### MICROSCOPE Mission Presents Most Precise Test of General Relativity’s Weak Equivalence Principle

In new research, a team of scientists demonstrates the most precise test ever of the Weak Equivalence Principle, a key component of the theory of general relativity. A pair of new studies on the research will be published today (September 14) in *Physical Review Letters* and a special issue of *Classical and Quantum Gravity*. The report describes the final results from the MICROSCOPE mission, which tested the principle by measuring accelerations of free-falling objects in a satellite orbiting Earth. The team found that the accelerations of pairs of objects differed by no more than about one part in 10^{15 } ruling out any violations of the Weak Equivalence Principle or deviations from the current understanding of general relativity at that level.

“We have new and much better constraints for any future theory, because these theories must not violate the equivalence principle at this level,” says Gilles Métris. He is a scientist at Côte d’Azur Observatory and member of the MICROSCOPE team.

Published by Albert Einstein in 1915, the theory of general relativity describes how gravity works and relates to time and space. However, it does not account for the observations of quantum phenomena. Therefore, scientists look for deviations from the theory at increasing levels of precision and in various situations. Such violations would indicate new interactions or forces that could unite relativity with quantum physics. Testing the Weak Equivalence Principle (WEP) is one way to search for potential expansions to general relativity.

Objects in a gravitational field fall in the same way when no other forces are acting on them, even if they have different masses or compositions, according to the WEP. To test the principle, the MICROSCOPE team designed their experiment to measure the Eötvös ratio — which relates the accelerations of two free-falling objects — to an extremely high precision. If the acceleration of one object differs from the other’s by more than about one part in 10^{15}, the experiment would measure it and detect this violation of the WEP.

To measure the Eötvös ratio, the researchers monitored the accelerations of platinum and titanium alloy test masses as they orbited Earth in the MICROSCOPE satellite. Electrostatic forces were used by the experimental instrument to keep pairs of test masses in the same position relative to each other and looked for potential differences in these forces, which would indicate differences in the objects’ accelerations.

A significant challenge of the experiment was finding ways to test the instrument on Earth to make sure it would work as designed in space. “The difficulty is that the instrument we launch cannot operate on the ground,” says Manuel Rodrigues, a scientist at the French aerospace lab ONERA and member of the MICROSCOPE team. “So it’s a kind of blind test.”

Once the instrument was ready, it was launched by the team in 2016. They released preliminary results in 2017, but they continued to analyze the data, accounting for glitches and systematic uncertainties, after the mission ended in 2018. They ultimately found no violation of the WEP, setting the most stringent constraints on the principle yet.

The team’s work paves the way for even more precise tests of the WEP with satellite experiments. Their analysis includes ways to improve the experimental setup, like reducing crackles in the satellite’s coating that affected acceleration measurements and replacing wires in the setup with contactless devices. A satellite experiment that implements these upgrades should be able to measure potential violations of the WEP at the level of one part in 10^{17}, the researchers say. But the MICROSCOPE results will likely remain the most precise constraints on the WEP for a while.

“For at least one decade or maybe two, we don’t see any improvement with a space satellite experiment,” Rodrigues says.

References:

14 September 2022, *Physical Review Letters*.

DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.129.121102

14 September 2022, *Classical and Quantum Gravity*.

Issue

1. Topological vortex and anti-vortex field pairs generate or annihilate at the limit points, and encounter, split or merge at the bifurcation points of the 3-dimensional vector order parameter. They can form unstable point defects system.

2. The most raw field and interaction in the universe can be written in terms of the topological vortex and anti-vortex field pairs.

3. The gravitation that comes from the topological vortex and anti-vortex field pairs is the beginning of all things, and is the most raw power for maintaining and connecting the world.

4. The unified field theory can be written in terms of the interaction for topological vortex and anti-vortex field pairs that is topological vortex and anti-vortex field = matter and anti-matter = monopole particles = graviton.

https://pic2.zhimg.com/v2-4127b0b58fe8b88feb27c189fb705029_1440w.jpg?source=172ae18b.

In the development of human being sciences and humanities, the shameful act of calling a stag as a horse has begun more and more objectionable.

The shameful and unbridled behavior is an extreme disrespect for science. The physical meaning of parity conservation is left and right symmetry. For elementary particles, the spin direction does not affect the physical properties of particles.

