Mysterious Source of Fast Radio Bursts – “We Could Not Believe It”

Extremely Fast Radio Signals

Extremely fast radio signals from a surprising source. A cluster of ancient stars (left) close to the spiral galaxy Messier 81 (M81) is the source of extraordinarily bright and short radio signals. The image shows in blue-white a graph of how one flash’s brightness changed over the course of only tens of microseconds. Credit: Daniëlle Futselaar,

The Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) are millisecond-long bursts of radiation recorded on radio waves. They are extremely powerful — for example, during one of the brightest flashes lasting five milliseconds, as much energy is radiated as our Sun generates in a month. The scale of the phenomenon is difficult to imagine.

The first radio bursts were “discovered” barely 15 years ago. Until April 2020, all the FRBs observed by astronomers came from cosmological distances of hundreds of millions of light years. It was only two years ago that they also managed to track flashes originating in our Galaxy. It is important to note that due to the equipment and associated sensitivity limit, researchers are only able to observe the most luminous objects in the Universe, the most powerful bursts.

“When we saw the first results, we could not believe it, and at first, we even thought that we had made a calculation error.” — Dr. Marcin Gawronski

“FRBs are currently one of the hottest topics in contemporary astrophysics. Discovered accidentally in 2007 during a review of archival data, and currently under intensive observation, they are still a great mystery,” explains Dr. Marcin Gawronski from the Institute of Astronomy at the Faculty of Physics, Astronomy and Informatics Nicolaus Copernicus University (Torun, Poland). “The results gathered so far make it possible to divide the FRB phenomena into different classes, but we still have not found out whether they are emanations of one or many separate physical processes.”

Cosmic catch

Researchers are not 100 percent sure what causes the bursts. Astrophysicists have various hypotheses that could explain their formation, including the existence of extraterrestrial civilizations. However, so far magnetars have been considered to be the source of FRBs.

Magnetar in Cluster of Ancient Stars

Source of mysterious radio signals: an artist’s impression of a magnetar in a cluster of ancient stars (in red) close to the spiral galaxy Messier 81 (M81). Credit: Daniëlle Futselaar,

“Magnetars are neutron stars with extremely strong magnetic fields, they are formed after supernova explosions,” says Dr. Gawronski. “So far, scientists have agreed that they are responsible for the FRBs. Why? Because in order to produce an FRB, it is necessary to have a huge amount of energy, which can be quickly released and used in various processes. The only sources of this type known to us are either the magnetic fields of a cluster of neutron stars — these magnetars — or the gravitational energy of black holes.”

Although astronomers agree that fast radio flashes are the result of violent processes occurring in the immediate vicinity of highly magnetized neutron stars, it is still unclear why most of them appear as single signals, while other sources can be observed on radio waves repeatedly. In some cases, the bursts are additionally characterized by periodic activity, i.e., they occur at regular time intervals. This, however, only helps in planning observations.

There are also quite a few difficulties that astronomers have to deal with in FRB observations. “Studying FRB activity is very difficult because flashes are random phenomena. It seems a bit like fishing — we cast a fishing rod and wait. So, we set up radio telescopes and we have to wait patiently,” says Dr. Gawronski. “Another problem is that radio telescopes “see” quite a large field of the sky, e.g., ours in Piwnice covers an area half the size of the Moon’s disk in the radio band, which we usually use for FRB observations. There are many objects over such a large area, so it is difficult to pinpoint one particular flash. Another issue is the enormous amount of data that we collect during such observations — we can record up to 4 gigabits of data per second, so we need very large storage capacities. So, we have to process, analyze and delete this data on an ongoing basis to make room for the next.”

Marcin Gawronski

Dr. Marcin Gawronski from the Institute of Astronomy at the Faculty of Physics, Astronomy and Informatics Nicolaus Copernicus University (Torun, Poland). Credit: Andrzej Romanski/NCU, Torun, Poland

As you can see, there are many puzzles and difficulties connected with fast radio bursts Astrophysicists are working on models to explain this phenomenon, but the recent discovery, in which Dr. Marcin Gawroñski also participated, brings yet another mystery to be solved.

Cosmic inquisition

Last year an international group of astronomers, including Dr. Gawronski, pointed radio telescopes towards the galaxy M81.

