Medicines Aren’t Very Effective for IBS: Scientists Found What Works Better

Stomach Pain Stomachache IBS

A recent study examined the effectiveness of three different treatments for IBS, revealing that dietary adjustments, particularly those low in FODMAPs and carbohydrates, are more effective in reducing symptoms compared to medication.

Dietary treatment is more effective than medications in irritable bowel syndrome (IBS). These are the findings of a study conducted at the University of Gothenburg. With dietary adjustments, more than seven out of ten patients had significantly reduced symptoms.

Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) is a common diagnosis that causes abdominal pain, gas abdominal bloating, diarrhea, and constipation, in various combinations and with varying degrees of severity.

Treatment often consists of dietary advice such as eating small and frequent meals and avoiding excessive intake of food triggers such as coffee, alcohol and fizzy drinks. Patients may also be given medications to improve specific symptoms, such as gas or constipation, diarrhea, bloating or abdominal pain. Antidepressants are sometimes used to improve symptoms in IBS.

The current study, published in The Lancet Gastroenterology & Hepatology, compared three treatments: two dietary and one based on use of medications. The participants were adult patients with severe or moderate IBS symptoms at Sahlgrenska University Hospital in Gothenburg.

More Symptom Relief After Dietary Adjustment

The first group was given traditional IBS dietary advice, focusing on eating behavior combined with low intake of fermentable carbohydrates, known as FODMAPs. These include e.g. products with lactose, legumes, onions, and grains, which ferment in the colon and can cause pain in IBS.

The second group received a dietary treatment low in carbohydrates and proportionally high in protein and fat. In the third group, the best possible medication was given based on the patient’s most troublesome IBS symptoms.

Each group included around 100 participants and the treatment periods lasted four weeks. When the researchers then examined how well the participants responded to the treatments, using an established IBS symptom scoring scale, the results were clear.

Sanna Nybacka, Stine Störsrud and Magnus Simrén

Sanna Nybacka, Stine Störsrud and Magnus Simrén, Sahlgrenska Academy at the University of Gothenburg. Credit: Photo by Margareta G. Kubista), Malin Arnesson and Johan Wingborg

Of those who received traditional IBS dietary advice and low content of FODMAPs, 76% had significantly reduced symptoms. In the group receiving low carbohydrates and high protein and fat, the proportion was 71%, and in the medication group 58%.

All groups reported significantly better quality of life, less physical symptoms, and less symptoms of anxiety and depression.

The Importance of Personalization

At a six-month follow-up, when participants in the dietary groups had partially returned to their previous eating habits, a large proportion still had clinically significant symptom relief; 68% in the traditional dietary advice and low FODMAP group, and 60% in the low-carbohydrate diet group.

The study was led by Sanna Nybacka, Researcher and Dietician, Stine Störsrud, Associate Professor, and Magnus Simrén, Professor and Senior Consultant, all at Sahlgrenska Academy, University of Gothenburg.

“With this study, we can show that diet plays a central role in the treatment of IBS, but that there are several alternative treatments that are effective,” says Sanna Nybacka.

“We need more knowledge about how to best personalize the treatment of IBS in the future and we will further investigate whether there are certain factors that can predict whether individuals will respond better to different treatment options,” she concludes.

Reference: “A low FODMAP diet plus traditional dietary advice versus a low-carbohydrate diet versus pharmacological treatment in irritable bowel syndrome (CARBIS): a single-centre, single-blind, randomised controlled trial” by Sanna Nybacka, Hans Törnblom, Axel Josefsson, Johann P Hreinsson, Lena Böhn, Åsa Frändemark, Cecilia Weznaver, Stine Störsrud and Magnus Simrén, 18 April 2024, The Lancet Gastroenterology & Hepatology.
DOI: 10.1016/S2468-1253(24)00045-1

1 Comment on "Medicines Aren’t Very Effective for IBS: Scientists Found What Works Better"

  1. Now that the low FODMAP diet plus IBS dietary advice and the low carbohydrate diet showed improvement of symptoms, and the medication arm somewhat less so, it would be interesting to see if a low FODMAP diet plus dietary advice plus medication could relieve symptoms even more.

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.