Use of Female Animal Models in the Lab Led to the Crucial Finding
Alzheimer’s disease disproportionately affects women, who represent about two-thirds of those diagnosed with the late-onset type of the disease.
Previous research has shown Alzheimer’s is also more severe and progresses more rapidly in women, and women with Alzheimer’s experience a steeper cognitive decline – loss of memory, attention, and the ability to communicate and make decisions – compared to men with the disease.
The biological bases for these differences between men and women with Alzheimer’s disease are not well understood. However, understanding them is necessary for developing appropriate therapies.
Role of Female Sex Hormones
In a new study in mice and humans, Western University researchers have shown female sex hormones play a significant role in how Alzheimer’s manifests in the brain.
The study, published in Alzheimer’s & Dementia: The Journal of the Alzheimer’s Association, also highlights the importance of developing therapeutic strategies focused on these hormonal connections. The research indicates a need to better understand the role of estradiol – a form of the female sex hormone estrogen, used therapeutically to mitigate menopause symptoms – in Alzheimer’s disease.
While the significance of the findings is paramount, the methodology behind them is equally critical, pointing to a necessary shift in scientific approaches.
“To understand how sex hormones play a role in Alzheimer’s, we need to study appropriate animal models. Unfortunately, most studies at this level still focus mainly on the male brain. Our research emphasizes the importance of using animal models that reflect, for instance, postmenopausal women, to understand how sex hormones influence Alzheimer’s pathology,” said Vania Prado, professor, departments of physiology and pharmacology and anatomy & cell biology at Schulich School of Medicine & Dentistry and scientist at Robarts Research Institute.
This study was led by graduate student Liliana German-Castelan, under the supervision of Vania Prado.
Brain Communication and Alzheimer’s
One of the key markers of Alzheimer’s disease is the toxic build-up of the protein beta-amyloid in the brain, which eventually disrupts the brain’s communications system and impacts cognition.
The new study shows that the brain chemistry of male and female mice regulates beta-amyloid protein in Alzheimer’s in different ways, with the hormone estradiol contributing to this variation.
Previous studies on mice and at-risk older individuals have revealed that cholinergic neurons, a type of brain cells that produce the chemical messenger acetylcholine, are particularly vulnerable to the damaging Alzheimer’s-associated beta-amyloid accumulation in the brain. Additionally, acetylcholine has been shown to be essential for normal memory and cognition.
While beta-amyloid aggregation impacts the production of acetylcholine, the subsequent loss of this chemical messenger further increases Alzheimer’s pathology, creating a vicious loop.
The team of Western researchers studied this interaction between changes in brain chemistry and the beta-amyloid protein build-up seen in brains impacted by Alzheimer’s.
“Since male and female brains have differences in the cholinergic system, we wanted to see if sex affects this relationship between acetylcholine signalling and the beta-amyloid protein buildup,” said Marco Prado, professor, departments of physiology and pharmacology and anatomy and cell biology. Marco Prado, one of the authors of the study, is also the Canada Research Chair in Neurochemistry of Dementia and a scientist at Robarts Research Institute.
The Importance of Gender-Specific Analysis
In this study, the researchers observed differences in beta-amyloid accumulation in male and female mice when changing the levels of cholinergic activity. Additionally, they analyzed brain MRI images of healthy older humans.
Different from most studies in humans, in which the MRI scans of men and women are analyzed together, Western professor Taylor Schmitz and graduate student Hayley Shanks analyzed MRI brain scans and the rate of brain loss for aged men and women independently.
“We observed that the relationship between the integrity of the brain region where cholinergic neurons reside and beta-amyloid accumulation was the same for men and women but was different in male and female mice,” said Marco Prado. The researchers suspected that the fact the female mice being studied were not post-menopausal, while women were, could be an attributing factor to the difference.
The lead author of the study, German-Castelan, intrigued by the sex differences, decided to introduce another layer of testing into the mouse models and with the help of Western researcher Robert Gros studied female mice who were closely modelled to represent postmenopausal women. This was done to investigate how the presence or lack of sex hormones could impact the relationship between cholinergic signaling and the beta-amyloid buildup in the brain.
“We found that when the sex hormone estradiol was present, the relationship between acetylcholine and toxic amyloid was lost, but when sex hormones were eliminated in the female mice that relationship reproduced the results seen in humans,” said German-Castelan.
These findings also point to the urgent need to study amyloid and cholinergic function in the ‘peri-menopausal’ age range of 40-50 years, which is much younger than the individuals examined in most large-scale studies of Alzheimer’s disease. Indeed, the sample examined in this study were closer to the age of 70 on average.
“Which explains why there were differences between the results of male and female mice and men and women in our initial exploration,” said German-Castelan.
Researchers emphasized that if they hadn’t included female mice in the study, they might have missed crucial information about Alzheimer’s and sex differences.
“Women and men respond differently to medications and have a somewhat different journey in Alzheimer’s. To develop more effective therapeutics, we need to study animal models that can reproduce different aspects of the journey. Sex hormones and estradiol levels are just one of these factors,” said Vania Prado.
Reference: “Sex-dependent cholinergic effects on amyloid pathology: A translational study” by Liliana German-Castelan, Hayley R. C. Shanks, Robert Gros, Takashi Saito, Takaomi C. Saido, Lisa M. Saksida, Timothy J. Bussey, Marco A. M. Prado, Taylor W. Schmitz and Vania F. Prado, 17 October 2023, Alzheimer’s & Dementia.
DOI: 10.1002/alz.13481
Other authors on the study include Western researchers Lisa M. Saksida and Timothy J. Bussey, and Takashi Saito and Takaomi C. Saido of RIKEN Center for Brain Science, Japan.
Never miss a breakthrough: Join the SciTechDaily newsletter.
Follow us on Google and Google News.
1 Comment
First diagnosed with gout (elevated serum uric acid) and allergies in 1981, in late 2010 I found on my own at-home I had a serious medically undiagnosed calcium deficiency and that standard blood serum testing for calcium was unreliable (blood pH regulation). In 2011 a six page ‘letter’ to JACI and a one page ‘correspondence’ to The Lancet went unpublished. Mostly taking calcium carbonate for a decade, in mid-March of 2021 I found on my own again that I was even more seriously ill with a phosphorus deficiency, calcium carbonate was known to “bind” with phosphorus, estrogen was protective against uric acid and post-menopausal women not on hormone therapy were as likely to get gout as younger men. Since, I’ve written scores of researchers about my (Dr. Arthur F. Coca’s; by 1935) kind of food allergies causing elevated uric acid levels and older women (especially mothers) being more prone to dementia from acidic blood resulting in medically undiagnosed calcium deficiencies. As only a lay investigator, I postulate that uric acid erodes cholesterol from the myelin sheaths of brain and nerve cells to wreak havoc and stimulate the body to fill-in the voids using whatever is available, resulting in plaques and tangles in the brain.