Einstein’s Twist: Princeton Astrophysicists Unravel the Mystery of Black Hole Jets and Galactic “Lightsabers”

Black Hole Blazar Cosmic Jet Concept

Princeton researchers have found that the M87* black hole expels energy outward, contributing to the formation of massive jets. This discovery, rooted in Einstein’s theory of relativity, challenges traditional views of black holes and could be further tested with advanced telescopes. The study opens new avenues in understanding black hole dynamics, though it stops short of definitively explaining the source of the jets’ power. Credit: SciTechDaily.com

A team of Princeton astrophysicists has now determined conclusively that energy close to black hole M87* is pushing outward, not inward, a longstanding debate within the field.

The one thing everyone knows about black holes is that absolutely everything nearby gets sucked into them.

Almost everything, it turns out.

“Even though black holes are defined as objects from which nothing can escape, one of the astonishing predictions of Einstein’s theory of relativity is that black holes can actually lose energy,” says astrophysicist Eliot Quataert, Princeton’s Charles A. Young Professor of Astronomy on the Class of 1897 Foundation. “They can rotate, and just like a spinning top slows down over time and loses that energy in its rotation, a rotating black hole can also lose energy to its surroundings.”

Scientists have widely accepted this model since the 1970s. They knew that magnetic fields probably extract energy from spinning black holes — they just didn’t know how.

A team of Princeton astrophysicists has now determined conclusively that energy close to the event horizon of black hole M87* is pushing outward, not inward. (M87 is the name of the galaxy, Messier 87, so the black hole at its center is designated M87*.) The researchers have also created a way to test the prediction that black holes lose rotational energy, Quataert said, and to establish it’s that energy that produces “the incredibly powerful outflows we see that we call jets.”


An animation showing how the magnetic field crossing the black hole’s event horizon twists up as as the black hole rotates more quickly. A faster-rotating black hole `winds up’ the magnetic field more quickly, causing the black hole to lose more energy to its surroundings. A team of Princeton astrophysicists observed the wind-up of magnetic field lines in images from the Event Horizon Telescope of the linear polarization from black holes. Credit: Video by George Wong, Institute for Advanced Study and Princeton University

These energy outflow jets “are basically like million-light-year-long Jedi lightsabers,” said former Princeton postdoc Alexandru Lupsasca, and they can extend 10 times longer than the Milky Way galaxy.

The results of their work were recently published in The Astrophysical Journal. Andrew Chael, an associate research scholar in astrophysics, is the first author on the paper. He and co-author George Wong are both members of the Event Horizon Telescope team and have played a critical role in developing the models that are used to interpret black holes. Chael, Wong, Lupsasca and Quataert are all theorists affiliated with the Princeton Gravity Initiative.

The team gave Chael credit for the vital insight at the core of the new paper: that the direction in which the magnetic field lines are spiraling reveals the direction of the energy flow. From that, “the rest sort of fell into place,” Quataert said.

Model of M87* Twisting Magnetic Fields

The black hole M87* (the asterisk designates the black hole in the middle of galaxy M87) caught the world’s attention when it was first detected by the Event Horizon Telescope. Since then, Princeton astrophysicists have discovered that the twisting magnetic field around a black hole determines the tell-tale polarization spiral observed in black hole images. In particular, the direction of energy flow (from the hole to the field or vice versa) determines the how the polarization twists. By measuring which way the polarization spirals, one can infer whether the magnetic field is extracting spin energy from the hole or pumping spin energy into it. Credit: Model by Andrew Chael, George Wong, Alexandru Lupsasca and Eliot Quataert, Princeton Gravity Initiative

“If you took the Earth, turned it all into TNT and blew it up 1,000 times a second for millions and millions of years, that’s the amount of energy that we’re getting out of M87,” said Wong, an associate research scholar with the Princeton Gravity Initiative and a member of the Institute for Advanced Study.

Scientists have known for decades that as a black hole starts to spin, it drags the fabric of spacetime around with it. Magnetic field lines that thread through the black hole get dragged along, and that slows down the rotation, leading to the energy release.

“Our new, sharp prediction is that whenever you look at an astrophysical black hole, if it has magnetic field lines attached to it, there will be energy transfer — truly insane amounts of energy transfer,” said Lupsasca, a former associate research scholar at Princeton who is now an assistant professor of physics and mathematics at Vanderbilt University, and who won the 2024 New Horizons in Physics Prize from the Breakthrough Prize Foundation for his black hole research.

