New research suggests that while remote and hybrid working arrangements can enhance employees’ work-life balance, they may also be hindering innovation.
While remote and hybrid working arrangements can enhance employees’ work-life balance, new research suggests they might be hindering innovation.
The study, led by University of Essex and University of Chicago economists, found that staff who worked in a hybrid model were less likely to come up with innovative ideas than colleagues who always worked in the office. And staff working from home tended to produce lower quality innovative ideas than those who always worked in the office.
“Innovation in the workplace can occur through random, spontaneous ‘watercooler’ conversations between employees,” explained lead researcher Dr Christoph Siemroth. “However, these ‘productive accidents’ are less likely to occur when employees work from home. Our research has found that innovation is suffering as a result.”
Post-pandemic, many firms are hesitant to implement a full-time return to working from the office and have adopted a hybrid model, where employees get the best of both worlds, spending some days in the office and some at home.
Research Findings and Recommendations
Many business leaders have voiced concerns over innovation suffering with these new work modes. This new research, published in the journal Scientific Reports, finds their concerns could be valid.
“Of course, this cost to innovation may be acceptable, given the significant benefits for employees in terms of work-life balance, which makes more flexible employers more attractive,” added Dr Siemroth, from Essex’s Department of Economics.
“Our findings imply that companies should take steps to coordinate when employees are in the office. Innovation does not work well if half the team is in on Mondays while the other half is in on Wednesdays. Instead, set days where the whole team is expected in the office. While this limits the flexibility of hybrid work, our results suggest that innovation benefits as a result.”
The study followed over 48,000 employees from a large Indian IT company during periods of working from the office, working from home, and hybrid working. Innovation is not a core part of their work, but the company has taken significant steps to instill a culture in which all employees see innovation as a key part of their job, with the company offering financial rewards to foster innovation at work.
The employees write up ideas about process improvements, cost-saving measures, or new products, which are then evaluated by the company and either implemented or discarded.
Whilst the quantity of ideas did not change during the working from home period compared to working in the office, the quality of ideas suffered. During the later hybrid period, the quantity of submitted ideas fell and innovation suffered, particularly in teams which did not coordinate when they worked at the office or from home.
Reference: “Employee innovation during office work, work from home and hybrid work” by Michael Gibbs, Friederike Mengel and Christoph Siemroth, 24 July 2024, Scientific Reports.
DOI: 10.1038/s41598-024-67122-6
Never miss a breakthrough: Join the SciTechDaily newsletter.
Follow us on Google and Google News.
3 Comments
Oh no, who knows what kind of ‘innovations’ we’ve missed out on in the field of ‘literally breathing down employees neck’, etc.
This is interesting. I have also seen scientific studies that found that the idea of the “water cooler breakthrough” is largely a myth. As long as remote workers are highly engaged with the members of their teams, which assumes an intelligent and thorough investment in technologies that support remote collaborative work, workers are more productive and innovative because they are happier, healthier, and less stressed.
Thank God for that! We could do a few centuries without innovations. Let’s first get used to the innovations we’re already having in the civilization, and figure out how to deal with their negative social and ecological impact – and then maybe think about starting another batch of innovations.