The complex interaction of topological vortices is the basis of the formation and evolution of cosmic matter. One is vortex, more is different. This is the physical essence of the theory of condensed matter. Scientific research cannot be separated from seeking truth from facts. We should see the essence through phenomena and act according to nature low. Many strange things are actually not strange.

From accretion disks to quantum spins, countless facts show that the interaction and balance of topological vortex gravitational fields are indispensable in the formation and evolution of cosmic matter. The mathematics has also clearly told us that the topological vortex gravitational field can evolve into a complex space-time structure from the cusp singularity. However, contemporary physics has always regarded understanding as muddle headed, starting from the top-level design and developing wantonly towards pseudoscience. Wrong world outlook and scientific outlook may mislead a generation, even several generations. If you are interested, you can browse https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/463666584.

1. To measure the speed of light in vacuum, the range of vacuum must be determined first.

2. If the range of vacuum cannot be determined, do not tell the public that the speed of light you measure is the speed of light in vacuum.

3. As long as there are lights, rays, beam or various energy waves in the space, it cannot be called vacuum.

4. According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, the speed of light in vacuum is an intrinsic attribute of light, which is independent of the selected reference system.

5. According to the theory of topological vortex gravitational field, the vacuum range between the two ends of light is uncertain, which can be infinite great or infinitely small, depending on the physical environment of the space where light is located.

The origin of the asymmetry of matter and antimatter is one of the most challenging problems in particle physics and cosmology. The hierarchical structure of matter and the way it interacts are crucial to understand matter and antimatter. Topological vortices are points in 2D fields and lines in 3D fields (as they have codimension two). Studies had confirmed that the interactions with two point vortices as the initial condition can form complex space-time structures. Symmetry is mainly expressed between topological vortex and anti-vortex, rather than between the high-dimensional space-time matter formed by their interaction. Topological vortex can be infinitely large or infinitely small. From the cosmic space accretion disk to the quantum spin, nothing is different.

According to the topological vortex field theory, the topological vortex gravitational field is the source of all things. They form a new space-time structure through superposition, deflection and kink, and are the inexhaustible motive force of mass, inertia and various forms of energy.

According to the topological vortex field theory, quantum gravity comes from the interaction between topological vortex gravitational fields. From the cosmic space accretion disk to the quantum spin, the topological vortex gravitational fields are everywhere.

Numerous topological vortices and their twin anti-vortices interact with each other to form a world that human eyes see and do not see. Symmetry is mainly manifested in the topological vortex and its twin anti-vortex, but not in the high-dimensional space-time matter formed by their interaction. From the cosmic space accretion disk to the quantum spin, this interaction is everywhere.

Topological vortex is a natural gravitational field. Mass, inertia and various forms of energy are the result of the interaction of topological vortices. In fact, each topological vortex is the unity of opposites of left rotation and right rotation, which is not only for the observers, that is the same in the interaction of vortices. There is no eternal mass, only eternal fluid mechanics.

In fact, each topological vortex is the unity of opposites of left rotation and right rotation, which is not only for the observers, that is the same in the interaction of vortices. There is no eternal mass, only eternal fluid mechanics.

Contemporary physics has been fooled by pseudoscience. Topological vortex is a natural gravitational field. According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, gravity is the source of all things and the most raw force to maintain and connect the world. Mathematics tells us that topological vortex can form complex space-time structure by interaction. Mathematics does not tell us that there must be God particles, neutrinos, bosons and fermions. That the imaginary microscopic particles with certain physical properties, even if they exist, are also the result of topological vortex interaction. Everything is the interaction of topological vortices from the cosmic space accretion disk to the quantum spin. The end of science is mathematics, not theology and wishful thinking.

Symmetries are power. For centuries, symmetries have allowed physicists to find underlying connections and fundamental relationships throughout the universe. The symmetry of topological vortex and its anti-vortex conform to the all characteristics of matter and antimatter scales in the ground state. We have observed that the vortex field is indeed everywhere, from the quantum spin to accretion disk in cosmos. That just are the implications of the vortex field for particle physics and cosmology.

