
Scientists using NASA’s Curiosity rover have discovered siderite—an iron carbonate—in the sulfate-rich rocks of Gale Crater, solving a long-standing mystery about Mars’ missing carbonates.
This find provides powerful new clues about the planet’s ancient atmosphere and supports theories that it once harbored conditions suitable for liquid water. The discovery challenges previous satellite data and suggests that more carbon may be hidden below the Martian surface or lost to space.
Rethinking Mars’ Ancient Atmosphere
Scientists have long believed that Mars once had a thick, carbon dioxide-rich atmosphere and flowing liquid water on its surface. According to that theory, the CO2 and water should have reacted with the planet’s rocks to form carbonate minerals. But until recently, surface analyses by rovers and orbital instruments using near-infrared spectroscopy hadn’t detected the expected levels of carbonate.
Now, new findings reported in Science reveal otherwise. Data from three drill sites examined by NASA’s Curiosity rover show the presence of siderite—an iron-based carbonate mineral—within sulfate-rich rock layers on Mount Sharp, located in Gale Crater.

A Surprising Find Beneath the Surface
“The discovery of abundant siderite in Gale Crater represents both a surprising and important breakthrough in our understanding of the geologic and atmospheric evolution of Mars,” said Benjamin Tutolo, associate professor at the University of Calgary, Canada, and lead author of the paper.
To investigate the mineral composition of the Martian surface, Curiosity drills a few centimeters into the ground and collects powdered rock samples. These samples are analyzed by CheMin, an onboard instrument developed by NASA’s Ames Research Center. CheMin uses X-ray diffraction to determine the mineral structure of the rocks, with further analysis carried out by scientists at NASA’s Johnson Space Center in Houston.

X-Ray Insights into Ancient Mars
“Drilling through the layered Martian surface is like going through a history book,” said Thomas Bristow, research scientist at NASA Ames and coauthor of the paper. “Just a few centimeters down gives us a good idea of the minerals that formed at or close to the surface around 3.5 billion years ago.”
The discovery of this carbonate mineral in rocks beneath the surface suggests that carbonate may be masked by other minerals in near-infrared satellite analysis. If other sulfate-rich layers across Mars also contain carbonates, the amount of stored carbon dioxide would be a fraction of that needed in the ancient atmosphere to create conditions warm enough to support liquid water. The rest could be hidden in other deposits or have been lost to space over time.

What’s Next for Mars Exploration
In the future, missions or analyses of other sulfate-rich areas on Mars could confirm these findings and help us better understand the planet’s early history and how it transformed as its atmosphere was lost.
Explore Further: NASA’s Curiosity Rover Digs Up a Carbon Time Capsule on Mars
Reference: “Carbonates identified by the Curiosity rover indicate a carbon cycle operated on ancient Mars” by Benjamin M. Tutolo, Elisabeth M. Hausrath, Edwin S. Kite, Elizabeth B. Rampe, Thomas F. Bristow, Robert T. Downs, Allan Treiman, Tanya S. Peretyazhko, Michael T. Thorpe, John P. Grotzinger, Amelie L. Roberts, P. Douglas Archer, David J. Des Marais, David F. Blake, David T. Vaniman, Shaunna M. Morrison, Steve Chipera, Robert M. Hazen, Richard V. Morris, Valerie M. Tu, Sarah L. Simpson, Aditi Pandey, Albert Yen, Stephen R. Larter, Patricia Craig, Nicholas Castle, Douglas W. Ming, Johannes M. Meusburger, Abigail A. Fraeman, David G. Burtt, Heather B. Franz, Brad Sutter, Joanna V. Clark, William Rapin, John C. Bridges, Matteo Loche, Patrick Gasda, Jens Frydenvang and Ashwin R. Vasavada, 17 April 2025, Science.