While the energy flow close to M87*’s event horizon is streaming outwards, the team said that the energy flow could theoretically go inward in a different black hole. They are confident in their link between energy flow and the direction of the magnetic field lines, and their prediction that the energy flow comes from the black hole will be tested with the launch of the still-theoretical “next generation” Event Horizon Telescope.

For the past year and a half, black hole researchers around the world have been proposing specs for the future instrument, Wong said. “Papers like ours can play a crucial role in determining what we need. I think it’s an incredibly exciting time.”

The four researchers stressed in their paper that they haven’t conclusively shown that the black hole’s spin “truly powers the extragalactic jet,” though the evidence certainly leans in that direction. Even though the levels of energy that their model shows are commensurate with what the jets need, they couldn’t rule out the possibility that the jet could be powered by rotating plasma outside the black hole. “I think it’s extremely likely the black hole powers the jet, but we can’t prove it,” said Lupsasca. “Yet.”

Reference: “Black Hole Polarimetry I. A Signature of Electromagnetic Energy Extraction” by Andrew Chael, Alexandru Lupsasca, George N. Wong and Eliot Quataert, 14 November 2023, The Astrophysical Journal.
DOI: 10.3847/1538-4357/acf92d

The research was supported by the Princeton Gravity Initiative, the Taplin Fellowship, the National Science Foundation (grant 2307888) and a Simons Foundation Investigator award.

10 Comments on "Einstein’s Twist: Princeton Astrophysicists Unravel the Mystery of Black Hole Jets and Galactic “Lightsabers”"

  1. Hottan Raideyatin | December 24, 2023 at 1:14 am | Reply

    This was written for me to understand. I don’t, but that’s alright, as it sounds like nobody really understands how these jets are created. Astrophysical jets are just beautiful. The energy, which Princeton and authors Chael & Lupsasca & Wong & Quataert found is actually escaping the black hole, boggles the mind, not to mention the energy that isn’t escaping. The quotes, with “million-light-year-long Jedi lightsabers”, and the Earth made of TNT exploding every second, I can just sense the fun the astrophysicists are having trying to conceptualize and explain it.

    I’m not an astrophysicist, and the full-text-available study is beyond me, meaning I can’t really speak to the veracity of the finding. Props to Liz Fuller-Wright on a well written press release. That was great, from the explanations, to the quotes, to shaping the quotes with the “yet” at the end. The whole article left me feeling optimistic and wanting to learn more. We’ll know someday, and maybe go check it in person.

    • Fantastic approach to life and learning.

      • Hottan Raideyatin | December 25, 2023 at 11:30 pm | Reply

        Thank you AG3. It’s a difficult world lately to keep an approach like that up, but I hope it’s a winning way. The massive energy transfer away from the black hole, versus what I learned about Hawking radiation, yet this jet is only described as originating maybe “close to the event horizon”, basically I’m confused. Hopefully the Next Generation Event Horizon Telescope (ngEHT) can clear it up, and I enjoy the goofy names of the new big telescopes, like the ELT (Extremely Large Telescope). I suggest the next one be called the RRBT, the Really Really Big Telescope.

        I enjoy well written articles, sometimes beyond the content. Many are dumbed-down so far as to be false, or so badly written as to oppose the foundations of the very field of science the study was in. We should expect a communications writer at Princeton to do well, but there’s some kind of competency crisis happening lately. This article’s topic is something so obscure and distant and confusing and unimaginable, explained so well in a relatable fun way. Maybe an astrophysicist can comment if it was all rubbish, but it sounds fair, with no absurd claims, no cheap tricks, like how it could be dangerous or confirms someone’s agenda. I’m harshly and glibly critical of bad writing I see on SciTechDaily, and I feel bad about that while trying to bring back a scientific criticism approach to interpreting articles, so it was a joy to see excellent writing about the progress in our understanding of the universe.