“It is a huge and close to us galaxy, similar to the Milky Way — it is located about 12 million light-years away from us, in summer when the weather is good you can see it with a regular set of binoculars, and e.g., with the Hubble telescope you can observe single stars in it,” explains Dr. Gawronski. “Canadians from the CHIME project told us that there was a source of fast radio bursts in the vicinity of this galaxy, and what’s more, some of its properties indicated that this object was related to the M81. We thought it would be a great opportunity to try to find out what specifically generated the FRBs.”

The observations were made by researchers working primarily in the PRECISE consortium.

“This is a team of researchers whose main objective is to locate FRB sources, estimate the distances to them, and study the properties of the environment in which FRBs are placed. In this way, we can try to say something about the evolution of the sources of fast bursts and the very processes in which FRB objects are generated,” says Dr. Gawronski. “In a sense, we act in parallel to EVN (European Very Long Baseline Interferometry Network), as we try to gather European radio telescopes outside the time allocated for standard observations within this consortium, to which, of course, the NCU Institute of Astronomy belongs together with the RT4 radio telescope.”

Marcin Gawronski Astronomy

Dr. Marcin Gawronski from the Institute of Astronomy at the Faculty of Physics, Astronomy and Informatics Nicolaus Copernicus University (Torun, Poland). “In these observations, we used the largest European radio telescopes: a 100-meter dish in Effelsberg, Germany, and a 60-meter dish on Sardinia and RT4 in Piwnice,” says Dr. Gawronski. Credit: Andrzej Romanski/NCU, Torun, Poland

The researchers are very lucky. The first time they pointed their radio telescopes at the vicinity of the M81 galaxy, they found a series of four bursts. It wasn’t long before they caught two more. However, the new findings came as a surprise to the researchers.

“When we saw the first results, we could not believe it, and at first, we even thought that we had made a calculation error. It turned out that we had not. It was like in the Monty Python’s sketch ‘Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition.’ Because none of us expected such a thing,” says Dr. Gawronski.

A young one among the old?

Firstly, the burst came from a globular cluster. So, the first disappointment came at the beginning — a cluster of this type consists of a huge number of densely packed stars, so it was impossible to pinpoint the specific object that was the source of the FRB, even with the help of the Hubble orbiting telescope. More interestingly, globular clusters are composed of very old stars, formed up to 10 billion years ago — they are the oldest star systems in the galaxies. It is therefore futile to look for “young” magnetars there.

“Many questions came to our minds: where did the magnetar come from there? We assumed that it must have been the source of the bursts. In fact, the magnetar could not have been there. And if it was, it could not have been formed in a classical way, i.e., following an explosion of a massive star,” explains Dr. Gawronski. “Such massive stars live for a very short time and within an estimated time of several tens of millions of years after their formation they end their lives in a very impressive phenomenon, called a supernova explosion. It is known that stars do not form in globular clusters for a long time, so no new magnetars can form there during a supernova phenomenon.”

If we reject the possibility that there are star wars taking place quite near us, in which planets are destroyed — and such a hypothesis may not be straight out of science fiction films, since many scientists take into account that FRBs may be technosignatures — then there are several other hypotheses.

“Theoretically, a new magnetar could have been born from an old star, or more precisely from the explosion of a white dwarf. Such a phenomenon can occur in a binary system, where a white dwarf slowly “eats” its companion and at some point, it exceeds the mass for which its stable structure can exist. Then this unstable dwarf explodes in a thermonuclear explosion, during which a neutron star may also be formed, such as a magnetar,” explains Dr. Gawronski. “However, it is not such a simple explanation: if there was a supernova explosion in a globular cluster (but of a different type than the death of massive stars), it must have happened not so long ago on a cosmic scale. According to current theories, magnetars are active for only a few million years after birth. The effects or remnants of such an explosion should be noticeable to us, but so far nothing has been observed.”

The other possible explanation is the merger of two compact, old stars — white dwarfs and/or neutron stars — and the formation of a young object in the so-called kilonova phenomenon. However, the chance of such an event occurring in our “local” Universe is rather slim.

The astronomers’ discovery is as interesting as it is mysterious. For now, one thing is certain — the bursts are the result of some as yet unrecognized phenomenon. The work of astrophysicists may contribute to its description and investigation. The results have been published in the prestigious journal Nature. The article “A repeating fast radio burst source in a globular cluster,” co-authored by Dr. Marcin Gawroñski, concerning the astronomers’ latest discovery is topic no. 1 in the latest issue of the journal.

What were the FRB observations like?

Researchers use the EVN infrastructure, primarily the huge disk capacities that were dedicated to the PRECISE consortium.