DOI: 10.1126/science.ado9966
Curiosity is a car-sized rover that’s part of NASA’s Mars Exploration Program (MEP), designed to explore the geology and climate of Mars and assess whether the planet ever had conditions suitable for life. The rover was built by NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL), which is managed by Caltech in Pasadena, California. JPL also leads the mission operations on behalf of NASA’s Science Mission Directorate in Washington. Since landing in Gale Crater in 2012, Curiosity has been using advanced instruments to analyze Martian rocks, soil, and atmosphere, providing key insights into the planet’s ancient environment and its potential habitability.
Never miss a breakthrough: Join the SciTechDaily newsletter.
41 Comments
Lmao 🤣 Public education is a disgrace. People that be-LIE-ve NASA has gone anywhere but a fish tank and the desert have mud between their ears
Education definitely failed you – so dumb and yet so confident
Well said .
So exciting to view these newly released Rover Findings on Mars!!!! The crystals and level of carbonate…this is so important for future generations
How is this so important to our future generation, when we, as a species are busy ignoring our own destruction of our own planet? Money should have been spent on our own survival here on Earth, not Mars the fossilized dead planet.
The money spent to explore Mars is billions over decades, while research on climate change (and fighting it( is now trillions per year.
And what have you done with your life to disprove them. To me there is no difference in blindly believing someone else work as taking the English version of the Bible literally. Either way. You have done nothing in your life that should let you condem or promote research done by others. And to truly believe it is all done on earth is ignorance on your part. Ignorance comes in many ways. Get off your ass and do some research yourself before you condem or promote either theory. It’s so easy to piggy back on someone else’s research or faith and call it your own. But that’s just lazy and puts you in the same boat as everyone else who says their beliefs are right and all others are stupid or easily manipulated. Both sides are idiots. Only those who get off their ass and do any kind of research deserve to state their findings. Even they should only state the findings. Not the beliefs in what they MAY lead to.
I know a place where all the equipment is staged On Earth, I also thought it was Mars. Till no one was allowed to go to that place making me curious why then only to find out, that was happening
Where’s it at?
The pictures taken by the rovers are real. Some details may be lost because of stitching frames together but they are real, and they are from MARS.
The planet is literally littered with fossils, most belonging to the “glass” sponge-like organisms that are marine in origin (on Earth), and liv are associated with moderately deep , and extremely deep
water.
I think spock from star treck could still be regenerated and have a spock baby there so make more movies and we could dream of the answer
Mike, you’re a disgrace and example of someone who doesn’t apply themselves in public education then blames the system. You probably have a problem accepting responsibility for your own actions throughout life. Probably expect the rest of us to pay your student loans off too.
What if one of Mars’ secrets is : Mars had a moon, considerably bigger and in a stable orbit , 3.8 billion years ago. The tidal forces within Mars’ would begin to support the theory of a thicker atmosphere, liquid water on the surface , a protective magnetic shield and finally an active metallically molten core/volcanic. Maybe Phobos and Deimos are remnants of this larger moon theory 🤔 ?
I bet you are a flat earther too. In my opinion you are an idiot.
I love it when people are so confidently wrong.
Wondering if Mike has any proof of his conspiracy theory.
Yes, but just more conspiracy theories….but Elon Musk/SpaceX, will soon find out , as he unleashes his Tesla Optimus robots on Mars….Will greatly find out much more , as they start a program for Earth inhabitants of Mars….Or as the conspiracy people would say….Some earth foreign agents….Bent on taking over Mars….
Hope there will be many huge discovery, of minerals/metabolites , of great importance to mankind….Solar panel factories on Mars, to make power cheaply…So there will not be a huge need for proliferation of several small nuclear power plants…
I call this a waste of American tax payere money, they need the money on earth to clean up the mess that they have made here.
From the point of view of scientific development it is all alright. But making and establishing human colonies on Mars is still a far dream, I believe.
Who is “they”? The money spent to put that probe on Mars was collected & used long ago, before you were born. You needn’t worry that your minor involvement might have ended the program if you had something to say about it.
They/them… we’re not allowed to use he/she anymore.
Nope, he don’t.
I don’t think there are any fish tanks on Mars
Nat science just imaginations , planet constant relationship with their Sun, were how they are designed. Meaning in our own solar system only one planet earth sustain life. The other planets are component parts supporting earth. So we need to find another solar system with planetaries similar to ours that one planet member may sustain life for us, or to be together with living things already existed there. Solar systems are universal sovereigns. There may be solar planets somewhere for us to homestead.
