Long Considered Impossible in Physics: Nonlinear Circuit Harvests Clean Power Using Graphene

Graphene Electricity Materials Science Concept

Researchers have discovered a method to harness energy from ambient heat using graphene, overturning long-established physics theories. This breakthrough holds promising commercial potential, especially for wireless sensors.

The discovery overturns more than a century of physics orthodoxy by identifying a new form of energy that can be extracted from ambient heat using graphene.

Obtaining useful work from random fluctuations in a system at thermal equilibrium has long been considered impossible. In fact, eminent American physicist Richard Feynman effectively shut down further inquiry in the 1960s after he argued in a series of lectures that Brownian motion, or the thermal motion of atoms, cannot perform useful work.

However, Feynman missed something important, as proven in a new study published in the journal Physical Review E titled “Charging capacitors from thermal fluctuations using diodes.”

Three of the paper’s five authors are from the University of Arkansas Department of Physics. According to first author Paul Thibado, their study rigorously proves that thermal fluctuations of freestanding graphene, when connected to a circuit with diodes having nonlinear resistance and storage capacitors, does produce useful work by charging the storage capacitors.

Demonstration of newly discovered nonlinear thermal current generated by diodes. The current’s primary function is to cancel the conventional current to satisfy the second law of thermodynamics. However, the two currents act on different time scales, thereby allowing the storage capacitors to develop a temporary net charge, which can be harvested and stored. Credit: Ben Goodwin

Empirical Evidence Supporting the Discovery

The scientists discovered that when the storage capacitors have an initial charge of zero, the circuit draws power from the thermal environment to charge them. The team then demonstrated that the system satisfies both the first and second laws of thermodynamics throughout the charging process. They also found that larger storage capacitors yield more stored charge and that a smaller graphene capacitance provides both a higher initial rate of charging and a longer time to discharge. These characteristics are important because they allow time to disconnect the storage capacitors from the energy harvesting circuit before the net charge is lost.

This latest publication builds on two of the group’s previous studies. The first was published in a 2016 Physical Review Letters article entitled “Anomalous Dynamical Behavior of Freestanding Graphene Membranes.” In that study, Thibado and his co-authors identified the unique vibrational properties of graphene and its potential for energy harvesting. The second was published in a 2020 Physical Review E article entitled “Fluctuation-induced current from freestanding graphene,” in which they discuss a circuit using graphene that can supply clean, limitless power for small devices or sensors.

This latest study progresses even further by establishing mathematically the design of a circuit capable of gathering energy from the heat of the earth and storing it in capacitors for later use.

“Theoretically, this was what we set out to prove,” Thibado explained. “There are well-known sources of energy, such as kinetic, solar, ambient radiation, acoustic, and thermal gradients. Now there is also nonlinear thermal power. Usually, people imagine that thermal power requires a temperature gradient. That is, of course, an important source of practical power, but what we found is a new source of power that has never existed before. And this new power does not require two different temperatures because it exists at a single temperature.”

In addition to Thibado, co-authors include Pradeep Kumar, John Neu, Surendra Singh, and Luis Bonilla. Kumar and Singh are also physics professors at the University of Arkansas, Neu at the University of California, Berkeley, and Bonilla at Universidad Carlos III de Madrid.

A Decade of Inquiry

The study represents the solution to a problem Thibado has been studying for well over a decade, when he and Kumar first tracked the dynamic movement of ripples in freestanding graphene at the atomic level. Discovered in 2004, graphene is a one-atom-thick sheet of graphite. The duo observed that freestanding graphene has a rippled structure, with each ripple flipping up and down in response to the ambient temperature.

“The thinner something is, the more flexible it is,” Thibado said. “And at only one atom thick, there is nothing more flexible. It’s like a trampoline, constantly moving up and down. If you want to stop it from moving, you have to cool it down to 20 Kelvin.”

His current efforts in the development of this technology are focused on building a device he calls a Graphene Energy Harvester (or GEH). GEH uses a negatively charged sheet of graphene suspended between two metal electrodes. When the graphene flips up, it induces a positive charge in the top electrode. When it flips down, it positively charges the bottom electrode, creating an alternating current. With diodes wired in opposition, allowing the current to flow both ways, separate paths are provided through the circuit, producing a pulsing DC current that performs work on a load resistor.

