“The Most Dramatic Evolutionary Biogeography Story I’ve Ever Seen” – Plant Fossils Reveal Ancient South America-to-Asia “Escape Route”

A Compound Infructescence Fossil Showing Preserved Fruits and Seeds Attached to Branches

A compound infructescence fossil showing preserved fruits and seeds attached to branches. The 52-million-year-old fossil fruits and leaves that the researchers identified as belonging the the Macaranga-Mallotus clade (MMC) of the spurge family suggest that the MMC, long considered to have Asian origins, may have first appeared in Gondwanan South America before spreading around the globe. Credit: Courtesy of Peter Wilf

Newly discovered fossils in Argentina provide evidence that changes in climate and geography may have compelled a well-known species of spurge plants to migrate from southern South America to southeast Asia and beyond.

Those who have embarked on extended journeys by road or bicycle have likely benefitted from a product of the spurge plant family – rubber. The spurge family, also known as Euphorbiaceae, encompasses economically significant plants such as the rubber tree, castor oil plant, poinsettia, and cassava. Now, recently identified fossils in Argentina indicate that these spurges embarked on their own journey several millions of years ago.

Prompted by shifts in climate and terrestrial movements over countless millennia, a group of spurges migrated thousands of miles away from ancient South America, reaching as far as Australia, Asia, and certain regions in Africa, according to research led by Penn State.

Reported in the American Journal of Botany, the findings suggest that the spurge family’s Macaranga-Mallotus clade (MMC), encompassing a common ancestor and all its descendants and long considered to have Asian origins, may have first appeared in South America when it was still part of Gondwana — the supercontinent that encompassed South America, Antarctica, and Australia — before spreading around the globe.

CT Scan of a Fossil Infructescence Showing Fruits and Tiny Paired Seeds Inside the Fruits

A CT scan of a fossil infructescence showing fruits and tiny paired seeds inside the fruits. The CT scan picked up density changes in the rock and rendered them into three-dimensional images. Credit: Courtesy of Peter Wilf

“Our study provides the first direct fossil evidence of spurges in Gondwanan South America,” said Peter Wilf, professor of geosciences at Penn State and lead author of the current study, noting that the finding contrasts with the prevailing idea that the MMC evolved in Asia. “But if they evolved in Asia, how in the world would they have gotten to where we found them, in Argentine rocks 50 million years old? Instead, we think these spurges tracked the moving continents from South America to Asia, to the other side of the world. You can’t go much farther than that without leaving the planet. We’ve seen this pattern in many other plant groups we’ve found as fossils in South America like kauris, Asian chinkapin, and yellowwood trees. Altogether it is the most dramatic evolutionary biogeography story I’ve ever seen.”

According to Wilf, Euphorbiaceae have adapted well to evolutionary challenges in different environments.

“They’re common in tropical rainforests in Africa, South America, and most notably in Asia, where if you count the number of trees in a plot, they’re usually the second most common type,” he said. “They make up much of the understory habitat that is structurally important to the rainforest and its animal life. The MMC is well known in the Asian tropics and is highly visible along roadsides and in burned areas. Its plants often have large, umbrella-like leaves that provide abundant shade, and they provide nutritious seeds for animal forage.”

The spurge family comprises more than 6,000 species, found mostly in the tropics but also in deserts and cold temperate zones, and there are about 400 species in the MMC alone. Given their prevalence in southeast Asia and 23-million-year-old fossils previously found in New Zealand, scientists have considered the MMC an “Old World” plant group likely with Asian origins. The current study, based on fossils more than twice as old as the New Zealand specimens, provides the first evidence of “New World” origins for MMC spurges and adds two new species to the plant family, according to the scientists.

Fossil Leaves With Characteristics Identical to Several Macaranga Species

Fossil leaves with characteristics identical to several Macaranga species. Credit: Courtesy of Peter Wilf

Wilf and his colleagues at Argentina’s Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Tecnológicas (CONICET) in Bariloche and the Museo Paleontológico Egidio Feruglio (MEF), and Cornell University examined 11 leaf fossils and two compound infructescence fossils, or fossils that show preserved fruits and seeds attached to branches. The fossils came from a site in Chubut, Argentina called Laguna del Hunco, where the researchers have collected fossils for decades. Dating of volcanic rocks at this site places the fossils at 52 million years old, a globally warm time immediately preceding the final separation of Gondwana.

The scientists studied the detailed characteristics of the leaves and fruits and compared them with living specimens. They also took CT scans of the infructescences at the Penn State Center for Quantitative Imaging. The scans picked up density changes in the rock and rendered them into three-dimensional images that the researchers used to study the fruits’ features, including tiny paired seeds inside the fruits that were barely visible at the surface.