Many physical phenomena observed in scientific experiments are often not the whole picture, let alone the essence, the hidden variables in which are closely related to symmetry. Scientific research is inseparable from seeking truth from facts. We should see the essence through the phenomenon and act according to the laws of nature, rather than distorting the facts and making arbitrary inference. Parity non-conservation and symmetry breaking are appearances, not the essence of nature.From the cosmic space accretion disk to the quantum spin, what is the fact of the space-time background. Why does contemporary physics turn a blind eye to vortex and pursue the so-called string instead. What gives the vortex the power of endless rotation. Why give up the natural gravitational field of vortex and look for the source of gravity everywhere. Humans are great because they are good at thinking.

In particle physics, an elementary particle or fundamental particle is not composed of other particles. Dirac equation predicted every fundamental particle in the universe has an antiparticle – its identical twin but with opposite charge. That are parity conservation (P), charge conjugation (C) and time reversal (T) are the nature feature of elementary particles.The essence of mass, inertia and various forms of energy is the interaction of elementary particles. According to the modern discoveries in physics, fundamental forces and elementary particles can be written in terms of a pair of physical and virtual fields. Topological vortex and anti-vortex fields always appear in pairs. They perfectly reflect the exact symmetry under the simultaneous transformation of parity conservation (P), charge conjugation (C) and time reversal (T). As a result,Topological vortex and anti-vortex field pairs had all the physical characteristics of elementary particles.

Special Statement

1. Contemporary physics has long been misled by so-called academic journals and scientific associations.

2. According to the topological vortex field theory, topological vortex and its twin anti-vortex mirror each other. Symmetry is mainly expressed between topological vortex and its twin anti-vortex, but not between the high-dimensional space-time matter formed after their interaction.

3. Whether two objects are mirror images of each other must meet two requirements, one is simultaneous transformation, the other is precise symmetry, both of which are indispensable.

4. Please speak with facts. Which of the above two requirements can be achieved by the artificial inversion of two groups of Cobalt-60?

5.It is not rigorous to observe parity by using two sets of cobalt-60 reversals. Physical Review Letters has created the largest bug in the history of human science.

6. It is not rigorous to discuss parity between two objects that are not mirror images of each other. This discussion has no value or significance.

7. Science will eventually return to the right track, and it will not change for the misleading of Physical Review Letters and some so-called scientific associations.

The spin of topological vortex field covers all the long and short distance contributions of space-time motion, which is the basis of the evolution of space-time material motion. Scientific research has not found atoms, electrons, quanta and so-called neutrinos that are just a point and never spin.

Topological vortices are points in 2D fields. Two or more topological vortices interact together, in which the vortex cores or planes are deviated, or the vortex cores and planes all are deviated.

(1) Absolute Space-time

The cores of the vortices are coincided, where the vortex planes of them are deviated from each other. This vortex field is defined as Absolute Space-time (AST). The typical geometric model is sphere.

(2) Quantum Space-time

The planes of the vortices are superimposed in the same easy-planes, where the vortex cores of them deviate. This vortex field is defined as Quantum Space-time (QST). The typical geometric model is Möbius strip.

(3) Relative Space-time

The cores and the planes of the vortices all are deviated from each other. This vortex field is defined as Relative Space-time (RST). The typical geometric model is cylinder.

Relativity describes the evolution of topological vortex in relative space-time (RST), while quantum mechanics describes the evolution of topological vortex in quantum space-time (QST). According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, both relativity and quantum mechanics are correct.

The essence of space-time movement is the dynamic evolution of one or countless points. Topological vortices are points in 2D fields. The end of science is mathematics, is the dynamic evolution of the mathematical symbol topological vortex, is the interaction and balance of the gravitational field of topological vortex, and is the unity of mathematics, physics and philosophy.

The theory of unity of opposites is the basis for dialectical materialism to understand all existence and movement relations, and is the essence and core of materialistic dialectics. The essence of philosophy for Schrödinger’s cat is the unity of opposites. Topological vortex is point in 2D field. Observing the vortex simultaneously in front and behind of 2D field, if clockwise rotation is observed in front of the vortex, then counterclockwise rotation will be observed in behind of the vortex. The unity of opposites of clockwise rotation and counterclockwise rotation, which is not only for the observers, that is the same in the interaction of vortices. Cat is a high-dimensional space-time material. It is unscientific to use cat to analogy low-dimensional space-time material. That can easily lead to misunderstanding and ambiguity. With the deepening of the study about topological vortex field, human science’s understanding about the laws of material motion is expected to be perfectly solved in topological space-time. Mr.Schrödinger’s half-dead cat and poison bottle should probably end and go into history. If you are interested, you can browse https://www.zhihu.com/column/c_1278787135349633024.