Commercial Applications

NTS Innovations, a company specializing in nanotechnology, owns the exclusive license to develop GEH into commercial products. Because GEH circuits are so small, mere nanometers in size, they are ideal for mass duplication on silicon chips. When multiple GEH circuits are embedded on a chip in arrays, more power can be produced. They can also operate in many environments, making them particularly attractive for wireless sensors in locations where changing batteries is inconvenient or expensive, such as an underground pipe system or interior aircraft cable ducts.

Donald Meyer, founder and CEO of NTS Innovations, said of Thibado’s latest effort: “Paul’s research reinforces our conviction that we are on the right path with Graphene Energy Harvesting. We appreciate our partnership with the University of Arkansas in bringing this technology to market.”

Ryan McCoy, NTS Innovations’ vice president of sales and marketing, added, “There is broad demand across the electronics industry to shrink form factors and decrease dependency on batteries and wired power. We believe Graphene Energy Harvesting will have a profound impact on both.”

Of the long road to making his latest theoretical breakthrough, Thibado said, “There was always this question out there: ‘If our graphene device is in a really quiet, really dark environment, would it harvest any energy or not?’ The conventional answer to that is no, as it apparently defies the laws of physics. But the physics had never been looked at carefully. I think people were afraid of the topic a bit because of Feynman. So, everybody just said, ‘I’m not touching that.’ But the question just kept demanding our attention. Honestly, its solution was only found through the perseverance and diverse approaches of our unique team.”

Reference: “Charging capacitors from thermal fluctuations using diodes” by P. M. Thibado, J. C. Neu, Pradeep Kumar, Surendra Singh and L. L. Bonilla, 16 August 2023, Physical Review E.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.108.024130

12 Comments on "Long Considered Impossible in Physics: Nonlinear Circuit Harvests Clean Power Using Graphene"

  1. I can’t make heads or tails of this.
    Feynman was hardly the first theoretician to assert that perpetual motion — work done by a system at equilibrium — is not possible.
    Because I do not have access to Phys Rev Letters via any institution, I cannot see what the authors wrote there. Stalemate.

  2. This is a thoretical work. Let experiment judge its validity.

  3. Gemini Musings | August 22, 2023 at 7:00 am | Reply

    Welcome to the “organic” age! Organic energy storage, organic computer chips, zero line-loss transmission lines… the possibilities are endless. Electrical work with no heat; voila!

  4. Is there a possibility that electromagnetic energy is being harvested?

  5. Would it work in an EV ?

  6. Scott Mckinney | August 22, 2023 at 7:25 pm | Reply

    Thank You for Sharing your Studies.Keep up the good work.

  7. Maria Angelica C. Bulay | August 22, 2023 at 7:59 pm | Reply

    If I am a Nonallionaire, I will exhaust all means to investigate why experiments or projects should commence authorized or unauthorized.

    It is Not to challenge scientists or partners-in-business or even the sick of the most greedy of them all.
    Nor to seek to annihilate the entire Cosmos beings.

    What for?? What will make you the Happiest Man anyway??
    Where is it going??

  8. Pain is going on… Pain heart, body, mind and soul.

  9. How much energy is needed to flip the switch? Oh, it’s equal to the energy gained.

  10. While it’s impossible to recover energy from a system in perfect thermal equilibrium, many practical systems probably have significant (but still small) amounts of negentropy that is just difficult to access with classical methods.
    Harvesting that negentropy to power ultra low power devices might very well work, though it wouldn’t be remotely practical as a replacement to classical power sources (at best, its addition to those power sources might bring the efficiency closer to the Carnot limit)

  11. Ok at the risk of seeming dumb I’m just not grasping exactly what they claim to have achieved? Unless I’m missing something “which I’m sure I am” I am willing to bet that when all is said and done they’re not actually netting any useful energy

  12. William Readling | September 7, 2023 at 1:17 pm | Reply

    Classical thermodynamics is a creature of statistics. In the quantum realm, where graphene lives things are quantized, so entropy is a sketchy prospect. Maybe Maxwell’s demons live on flakes of graphene.

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.