Efficiency of the Ocean’s “Biological Carbon Pump” Has Been Drastically Underestimated

Marine chemist Ken Buesseler (right) deploys a sediment trap from the research vessel Roger Revelle during a 2018 expedition in the Gulf of Alaska. Buesseler’s research focuses on how carbon moves through the ocean. Buesseler and co-authors of a new study found that the ocean’s biological carbon pump may be twice as efficient as previously estimated, with implications for future climate assessments. Credit: Photo by Alyssa Santoro, © Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution

The Ocean’s ‘Biological Pump’ Captures Twice as Much Carbon as Expected

Every spring in the Northern Hemisphere, the ocean surface erupts in a massive bloom of phytoplankton. Like plants, these single-celled floating organisms use photosynthesis to turn light into energy, consuming carbon dioxide and releasing oxygen in the process. When phytoplankton die or are eaten by zooplankton, the carbon-rich fragments sink deeper into the ocean, where it is, in turn, eaten by other creatures or buried in sediments. This process is key to the “biological carbon pump,” an important part of the global carbon cycle.

Scientists have long known that the ocean plays an essential role in capturing carbon from the atmosphere, but a new study from Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (WHOI) shows that the efficiency of the ocean’s “biological carbon pump” has been drastically underestimated, with implications for future climate assessments.

Scientists have long known that the ocean plays an essential role in capturing carbon from the atmosphere, but a new study shows that the efficiency of the ocean’s “biological carbon pump” has been drastically underestimated.

In a paper published today (April 6, 2020) in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, WHOI geochemist Ken Buesseler, and colleagues demonstrated that the depth of the sunlit area where photosynthesis occurs varies significantly throughout the ocean. This matters because the phytoplankton’s ability to take up carbon depends on the amount of sunlight that’s able to penetrate the ocean’s upper layer. By taking account of the depth of the euphotic, or sunlit zone, the authors found that about twice as much carbon sinks into the ocean per year than previously estimated.

The paper relies on previous studies of the carbon pump, including the authors’ own. “If you look at the same data in a new way, you get a very different view of the ocean’s role in processing carbon, hence its role in regulating climate,” says Buesseler.

Carbon loss traditional measurement at 150 meters (500 feet) compared to carbon loss measurement considering the depth of sunlight penetration. Credit: Courtesy Ken Buesseler, © Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution

“Using the new metrics, we will be able to refine the models to not just tell us how the ocean looks today, but how it will look in the future,” he adds. “Is the amount of carbon sinking in the ocean going up or down? That number affects the climate of the world we live in.”

In the paper, Buesseler and his coauthors call on their fellow oceanographers to consider their data in context of the actual boundary of the euphotic zone.

“If we’re going to call something a euphotic zone, we need to define that,” he says. “So we’re insisting on a more formal definition so that we can compare sites.”

Rather than taking measurements at fixed depths, the authors used chlorophyll sensors — indicating the presence of phytoplankton — to rapidly assess the depth of the sunlit region. They also suggest using the signature from a naturally-occuring thorium isotope to estimate the rate at which carbon particles are sinking.

Reference: “Metrics that matter for assessing the ocean biological carbon pump” by Ken O. Buesseler, Philip W. Boyd, Erin E. Black and David A. Siegel, 6 April 2020, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1918114117

Buesseler is a principal investigator with WHOI’s Ocean Twilight Zone project, which focuses on the little-understood but vastly important mid-ocean region. In a commentary published in Nature on March 31, Buesseler and colleagues call on the international marine research community to intensify their studies of the twilight zone during the upcoming United Nations Decade of the Ocean (2021-2030). Increased understanding of the twilight zone ecosystem and its role in regulating climate, the authors say, will lead to global policy to protect the area from exploitation.

Coauthors of the paper include: Phillip Boyd of University of Tasmania, Australia; Erin Black of Dalhousie University, Nova Scotia, and Lamont Doherty Earth Observatory, New York; and David Siegel, University of California, Santa Barbara.

This work was funded by: WHOI’s Ocean Twilight Zone project; NASA as part of the EXport Processes in the global Ocean from RemoTe Sensing (EXPORTS) program; the Ocean Frontier Institute at Dalhousie University; and the Australian Research Council.

Key takeaways:

• Using photosynthesis, phytoplankton floating on the ocean’s surface absorb carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. The depth of this sunlit layer affects the efficiency of the ocean’s “biological carbon pump” or ability to take up carbon.
• By measuring the depth of the ocean’s sunlit surface area, or “euphotic zone”, scientists found that the “biological carbon pump” is twice as efficient as previously estimated.
• Using this method could lead to more accurate climate models, such as those used by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, to set global climate policy.
• More study of the mid-ocean “twilight zone” will lead to better understanding of the biological carbon pump’s role in regulating climate and the productivity of fisheries.