Or it’s a dead solar system already, earth is actually not real cause we’re in a simulation, and we’re already on Mars . Or underneath it. Maybe thats what people actually mean when they say flat earth, as in flat plane (with holographic reflectors (where this sleep chamber/pyramid would be located in middle) and around that is maybe an actual sphere . Cause why would Venus and Mars be torched by our sun but earth is water and green and missed that and all the comets. That hit the moon so much that has craters all over it. That never happens, because we would see asteroids and debris smashing into it. Because hole in ozone layer would mean earth would in fact look like Venus or Mars, which is probably some approximation of what happened. And Jupiter or Saturn are not planets (just look at them, they look too engineered and unlikely in appearance overall) but the sun, or surrounding the sun as Dyson swarm , as its red dwarf and wouldn’t have to live within it too harness energy if you have self replicating technology that would be able to in some get this unlimited energy without getting too close. That leaves open possibilities that are endless in regards to what base reality is then, if this is simulation. Physics, actual appearance versus representation of planets and solar system, universe, black holes (probably not real but something else) and Venus and Mars could be same planet just combined. Just a thought.
It seems that there are many people who pick and choose what science they want and do not want to believe. One must wonder if the discoveries about the rest of our planets is believed. Do these non-believers believe the composition of our Milky Way or the composition of the other galaxies in our Universe.
Look through a telescope sometime the planets appear just like the pictures.
Interesting Analysis of an Ancient Planet.🌝🌹wondering if that chiseled Doorway Picture on Mars was made by our Creators ..Remember the 📕 📖 📚 Book of 🧬 Genesis 💫 ⭐️ Starts of by saying “Let us Make Them in our Image”So We are all Creators made in Our Creators Image..What happens on Mars now with Exploration is the Creator of Us letting us Use our Human creativity to Build Create&Explore..Whether Humans will ever live on Mars is a Big 🙋♂️ Question as the Wars on Earth 🌎 Will have to ✋ 🛑 Stop..”YAHWEH “He causes to be he cause to become in Ancient Hebrew Language will be the final to decide if Humans will live on Mars as it says in the Ancient 📕 Books 📖 📚 Books Psalms 37:11/The Meek shall inherit the Earth 🌎 Earth etc…
I thought liquid water was a done deal,didn’t they just explore a “river” delta?
Yes…yes they did , also in the bottom of the deeper large asteroid craters , where the sun does not hit….they found ice crystals , under the soil there , and on the poles….So that for some time , has been much of the excitement , around a survivable existence on Mars….As they have the robots , to mine ice crystals , to make potable water , also to make hydrogen/methane fuels , to supply returning rockets from Mars….
Even running many calculations, on available water , from collecting the ice from underground….
I believe the assumption was liquid water and the evidence of liquid something was undeniable but of it being specifically water there was missing the tell tale signs and evidence of water itself.
I’ll go to my Mars and live there
I’m placing my bets on the “water” having come from earth near the hyperpolarization point of our climate change cycles, and fully agree the other planets are components of a system in which only one has the ability and purpose of supporting life.
We are in the process of destroying life on earth. Typical of Homo Sapiens…destroy something, leave it and move on!
Want to subscribe for a daily scitech news
Okay, doctors / scientist , and even mr. Ketamine, know very well that it’s impossible for man to survive the journey to Mars . Your organs will fail
There’s obviously some very inept people that believe what they want. I’ve actually met a group of people that believe the Earth is flat. I don’t argue with them because there’s no sense. If we don’t start stopping the polluting of this planet the ozone layer will deplete even further and we’ll all just have to cover up do not get the radiation from the Sun. I know someone that just died from skin cancer.
I like how they use Gemini AI to create these images and then expect us to believe there’s actually a robot on Mars.
I am very interested Space like it
A hubba dubba dub, a hub dubba frubba, frubba bubba dubba ba dub!
Easy for you to say.