The study, published today (September 23, 2019) in Advanced Theory and Simulations, shows that digital computers cannot reliably reproduce the behavior of ‘chaotic systems’ which are widespread. This fundamental limitation could have implications for high-performance computation (HPC) and for applications of machine learning to HPC.
Professor Peter Coveney, Director of the University College London (UCL) Center for Computational Science and study co-author, said: “Our work shows that the behavior of the chaotic dynamical systems is richer than any digital computer can capture. Chaos is more commonplace than many people may realize and even for very simple chaotic systems, numbers used by digital computers can lead to errors that are not obvious but can have a big impact. Ultimately, computers can’t simulate everything.”
The team investigated the impact of using floating-point arithmetic — a method standardized by the IEEE and used since the 1950s to approximate real numbers on digital computers.
Digital computers use only rational numbers, ones that can be expressed as fractions. Moreover, the denominator of these fractions must be a power of two, such as 2, 4, 8, 16, etc. There are infinitely more real numbers that cannot be expressed this way.
In the present work, the scientists used all four billion of these single-precision floating-point numbers that range from plus to minus infinity. The fact that the numbers are not distributed uniformly may also contribute to some of the inaccuracies.
First author, Professor Bruce Boghosian (Tufts University), said: “The four billion single-precision floating-point numbers that digital computers use are spread unevenly, so there are as many such numbers between 0.125 and 0.25, as there are between 0.25 and 0.5, as there are between 0.5 and 1.0. It is amazing that they are able to simulate real-world chaotic events as well as they do. But even so, we are now aware that this simplification does not accurately represent the complexity of chaotic dynamical systems, and this is a problem for such simulations on all current and future digital computers.”
The study builds on the work of Edward Lorenz of MIT whose weather simulations using a simple computer model in the 1960s showed that tiny rounding errors in the numbers fed into his computer led to quite different forecasts, which is now known as the ‘butterfly effect’.
The team compared the known mathematical reality of a simple one-parameter chaotic system called the ‘generalized Bernoulli map’ to what digital computers would predict if every one of the available single-precision floating-point numbers were used.
They found that, for some values of the parameter, the computer predictions are totally wrong, while for other choices, the calculations may appear correct, but deviate by up to 15%.
The authors say these pathological results would persist even if double-precision floating-point numbers were used, of which there are vastly more to draw on.
“We use the generalized Bernoulli map as a mathematical representation for many other systems that change chaotically over time, such as those seen across physics, biology, and chemistry,” explained Professor Coveney. “These are being used to predict important scenarios in climate change, in chemical reactions, and in nuclear reactors, for example, so it’s imperative that computer-based simulations are now carefully scrutinized.”
The team says that their discovery has implications for the field of artificial intelligence, when machine learning is applied to data derived from computer simulations of chaotic dynamical systems, and for those trying to model all kinds of natural processes.
More research is needed to examine the extent to which the use of floating-point arithmetic is causing problems in everyday computational science and modeling and, if errors are found, how to correct them.
Professor Bruce Boghosian and Dr. Hongyan Wang are at Tufts University, Medford, Massachusetts, United States (Dr Wang now works at Facebook in Seattle). Professor Peter Coveney of UCL is speaking at an event tomorrow in the Science Museum on the future of quantum computing.
Reference: “A New Pathology in the Simulation of Chaotic Dynamical Systems on Digital Computers” by Bruce M. Boghosian, Peter V. Coveney and Hongyan Wang, 23 September 2019, Advanced Theory and Simulations.
The EPSRC, MRC, European Commission, and UCL funded the work.