The same lightbulbs used in offices and public spaces can destroy coronaviruses and HIV, according to a new study from U of T Scarborough.
Researchers killed both viruses using UV-LED lights, which can alternate between white light and decontaminating ultraviolet (UV) light. With a cheap retrofit, they could also be used in many standard lighting fixtures, giving them a “unique appeal” for public spaces, says Christina Guzzo, senior author of the study.
“We’re at a critical time where we need to use every single possible stop to get us out of this pandemic,” says Guzzo, an assistant professor in the department of biological sciences. “Every mitigation strategy that can be easily implemented should be used.”
UV lights kill viruses through radiation. Guzzo, alongside PhD students Arvin T. Persaud and Jonathan Burnie, first tested the lights on bacterial spores notorious for their resistance to this radiation (known as Bacillus pumilus spores).
“If you’re able to kill these spores, then you can reasonably say you should be able to kill most other viruses that you would commonly encounter in the environment,” says Guzzo, principal investigator at the Guzzo Lab.
Within 20 seconds of UV exposure, the spores’ growth dropped by 99 percent.
The researchers then created droplets containing coronaviruses or HIV, to mimic typical ways people encounter viruses in public, such as from coughing, sneezing, and bleeding. The droplets were then exposed to UV light and placed in a culture to see if any of the virus remained active. With just 30 seconds of exposure, the virus’ ability to infect dropped by 93 percent.
Upon testing the viruses at different concentrations, they found samples with more viral particles were more resistant to the UV lights. But even with a viral load so high Guzzo calls it “the worst-case scenario,” infectivity dropped 88 percent.
Though it wasn’t included in the study, Guzzo and her students also compared UV light to two heavy duty disinfectants used in lab research. They found the lights were similarly effective in their ability to deactivate viruses.
“I was really surprised that UV could perform on the same level of those commonly used lab chemicals, which we regard as the gold standard,” she says. “That made me think, ‘Oh, my gosh, this is a legitimate tool that’s really underutilized.’”
Balance UV’s pros and cons with clever use, researchers say
While the lights still left a small percentage of the virus viable, Guzzo references the “Swiss cheese model” of defense against COVID. Every strategy to fight the spread has its holes, but every layer is another chance to stop straggling virus particles.
Repeated exposure to UV light is key to catching those missed particles – fortunately, it’s as easy as flipping a switch. It’s also simpler to change a lightbulb than an air filtration system. Guzzo notes that UV-LEDs are cheap and could be easy to retrofit in existing light fixtures, and that the bulbs are long-lasting and simple to maintain.
“You could disinfect in a way that wouldn’t be infringing on people’s enjoyment of that everyday ‘normal’ life that they long for,” Guzzo says.
The lights also benefit from automation. A standardized, germicidal dose of light can be delivered each time, while the process of wiping down spaces with disinfectants leaves room for human error. Chemicals and waste from these disinfectants also end up in watersheds and landfills as hands are washed and wipes thrown away.
But the lights aren’t harmless, and there’s a reason for wearing sunscreen and sunglasses – UV radiation damages nucleic acid, and repeated, prolonged exposure is harmful. That’s why Guzzo says the lights should be used when public spaces are empty, such as vacated buses that have finished their routes, or empty elevators traveling between floors. Escalator handrails could be continuously disinfected by putting UV lights in the underground part of the track, cleaning it with each rotation.
Safe Antivirus Technologies, Inc., a Toronto-based start-up company that partnered with Guzzo for the study, is developing unique UV-LED lighting modules. With motion sensors, the lights automatically switch to UV light when a room is empty, then turn back to regular light with movement.
Funded by the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council (NSERC) Alliance COVID-19 Grant and published in the Virology Journal, this study highlights UV-LEDs as a tool that could be used beyond the pandemic, ideally to help prevent another.
“Worldwide events like the COVID-19 pandemic, as terrible as they are, hopefully can still be learned from,” Guzzo says. “One thing we learned is that this is an underutilized tool we should think more about implementing.”
Reference: “A UV-LED module that is highly effective at inactivating human coronaviruses and HIV-1” by Arvin T. Persaud, Jonathan Burnie, Laxshaginee Thaya, Liann DSouza, Steven Martin and Christina Guzzo, 10 February 2022, Virology Journal.
Funding: Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council (NSERC) Alliance COVID-19 Grant awarded to C.G. as the principal investigator and in collaboration with Safe Antiviral Technologies Inc.
“But the lights aren’t harmless, …”
Besides the risk to humans who might inadvertently be exposed, one should anticipate long-term degradation of organic materials such as plastics and rubber, often used as coverings and seals, particularly with the LEDs with the shorter wavelength. Just substituting the UV LEDs for conventional lights will probably result in higher maintenance costs and unpredictable failures in things like electrical insulation. Another problem is that many, if not most, light fixtures have glass or plastic coverings. The short-wave UV will not pass through glass, and even if it will pass through plastic, it will probably cause it to become cloudy or frosted (and brittle) over time.
What happens if someone is sitting alone in a room reading, or looking through a microscope, and not moving enough to keep the conventional lights on? One does not want to be exposed to even short, but frequent UV exposures.
Options open up for improving Public Health Solutions.
Combine with extremely sensitive sensors for detection of such viruses and retroviruses in open spaces and equip public lifgting to take these viruses / retro viruses out, when detected, as long as humans are not around. Humans can be detected vide body heat sensors.
The option can be kept ready with modified public lighting ,as a back-up plan, and such public infrastructure can be used for control of future viral pandemics?
Views expressed are personal and not binding on anyone.
Quite impressive BOTH COMMENTS Proves How Free Thinking Allowed IN USA Provides Input for SAFTEY & wellbeing FOR ALL, even with 1 fault THANK YOU (SciTech Daily) For FREE Speech.