A clinical trial has found no evidence of a link between adenotonsillectomies and unwanted weight gain in children.
A recent study led by Michigan Medicine researchers challenges the long-standing belief that adenotonsillectomy—a surgery to remove the tonsils and adenoids—causes excessive weight gain in children with mild sleep-disordered breathing.
The findings were published in JAMA Otolaryngology–Head & Neck Surgery.
Adenotonsillectomy is a widely successful procedure for alleviating symptoms of mild sleep-disordered breathing in children, offering significant improvements in their condition.
Mild sleep-disordered breathing occurs when children have obstructive sleep apnea symptoms but no clear obstructive sleep apnea on sleep lab testing.
The Pediatric Adenotonsillectomy Trial for Snoring included 458 children with mild sleep-disordered breathing, randomized into two groups: those who underwent adenotonsillectomy and those who received “watchful waiting with supportive care.”
The overall results of PATS showed that adenotonsillectomy didn’t result in a statistically significant improvement in primary neurodevelopmental outcomes, but did result in improvement in certain secondary outcomes, such as symptoms, blood pressure and quality of life.
This latest paper uses data from the trial to test the assertion that unwanted weight gain is a potential side effect of the procedure.
Examining Weight Gain Assumptions
“For many years, tonsillectomy causing weight gain in kids was a common assumption based on early studies with little control data,” said Erin Kirkham, M.D., M.P.H., FACS, a pediatric otolaryngologist at U-M’s C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital and lead author on the study.
“It turns out kids who are overweight tend to gain more weight over time regardless of whether or not they’ve had surgery for sleep apnea. Previously, we were seeing a natural trajectory of weight gain—that was going to happen anyway—and attributing it to surgery.”
Weight and sleep-disordered breathing in children are interrelated.
Children with obesity are more likely than other children to develop symptoms.
In addition, underweight patients who are failing to thrive due to their sleep-disordered breathing can experience a desired weight gain after adenotonsillectomy.
Researchers believe that such “catch up” weight gain among children in past studies also contributed to the perception that adenotonsillectomies could cause undesirable weight gain.
Grouping underweight children in with normal and overweight children made it seem as if the group as a whole gained weight after surgery.
A previous paper from the same research team using data from a different randomized trial involving children with obstructive sleep apnea, “Weight gain in children after adenotonsillectomy: undesirable weight gain or catch-up growth?” appeared in Sleep Medicine in 2021 and concluded, “Adenotonsillectomy may not be an independent risk factor for undesirable weight gain in children.”
Key Findings from the PATS Trial
For the PATS trial, researchers defined undesirable weight gain in two ways: underweight or normal-weight children who became overweight after 12 months, and already overweight children who continued to gain weight in the same span.
Undesirable weight gain occurred after 12 months in 32% of cases from the adenotonsillectomy group (120 children), versus 27% of the watchful waiting group (101 children).
A regression analysis did not find a significant association between adenotonsillectomy and undesirable weight gain.
“The upshot is that if you’re a sleep specialist—or an otolaryngologist considering taking out a child’s tonsils—you don’t have to worry families as much by saying, ‘There’s an obesity epidemic, and if you choose surgery, it could increase the risk of obesity for your child,’” said Ronald D. Chervin, M.D., M.S., Michael S. Aldrich Collegiate Professor of Sleep Medicine at U-M, director of its Sleep Disorders Center and senior author on the paper.
The authors note, however, that nearly a third of the participants did experience unwanted weight gain, even if adenotonsillectomy was not the cause.
They emphasize that there’s an opportunity for clinicians to encourage healthy weight management when they see overweight children with mild sleep-disordered breathing.
Reference: “Weight Gain After Adenotonsillectomy in Children With Mild Obstructive Sleep-Disordered Breathing: Exploratory Analysis of the PATS Randomized Clinical Trial” by Erin M. Kirkham, Stacey Ishman, Cristina M. Baldassari, Ron B. Mitchell, S. Kamal Naqvi, Ignacio E. Tapia, Lisa M. Elden, Fauziya Hassan, Sally Ibrahim, Kristie Ross, Mengqi Cen, Rui Wang, Susan Redline and Ronald D. Chervin, 22 August 2024, JAMA Otolaryngology–Head & Neck Surgery.
DOI: 10.1001/jamaoto.2024.2554
The study was funded by the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute.
Never miss a breakthrough: Join the SciTechDaily newsletter.
Follow us on Google and Google News.
1 Comment
As another good example of a medical study with a fatally-flawed basis, this article also provides me with a rare opportunity to share a theory of mine on the long-term harm of appendectomies and tonsillectomies.
Having had an emergency appendectomy at age thirteen followed with rapid weight gain and mysterious other conditions as a young adult, mostly seemingly “normal,” then, I had rapid hair loss following chronic tonsillitis and an adult tonsillectomy about age twenty-five, while being trained as an industrial electrician. I didn’t learn of my being something of a ‘worse’ but not ‘worst’ case scenario of multiple very, very mild food allergies, that my four siblings weren’t, until age thirty-seven.
I now formally postulate that the appendix and tonsils interact in a kind of ‘feedback loop’ that, generally, allows children to ‘outgrow’ their childhood allergies. As to the childhood sleep apnea which I never had, I now suspect that it results from very, very mild childhood food allergies being aggravated (extended and/or intensified) by allergenic and/or toxic FDA approved food additives such as soy, TBHQ and added MSG, minimally. Again here, as commented elsewhere, until mainstream medicine factors-in my (Dr. Arthur F. Coca’s, by 1935) kind of food allergies, aggravated (or not) with FDA approved food poisoning and/or excessive related/resultant medical errors, no cohort study will be entirely valid. And, much of humanity will continue to needlessly suffer cheaply and easily avoided illnesses and complications as adults.