Einstein’s General Relativity Validated 10 Years Ahead of Schedule by ‘Ringing’ Black Hole

An illustration of a supersized black hole resulting from the merger of two smaller black holes. The collision has caused the black hole to ring and radiate gravitational waves (white). Credit: Maximiliano Isi/MIT

Gravitational wave ‘tones’ detected following the merger of two black holes confirm the decades-old ‘no-hair theory’ of black hole properties.

For the first time, astrophysicists have heard a black hole ringing like a bell. By reanalyzing the first black hole merger ever detected, the astrophysicists measured the gravitational wave ‘tones’ emitted following the event. The breakthrough comes 10 years earlier than expected and confirms that the properties of black holes are just as Einstein predicted in his theory of general relativity in 1915.

“Previously it was believed these tones were too faint to be detected, yet now we are able to,” says study co-author Will Farr. “Just like the measurement of atomic spectra in the late 1800s opened the era of stellar astrophysics and classifying and understanding stars, this is the opening of the era of black hole spectra and understanding black holes and the general relativity that sits behind them.”

Farr is an associate professor at Stony Brook University in New York and group leader for gravitational wave astronomy at the Flatiron Institute’s Center for Computational Astrophysics in New York City. He and his colleagues presented their findings on September 12, 2019, in Physical Review Letters.

When two black holes merge into one, the resulting supersized black hole wobbles like a struck bell. The reverberations emit gravitational waves at characteristic tones that fade away as the black hole settles. The so-called ‘no-hair theory’ states that these tones — and all other external properties of a black hole — depend only on the black hole’s mass and rotation, just as Einstein’s general relativity predicts. Some scientists, however, propose that reality is hairier and that effects like quantum mechanics play a role as well.

Scientists knew that detecting a black hole’s tones could settle the debate. But the tones were thought to be too quiet to be detected by the current-generation gravitational wave detectors LIGO and Virgo.

In the new study, the astrophysicists combined simulations of black hole mergers with a reanalysis of the first gravitational waves ever detected. Those waves came from the merger of two black holes. The analysis led to the identification of two independent tones emitted by the newly combined black hole. The pitch and decay rates of these tones lined up with Einstein’s general relativity. The no-hair theory stood triumphant.

Farr says that with new data analysis and with LIGO and Virgo continuing to observe black hole mergers, tests from the observatories will become more precise. The added precision will likely lead to additional detections of black hole tones and an improved understanding of the exotic objects.

Farr collaborated on the study with Maximiliano Isi of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and the astrophysicists Matt Giesler, Mark Scheel and Saul Teukolsky of the California Institute of Technology.

Reference: “Testing the No-Hair Theorem with GW150914” by Maximiliano Isi, Matthew Giesler, Will M. Farr, Mark A. Scheel, and Saul A. Teukolsky, 12 September 2019, Physical Review Letters.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.123.111102

For more on this topic and a video simulation, see First Overtones Detected in the Ringing of a Black Hole as well as Scientists Detect Ringing of a Newborn Black Hole.

AstrophysicsBlack HoleGeneral RelativityMITSimons Foundation
Comments ( 3 )
Add Comment
  • katesisco

    I wonder if this ‘gravitational wave’ claim is not magnetism instead.
    Note that neutron stars are claimed to be almost perfectly spherical and this form would resist any distortions, wouldn’t it? I suspect bh are the most spherical form in the universe so No, once achieved they would not add.
    This addition of sound to gravitational waves seems like a desperate grab to save an unsupported theory. I experienced, on the day science claimed to have discovered ‘gravity waves’, an overwhelming sense of calm, which my research led me to believe was a magnetic wave, a soliton. Denying magnetic effects in the face of overwhelming evidence only leads science to opening a door that leads to 12 new doors. One reading science history may interpret this as the military coveting new applications and deliberately misleading research.
    Possibly a claimed ‘merger’ of gravity science and magnetism will occur once the weaponized effects are understood. How sad, as if we haven’t done it all before.

  • ConspiracyDebunket

    Previous comment by katesisco is the exact reason why we need to increase science education.

    Sigh. Rather than applying scientific analysis, the commenter delves into military and/or government conspiracy.

    Gravity waves do not make “sound” as we perceive it. It was a metaphor to try and explain the gravitational phenomena detected (which supports Einstein’s theory).

  • G r dixon

    See grdmax.net