    • dr mehrdad kasiri | December 25, 2023 at 1:38 pm | Reply

      Hottan

      Hello
      I read your comments about dark matter and its effect in space, but according to Johnson, all of this is a waste of time, gentlemen, come and research the past of the earth, stop the research in space outside the galaxy, please, and take some time to know the civilizations The earth has been destroyed, take your time and the history of the solar system and the hundreds of planets that came to the sun with their stars over the course of tens of billions of years and hundreds of planets in the solar system collided with the sun with their stars collided with the sun and gas planets, how did you know all this? The impact of meteorites from planets that exploded and their elements collided with solar bodies, did you not notice this? Thousands of planets after they exploded hit the inner belts and outer belts of the solar system. Materials and elements from planets and stars that collided with gaseous planets. The hydrogen gas of those stars joined Uranus, Jupiter and Saturn, and from the last collisions between the stars of the arm of the galaxy, which collided with the gas planets, Jupiter still burns due to the collision of the stars of the arm of the galaxy. I have known this simple matter for many years. I took away secrets by referring to the creators and creators of the earth, who gave me messages in the Surahs of Evolution and the Lord about the shape of the continents that were formed by humans, the seas and continents that were on the earth a hundred million years before those humans before us. They lived and had several million years of civilization and their civilization was destroyed due to the collision of several planets with the sun, which means that human life was destroyed a hundred million years ago, but again, life from bacteria and single cells appeared on the earth, but humans on the earth worshiped God. When they removed the skulls of the people, the souls of those people came out completely from their heads and they were placed in special coffins. At the time of their death, and the souls of those people, when the bones of the skull were removed, it came out more complete and bigger, and those great spirits a hundred million years ago with Feeding on the oxygen of the air, they grew up in the sky and the earth and became the souls of the lords of the earth. You should know that if you do this experiment on the earth and remove the skulls of the bones of the dead and later put those human bodies in special coffins so that The soul of those people should make an exit way that after forty days or two months, when the soul comes out from the center of the cytoplasm tissues, it will be placed in a spherical tank made of glass. Because the soul is very light, when the body of the corpse leaks, it leaks and The gas of the cells of all the flesh tissue and the brain due to the disintegration of the cells and the production of a lot of gas, the commander of the cell, which is the tissue of the soul, from the central parts of the brain and the organs of the corpse, trillions of cells come out and move upwards, when the soul and the body of the soul, respectively They are formed in the cerebellum, they are gathered together in a certain order, and the shape of the human soul is exactly the same as the person who was alive. I have seen the curtain that the Lord and God have revealed. I will discuss this issue in the next comments. For now, may God protect you and I hope to meet you soon to tell you the story of the earthlings. Dr. Kesiri Kathiri, Tehran, Iran time 1:08 am

      • Hottan Raideyatin | December 26, 2023 at 12:03 am | Reply

        Dr. Kasiri,

        I actually read your comments. They are surreal. I don’t understand their purpose, or what your intent is. Somehow though, I feel like you’re a real person. Removing the skulls of people, placing them in special coffins? Sunan Abi Dawud 4839, the messenger of Allah spoke in a distinct manner so that anyone who listened to him could understand it. I don’t understand you.

        If Allah is, then nature is his will, beyond the Quran and Hadith. The Mutaazilites were correct, in that by understanding nature, we can learn beyond any holy book. History shows the golden age of Islam was the age of the Mutaazilite philosophy. Hadith Jami` at-Tirmidhi 2646, “the messenger of Allah said “Whoever takes a path upon which to obtain knowledge, Allah makes the path to Paradise easy for him.””. This article is not “a waste of time”. Whatever God is to you, you can be closer to God by learning about astrophysical jets. The Hubble telescope has taken photos of them, and they’re incredibly beautiful. Take a look.

        • This Kasiri person is obviously schizophrenic. His post is an obvious, rambling word salad. For some reason, such people are drawn to science fora in increasing numbers.

  2. BibhutibhusanPatel | December 24, 2023 at 5:10 am | Reply

    Rotation of galaxy is a theory(though Law),and can not be measured by experiment.Rotation of supermassive black hole is equal to the rotation of star(s).So,all measured value found in this experiment are exact;without any excuse,so,good and thanks for binary jets due to supermassive black hole and stars separately.Values consistent with Star Dynamics.From the Galaxy Dynamics of Rotation,ĺink of M87 jet with òthers(galaxies) can be determined;as this is done here for our own galaxy milky way through star,the sun.

    • Please stop commenting on stuff you don’t understand. We can’t measure the rotational velocity of a black hole, but we can measure the rotational velocity of the accretion disk around it using Doppler shift of emitted light. No need for stars.

      “Rotation of galaxy is a theory(though Law)…” – what the actual f*** are you babbling about?

  3. Howard Jeffrey Bender, Ph.D. | December 24, 2023 at 7:32 pm | Reply

    Ever wonder why (and how) supermassive Black Holes expel jets of anything rather than sucking them in? One view of String Theory suggests that active galaxies, including radio galaxies, Seyfert galaxies, and Quasars, may be explained with branes (dimensional membranes) at their centers rather than Black Holes. This view also explains those curious low surface brightness galaxies like Malin 1. Specifics on this can be found by searching YouTube for “Active Galaxies – A String Theory Way”

    • I don’t wonder, because black holes don’t expel jets of matter – the accretion disk does. Nothing comes out from inside the event horizon. Hopefully, this fixes one of the education gaps in your Ph.D.

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.