Fluid vortex is a point in the two-dimensional field, and its physical characteristics are more suitable to be described by energy rather than mass. According to the gravitational field theory of topological vortex, there are two kinds of vortex, one is constant temperature vortex, the other is variable temperature vortex.

Spin physics are vital for describing how our world is screwed together. Topological vortices are points with spin in 2D fields.They are natural gravitational fields. According to topological vortex gravitational field theory, the VA field pair interact to form topological bifurcation that make up the fundamental understructure of various particles.

According to the gravitational field theory of topological vortices, before topological vortices interact, no one knows how topological vortices will connect with the outside world. Topological vortex and its identical twin anti-vortex may be the most raw field and interaction in the universe. They exhibit a rotational motion around a fixed guiding center, the nature of them are gravitational field. Gravity is the key to understanding the unified world.Science cannot be separated from seeking truth from facts. For pseudoscience in academic journals, please do not expect that few people understand it. Scientific research can be to imagine and guess, but it should not be reckless so as to seriously deviate from nature and the essence of science.

Mathematics is the language in which humans write the universe. Mathematics does not tell humans that elementary particles must be spherical, but can be unipolar. That suggest elementary particles may be two-dimensional matter. Topological vortices are points with spin in 2D fields. According to topological vortex gravitational field theory, the interaction of two or more vortices can form a complex space-time structure. Everything thrives on spin.

Many physical phenomena observed in scientific experiments are often not the whole picture, let alone the essence. Scientific research is inseparable from seeking truth from facts. We should see the essence through the phenomenon and act according to the laws of nature, rather than distorting the facts and making arbitrary inference. According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, the antielectron, antiproton, antineutron and antiquarks found in current scientific experiments are just coincidences in physical experiments. Matter and antimatter are only used to describe the “Schrödinger’s box” before it is opened, and cannot be used to describe the “Schrödinger’s box” after it is opened.The topic involves the essential differences between microscopic particles and elementary particles. The spatiotemporal structures of topological vortices before and after interaction are different.

String Theory and CP Violation are pseudoscience. According to the gravitational field theory of topological vortex, the physical real mirror image of nature only exists between the topological vortex and its twin antivortex.

Scientific research should not be always a blind man touchs an elephant, and adhere to that unremittingly.

According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, the following conclusions can be drawn:

1. Relativity and quantum mechanics are correct in their respective fields. However, they must be understood correctly.

2. String theory is a pseudoscience, which has no factual basis whether in the macroscopic scale of the universe or the microscopic scale of quantum.

3. CP violation is a blatant sophistry and a pseudoscience.

4. Many papers in so-called academic journals such as Science, Nature and PRL are pseudoscience.

5. Many established and ongoing research projects are destined to have no results or end up with Interpreting it in an incorrect way.

6. Nobel Prize and the so-called scientific association were misled by the so-called academic journals, and many awards were awarded to pseudoscience.

Scientific research must eventually return to the right track, and it will not be changed because it was misled by so-called academic journals and scientific associations. Author sincerely hope that the academic community can wake up as soon as possible.

Symmetries are power. For centuries, symmetries have allowed physicists to find underlying connections and fundamental relationships throughout the universe. For physics, CP violation is equivalent to self defeating martial arts.

What are microscopic particles? What are elementary particle? What is the essential difference between microscopic particles and elementary particle? In particle physics, an elementary particle or fundamental particle is not composed of other particles. Dirac equation predicted every fundamental particle in the universe has an antiparticle – its identical twin but with opposite charge.

In topology, a point in space-time may evolve into vortex-antivortex (VA) pairs by topological phase transition. The non-trivial topological phase has two singular points of zero reflection in the generalized parameter space, and their phase distributions support the optical vortex and antivortex, respectively. Optical vortices are characterized by a helical phase front and a phase singularity in the beam center, and are given a number called the topological charge according to how many twists the light does in one wavelength. The number is always an integer and can be positive or negative. Vortex beams with different topological charges are orthogonal, which suggests that high-dimensional multiplexing is possible.

