in the fin are like the finger bones found in the hands of most animals.”

“This finding pushes back the origin of digits in vertebrates to the fish level, and tells us that the patterning for the vertebrate hand was first developed deep in evolution, just before fishes left the water.”

The evolution of fishes into tetrapods — four-legged vertebrates of which humans belong — was one of the most significant events in the history of life.

Vertebrates (back-boned animals) were then able to leave the water and conquer land. In order to complete this transition, one of the most significant changes was the evolution of hands and feet.

In order to understand the evolution from a fish fin to a tetrapod limb, paleontologists study the fossils of lobe-finned fish and tetrapods from the Middle and Upper Devonian (393-359 million years ago) known as ‘elpistostegalians.’

These include the well-known Tiktaalik from Arctic Canada, known only from incomplete specimens.

Comparative Anatomy Stem-Tetrapod Fish and Early Tetrapod

Comparison of the anatomy of the pectoral limb endoskeleton (a) and humerus (b) of stem-tetrapod fish (Panderichthys, Tiktaalik and Elpistostege) and an early tetrapod (Tulerpeton). Proximodistal rows of radials or digits are shown color-coded according to the scheme in Fig. 4. Red arrows in b indicate the ectepicondyle. Panderichthys data are from ref. 13; Tiktaalik data are from ref. 4; Acanthostega data are from ref. 26; Tulerpeton data are from ref. 31. Images in b are modified from ref. 49. art.sf, articulation surfaces; lat.dor, attachment ridges for latissimus dorsi muscles; sup.rid, supinator ridge; rd.ext, attachment area for radial extensors; scap- hum., attachment area for scapula and humeral muscles. Credit: Nature

Co-author Richard Cloutier from Universite du Quebec a Rimouski says over the past decade, fossils informing the fish-to-tetrapod transition have helped to better understand anatomical transformations associated with breathing, hearing, and feeding, as the habitat changed from water to land on Earth.

“The origin of digits relates to developing the capability for the fish to support its weight in shallow water or for short trips out on land. The increased number of small bones in the fin allows more planes of flexibility to spread out its weight through the fin. ”

“The other features the study revealed concerning the structure of the upper arm bone or humerus, which also shows features present that are shared with early amphibians. Elpistostege is not necessarily our ancestor, but it is closest we can get to a true ‘transitional fossil,’ an intermediate between fishes and tetrapods.”

Elpistostege was the largest predator living in a shallow marine to estuarine habitat of Quebec about 380 million years ago. It had powerful sharp fangs in its mouth so could have fed upon several of the larger extinct lobe-finned fishes found fossilized in the same deposits.

Background

Elpistostege was originally named from just a small part of the skull roof, found in the fossiliferous cliffs of Miguasha National Park, Quebec, and described in 1938 as belonging to an early tetrapod.

Another part of the skull of this enigmatic beast was found and described in 1985, demonstrating it was really an advanced lobe-finned fish. The remarkable new complete specimen of Elpistostege was discovered in 2010.

Meticulous preparation of the new specimen and CT scanning of the fossil took place in Quebec in 2010 with Prof Cloutier working with Isabelle Bechard to do the initial interpretation of the scan data, and Vincent Roy and Roxanne Noel to analyze the backbone and fin structures.

Reference: “Elpistostege and the origin of the vertebrate hand” by Richard Cloutier, Alice M. Clement, Michael S. Y. Lee, Roxanne Noël, Isabelle Béchard, Vincent Roy and John A. Long, 18 March 2020, Nature.
DOI: 10.1038/s41586-020-2100-8

Collaboration with Prof John Long and the Flinders University team began in 2014. Dr Alice Clement continued the CT work which revealed details of the digits in the fin. Prof Mike Lee analysed the phylogenetic data to demonstrate that Elpistostege is now the most evolutionary ‘advanced’ fish known, one node down on the evolutionary tree to all tetrapods. The research was completed in 2019 when Prof Richard Cloutier spent 6 months on sabbatical working as a Flinders University Visiting International Fellow.

This study was funded by a Research Laboratory in Palaeontology and Evolutionary Biology at UQAR (Power Corporation Inc.). We thank the Parc national de Miguasha (MHNM) for the loan of the specimen and the special opportunity to work on this material.

1 Comment on "Evolutionary Origin of the Human Hand Revealed by Ancient Fish Fossil"

  1. Every species on Earth has evolved in the same moment independently having nothing to do with each other conform to the position that hierarchically and anarchically to each one belongs. But the species continue changing each other moment after moment dependently in cooperation evolutionary and revolutionary in the same moment but absolutely in the way they were initially evolved. The resemblance of the species is result of their hierarchically and anarchically position that each one chanced to be evolved.
    The theory that species has derived from each other is totally wrong.

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.