Personal Experience of Climate Change May Influence Opinion of It

Global Warming Climate Change Concept

A new study suggests that people worldwide are observing and accurately detecting changes in their local climates, providing the first global evidence for this phenomenon. Researchers believe this finding could have significant implications for efforts to combat climate change.

A study from scientists at Yale University examined the extent to which 91,000 individuals in 89 countries on five continents detected recent changes in average local temperatures, finding that public opinion of climate change may shift in response to the personal experience of climate change.

Human beings around the world are observing and accurately detecting changes in their local climates, according to a new study led by Yale University researchers. The finding provides the first global evidence for the phenomenon and could have meaningful implications for attempts to combat climate change, they said.

“We wanted to see if people have accurately detected the signal of a changing climate through their own local experience,” said Peter D. Howe, a postdoctoral associate at Yale and lead author of the study. “We found that many have noticed local changes, which may influence public responses to climate change in coming years.”

Published in Nature Climate Change, the study is based on Gallup World Poll surveys of about 91,000 individuals in 89 countries on five continents.

They were asked: “Over the past five years, would you say that the average annual temperatures in your local area have gotten warmer, colder, or stayed about the same?” Researchers at Yale, Columbia, and Princeton Universities then matched responses to the survey with data on respondents’ local climate conditions.

The researchers found that perceptions tended to match reality — people who reported that their local area was getting warmer were indeed experiencing temperatures over the previous 6 to 12 months that were relatively higher, on average, than those experienced by people who reported that their local area was getting colder or had stayed the same.

The study also found that respondents’ perceptions were influenced by recent weather. If surveyed during the local warm season, people were 11 to 19 percent more likely to believe that local temperatures were rising over the long term than they were when questioned during a cool period.

Even after controlling for geographic, demographic, and seasonal effects, however, the study found that an increase of 1 degree Celsius (1.8 degrees Fahrenheit) above the long-term local average was associated with a 7 to 12 percent increase in the likelihood that people would report that their local area was getting warmer.

The paper appeared in Nature Climate Change in December. The Gallup World Poll was conducted in 2007 and 2008.

Researchers said they could not definitively show a causal relationship between local climatic conditions experienced by respondents and their perceptions. But they concluded that “the logical direction of the effect of changes in temperature on perception, and the lack of an alternative variable that would predict both actual and perceived temperature change suggests that changes in temperature are a causal influence on perceptions.”

Reference: “Global perceptions of local temperature change” by Peter D. Howe, Ezra M. Markowitz, Tien Ming Lee, Chia-Ying Ko and Anthony Leiserowitz, 16 December 2012, Nature Climate Change.
DOI: 10.1038/nclimate1768

Other authors are: Anthony Leiserowitz (Yale); Ezra M. Markowitz (Princeton); Tien Ming Lee (Columbia); and Chia-Ying Ko (Yale).

The National Science Foundation provided support for the project.

1 Comment on "Personal Experience of Climate Change May Influence Opinion of It"

  1. Even within my own family, although we agree that on average, temperatures are rising, we hold opposing feelings regarding the phenomenon. I can’t stand hot, humid summers and in winter, I love snow, but hate slush, freezing rain and ice. I’d rather have cooler, drier summers and colder winters. My father is the opposite. The warmer the better. Our own household is divided on the issue of climate change and we don’t discuss it in order to keep the peace.

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.