Large Parts of Europe Warming Twice As Fast as the Planet – Already Surpassed 2°C

Warming in Europe

Left and right figures show warming in Europe of the summer half-year during the latest four decades, subdivided for clear-sky and conditions, respectively. Credit: Paul Glantz/Stockholm University

The warming during the summer months in Europe has been much faster than the global average, shows a new study published in the Journal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres. As a consequence of human emissions of greenhouse gases, the climate across the continent has also become drier, particularly in southern Europe, leading to worse heat waves and an increased risk of fires.

According to the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), warming over land areas occurs significantly faster than over oceans, with 1.6 degrees Celsius and 0.9 degrees Celsius on average, respectively. It means that the global greenhouse gas emissions budget to stay under a 1.5-degree Celsius warming on land has already been used up. Now, a new study by researchers at Stockholm University shows that the emissions budget to avoid a 2-degree Celsius warming over large parts of Europe during the summer half-year (April-September) has also been used up. In fact, measurements reveal that the warming during the summer months in large parts of Europe during the last four decades has already surpassed two degrees Celsius .

Drier Climate Southern Europa

Left and right figures show changes in sensible and latent heat fluxes, respectively, in Europe during the latest four decades of the summer half year. Credit: Paul Glantz/Stockholm University

“Climate change is serious as it leads to, among other things, more frequent heat waves in Europe. These, in turn, increase the risk of fires, such as the devastating fires in southern Europe in the summer of 2022,” says Paul Glantz, Associate Professor at the Department of Environmental Science, Stockholm University, and main author of the study.
In southern Europe, a clear, so-called, positive feedback caused by global warming is evident, i.e. warming is amplified due to drier soil and decreased evaporation.  Moreover, there has been less cloud coverage over large parts of Europe, probably as a result of less water vapor in the air.

“What we see in southern Europe is in line with what IPCC has predicted, which is that an increased human impact on the greenhouse effect would lead to dry areas on Earth becoming even drier,” says Paul Glantz.

Less Clouds in Europe

Left and right figures show decrease in clouds in Europe during the latest four decades, for the summer half year, with respect to low level clouds and total amount of clouds throughout the atmosphere, respectively. Credit: Paul Glantz/Stockholm University

Impact of aerosol particles

The study also includes a section about the estimated impact of aerosol particles on the temperature increase. According to Paul Glantz, the rapid warming in, for example, Central and Eastern Europe, is first and foremost a consequence of the human emissions of long-lived greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide. But since emissions of short-lived aerosol particles from, for example, coal-fired power plants have decreased greatly over the past four decades, the combined effect has led to an extreme temperature increase of over two degrees Celsius.

Coal Mining and Power Plants

Coal power plants on earth emit over 12 Gt of carbon dioxide each year, nearly one-third of the total emissions of carbon dioxide. Coal power plants constitute therefore the single largest source of global warming. Coal power plants emit also sulfur dioxide that forms aerosols in the atmosphere. Coal power plants have decreased and increased substantially in Europe and East Asia, respectively, during the latest four decades. Credit: Tomasz Matuszewski/Mostphotos

“The airborne aerosol particles, before they began to decrease in the early 1980s in Europe, have masked the warming caused by human greenhouse gases by just over one degree on average for the summer half-year. As the aerosols in the atmosphere decreased, the temperature increased rapidly. Human emissions of carbon dioxide are still the biggest threat as they affect the climate for hundreds to thousands of years,” says Paul Glantz.

According to Paul Glantz, this effect provides a harbinger of future warming in areas where aerosol emissions are high, such as in India and China.

Wildfires Global Warming

Warming and consequently drier conditions in Europe, particularly for southern countries, higher the risk for fires. In the report “Spreading like wildfires: the rising threat of extraordinary landscape fires,” by UN Environmental Program (UNEP) and GRID-Arendal (a UNEP partner) in 2022, conclude that climate change and land-use change are making wildfires worse. The report anticipates a global increase of extreme fires, even in areas previously unaffected. Credit: Ryhor Bruyeu/Mostphotos

Background facts — The greenhouse effect and aerosol effect

Fossil burning leads to the release of both aerosol particles and greenhouse gases. Although their source is common, their effects on climate differ.

Paul Glantz

Paul Glantz, Associate Professor at the Department of Environmental Science, Stockholm University, and main author of the study. Credit: Stockholm University

About the greenhouse effect

Greenhouse gases are largely unaffected by solar radiation while they absorb infrared radiation efficiently, leading to re-emission towards the Earth’s surface. The Earth absorbs both solar radiation and infrared radiation, which leads to the warming of the lower part of the atmosphere in particular.

Time-space: Greenhouse gases are generally long-lived in the atmosphere and this applies above all to carbon dioxide where human emissions affect climate for hundreds to thousands of years. It also means that greenhouse gases spread evenly over the entire planet.

About the aerosol effect

In contrast to greenhouse gases, aerosol particles affect incoming solar radiation, i.e. they scatter part of the sunlight back into space causing a cooling effect. Human emissions of aerosols can enhance this cooling effect.

Time-space: Airborne human aerosol particles have a lifetime of about a week, which means that they mainly cool the climate locally or regionally and in the short term.

According to the Paris Agreement, all parties must commit to drastically reduce their greenhouse gas emissions, but it is also important to decrease concentrations of aerosol particles as well because, in addition to their effects on climate, aerosol particles in polluted air cause approximately eight million premature deaths each year around the world.

Reference: “Unmasking the Effects of Aerosols on Greenhouse Warming Over Europe” by P. Glantz, O. G. Fawole, J. Ström, M. Wild and K. J. Noone, 4 November 2022, Journal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres.
DOI: 10.1029/2021JD035889

Funding: Svenska Forskningsrådet Formas (Formas)

3 Comments on "Large Parts of Europe Warming Twice As Fast as the Planet – Already Surpassed 2°C"

  1. An inquiring mind would be concerned why the warming appears so localized when the claimed cause is a well-mixed gas.

    “The airborne aerosol particles … have masked the warming caused by human greenhouse gases …” I think that the choice of the word “masked” is misleading. It implies that the warming has taken place, but we can’t perceive or measure it. I think that it would be more accurate to say that the aerosols have prevented warming that would otherwise have taken place. That is, the warming has not been hidden, it hasn’t taken place! Perhaps this is an innocent mistake made by someone for whom English is a second language. However, words are important, and for a topic as important as this, there should be a competent technical editor correcting poor writing.

    Personally, I think that the role of clouds is not given the attention that it deserves. Clouds are also the weakest link in the “based on science” Global Circulation Models, which have to be parameterized because of computational restrictions. The subjective parameterization provides considerable opportunity for personal biases to creep in.

  2. Rudolf Shepherd | November 27, 2022 at 5:59 pm | Reply

    Well there you go then. Humanity just needs to unite in order to release more aerosols. Someone just needs to set a target. How many tons do we need to emit? Climate change emergency catastrophe averted.

  3. Isn’t that where the war is?

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.