“We check which radio telescopes are available at a given time and apply for time — we organize this ad hoc, about 3-4 weeks in advance,” says Dr. Marcin Gawronski. “We have to connect at least five radio telescopes together, creating a network. In these observations we used the largest European radio telescopes: a 100-meter dish in Effelsberg, Germany, and a 60-meter dish on Sardinia. They are large and therefore have a significant collecting area, so we analyzed the data gathered by them first.”

After completing further series of observations, researchers must then study the recorded signal for the presence of FRBs as soon as possible, and inform the EVN stations that selected data can be deleted as irrelevant.

Recently, the system for observation, data collection and analysis has been improved. Firstly, the English e-MERLIN radio telescope network has granted up to 400 hours of availability of its instruments to the PRECISE. Secondly, and no less importantly, thanks to investments in equipment from the University Centre of Excellence “Astrophysics and Astrochemistry,” the researchers in Piwnice have the possibility to process and study the recorded signal autonomously through their radio telescope.

“You can say that I am giving some servers a hard time, as they are working practically non-stop, processing huge amounts of data,” says Dr. Gawronski. “Apart from the PRECISE project, there is also our internal research team monitoring the known sources of FRB. We conduct observations by means of three radio telescopes: our RT-4 from Piwnice near Torun, the Dutch Westerbork and the Swedish Onsala. Thanks to these additional observations, we study the activity of the known FRB sources at frequencies above 1.4 GHz. The addition of a local computing node should greatly expand the capabilities of our research team.”

For more on this discovery, see Mysterious Cosmic Flashes Pinpointed to a Surprising Location in Space.


“A repeating fast radio burst source in a globular cluster” by F. Kirsten, B. Marcote, K. Nimmo, J. W. T. Hessels, M. Bhardwaj, S. P. Tendulkar, A. Keimpema, J. Yang, M. P. Snelders, P. Scholz, A. B. Pearlman, C. J. Law, W. M. Peters, M. Giroletti, Z. Paragi, C. Bassa, D. M. Hewitt, U. Bach, V. Bezrukovs, M. Burgay, S. T. Buttaccio, J. E. Conway, A. Corongiu, R. Feiler, O. Forssén, M. P. Gawronski, R. Karuppusamy, M. A. Kharinov, M. Lindqvist, G. Maccaferri, A. Melnikov, O. S. Ould-Boukattine, A. Possenti, G. Surcis, N. Wang, J. Yuan, K. Aggarwal, R. Anna-Thomas, G. C. Bower, R. Blaauw, S. Burke-Spolaor, T. Cassanelli, T. E. Clarke, E. Fonseca, B. M. Gaensler, A. Gopinath, V. M. Kaspi, N. Kassim, T. J. W. Lazio, C. Leung, D. Z. Li, H. H. Lin, K. W. Masui, R. Mckinven, D. Michilli, A. G. Mikhailov, C. Ng, A. Orbidans, U. L. Pen, E. Petroff, M. Rahman, S. M. Ransom, K. Shin, K. M. Smith, I. H. Stairs and W. Vlemmings, 23 February 2022, Nature.
DOI: 10.1038/s41586-021-04354-w

“Burst timescales and luminosities as links between young pulsars and fast radio bursts” by K. Nimmo, J. W. T. Hessels, F. Kirsten, A. Keimpema, J. M. Cordes, M. P. Snelders, D. M. Hewitt, R. Karuppusamy, A. M. Archibald, V. Bezrukovs, M. Bhardwaj, R. Blaauw, S. T. Buttaccio, T. Cassanelli, J. E. Conway, A. Corongiu, R. Feiler, E. Fonseca, O. Forssén, M. Gawronski, M. Giroletti, M. A. Kharinov, C. Leung, M. Lindqvist, G. Maccaferri, B. Marcote, K. W. Masui, R. Mckinven, A. Melnikov, D. Michilli, A. G. Mikhailov, C. Ng, A. Orbidans, O. S. Ould-Boukattine, Z. Paragi, A. B. Pearlman, E. Petroff, M. Rahman, P. Scholz, K. Shin, K. M. Smith, I. H. Stairs, G. Surcis, S. P. Tendulkar, W. Vlemmings, N. Wang, J. Yang and J. P. Yuan, 23 February 2022, Nature Astronomy.
DOI: 10.1038/s41550-021-01569-9

Be the first to comment on "Mysterious Source of Fast Radio Bursts – “We Could Not Believe It”"

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.