The researchers found that the characteristics of the fossil fruits and leaves are only found today in MMC spurges, identifying them as two new species. They named the infructescences after the late Rodolfo Magín Casamiquela, an Argentine vertebrate paleontologist and anthropologist who collected one of the specimens, perhaps as early as the 1950s, and the leaf species after Kirk Johnson, paleobotanist and Sant Director of the Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History who had discovered the first of the leaf fossils in the 1990s.

52 Million Year Old Compound Infructescence Fossil

A 52-million-year-old compound infructescence fossil showing preserved fruits and seeds attached to branches, collected by the late Rodolfo Magín Casamiquela from Laguna del Hunco, Chubut province, Argentina. The plant’s characteristics — such as the terminal fruit (tf), axile seeds (sd), and plumose stigma (st) — are only found today in the Macaranga-Mallotus clade of the spurge family. Courtesy of Peter Wilf

“The MMC is widely distributed, but prior to this research they’ve never been found growing naturally in the Americas,” Wilf said. “This is the first time that the MMC has been reliably documented anywhere in the Western Hemisphere past or present.”

The fossils tell a story about environmental changes, plate tectonics, and biogeography, or the distribution of plants and animals around the world, Wilf said. The plants likely originated and evolved in Gondwana and began retreating as the climate grew drier and colder over millions of years, suffering extinction in Antarctica and South America but apparently surviving in Australia, he said.

At the same time, plate tectonics were pulling apart the Gondwanan supercontinent. Australia broke away from Antarctica more than 40 million years ago and collided with southeast Asia 25 million years ago, bringing the water-demanding plants to New Guinea and the southeast Asian rainforest, the researchers said.

“We’ve seen over and over again that we can trace a significant number of Australian and Asian rainforest plants all the way to Argentina and Western Gondwana,” Wilf said. “These fossils tell us how plants respond to environmental changes. If you give them time and an escape route, like Australia as it moved from the Antarctic latitudes to Asia, they can move around the world following their preferred environment and thrive. Deforestation and environmental changes today, including in southeast Asia where our Gondwanan survivor trees live, are occurring 100 to 1000 times faster than they did millions of years ago, and escape routes have been converted into cities and agriculture. These fossils serve as a warning from the deep past, that the natural world that we rely on is extremely resilient but cannot keep up with us. It is not too late to act and avoid the worst outcomes.”

Reference: “The first Gondwanan Euphorbiaceae fossils reset the biogeographic history of the Macaranga-Mallotus clade” by Peter Wilf, Ari Iglesias and María A. Gandolfo, 2 May 2023, American Journal of Botany.
DOI: 10.1002/ajb2.16169

The study was funded by the National Science Foundation, National Geographic Society.

3 Comments on "“The Most Dramatic Evolutionary Biogeography Story I’ve Ever Seen” – Plant Fossils Reveal Ancient South America-to-Asia “Escape Route”"

  1. ‘No one wants to be right about this’: climate scientists’ horror and exasperation as global predictions play out… https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jul/25/northern-hemisphere-heatwaves-europe-greece-italy-wildfires-extreme-weather-climate-experts

    Global warming will not only cause wildfires, flooding, sea-rise, famine, disruption of habitats, extinction of species, etc., it will afford an opportunity for very harmful viruses and diseases, for which there is no known cure, to evolve faster and flourish.

    For example, flesh-eating bacteria that thrive in warm fresh water, will prosper with warming, and there is no cure. What about a new drug-resistant malaria, or smallpox, or a long-dead virus resurrected in a melting glacier…?

    • The article is about the fossil record considering plate tectonic drift, and how plants migrate across continents, not global warming. It’s actually pretty interesting, and explains how plants survive changes to climate.

      Staphylococcus aureus only survives in costal waters, and the antibiotic-resistant strains that cause flesh-eating infections (necrotizing fascitis) come from untreated waste-water outfalls, dumping sewage into the ocean. That can be fixed by not doing that anymore, instead of climate concern. Ancient viruses are unlikely to infect anything living now, and more likely to be rapidly destroyed by the environment, so that’s more sci-fi than science.

      Oh, and The Guardian is as rubbish as the Daily Mail.

  2. “It is not too late to act and avoid the worst outcomes.” It would have been useful to have some suggestions that might make sense. Most do not. But that’s the obligatory thing to say even after a discussion of plate tectonics on the migration of plants over millions of years.

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.