Obviously, topological vortex is not composed of other particles and has an antivortex – its identical twin but with opposite charge. Topological vortex has all the physical characteristics of elementary particle.

In the world of topological vortices, there are no so-called dark clouds in the sky of physics, and the author will not take away any clouds. With the Schrödinger’s Cat Box slowly opened, the exciting moment to witness the history of science of mankind is coming. Please wait for more exciting moments.

Scientific research cannot do without correct and scientific theories. The fundamental reason why humans are different from other animals is that they have powerful theories based on logic and mathematics, which are applied in practice. The value of mathematics lies in its ability to make humans smarter and smarter, not more and more foolish. A correct understanding of the gravitational nature of topological vortices helps to understand Relativity and Quantum Mechanics correctly.

In 1996, Scientific American journalist John Horgan published “The End of Science: Facing the Limits of Knowledge in the Twilight of the Scientific Age”. The book has received a lot of attention and also received widespread criticism. This raises a question: What is the end of science?

According to the gravitational field theory of topological vortex, the End of Science is mathematics, is the topological vortex in mathematics, is the interaction and balance of topological vortex, and is the superposition, deflection and kink of topological vortex gravitational field.

The unity of chance and necessity, continuity and discontinuity in spatiotemporal motion runs through the interaction of topological vortices.

Topological vortex is not only a mathematical notation, but also a physical reality. The interaction and balance of them cover all long-distance and short-range contributions to spatiotemporal motion, and are the foundation of the evolution of spatiotemporal material motion. Vortex is a natural gravitational field. Quantum Mechanics and Relativity complement each other in the interaction of topological vortices gravitational field. They perfectly interpret the context of spatiotemporal motion.

Topological vortices are not only the superposition of both dextrorotatiom and levorotation, but also the superposition of both certainty and uncertainty. Without certainty, there would be no topological vortices. Without uncertainty, there would be no motion and evolution of topological vortices. Certainty and uncertainty are inseparable, then topological vortices and motion are inseparable.

According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, no particle can be independent from the world. The particles observed in scientific research activitys are never all of them.

If neutrino is independent from the world, and almost never interact with other matter, it must be a myth of the real world. Myth has nothing to do with science. The topological storm is coming, I can see the approaching steps of the spring for human scientific and technological revolution. Whoever has mastered the topological vortex gravitational field is expected to become the master of the universe.

If neutrino is independent from the world, and almost never interact with other matter, it must be a myth of the real world. Myth has nothing to do with science. The topological vorte storm is coming, I can see the approaching steps of the spring for human scientific and technological revolution. Whoever has mastered the topological vortex gravitational field is expected to become the master of the universe.

Contemporary physics believes that the spin of the Higgs boson is zero. It can obtain mass through self interaction. According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, zero spin is one of the interaction modes of topological vortex. If the spin is zero, mass can be obtained. Topological vortices are more capable of obtaining mass in interactions. Without the interaction of topological vortices, it is impossible to explain the zero spin of the Higgs boson, is impossible to explain whether the Higgs boson has gravity, and is impossible to explain where the mass of the Higgs boson comes from. The mass and gravity of the Higgs boson cannot come from God. God is a myth, not mathematics, let alone science.

According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, the formation and propagation of light depend on the interaction and balance of topological vortex gravitational field. Therefore, in some cases, the propagation speed of light waves is equal to that of gravitational waves.

Physics needs to fully understand the beauty and power of mathematics. The interaction and balance of topological vortex gravitational field shows that mathematical concepts can indeed become the basic structure that dominates the physical world.

The vortex battery based on topology architecture may be the direction of future energy for human society. According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, the vortex battery based on the topological structure can have endless power. It is not impossible to borrow force from the expansion of the universe and shine together with the sun and stars.

The Shame of Contemporary Physics

One Open Letter to The Physical Review Letters

Dear Editor

A paper called “Question of Parity Conservation in Weak Interactions”. Which published by Physical Review Letters (PRL) in October 1956. It is pseudoscience. Here’s why.

1. If we don’t understand how θ & τ was formed, there will be no clear evidence to infer parity violation of them in weak interaction.

2. There is no clear evidence to suggest that two sets of cobalt-60 can be transformed into symmetry by rotating in opposite directions. Similarly, the motion of two hydrogen atoms – electrons around the nucleus – may not necessarily be symmetrical at the same time, even via reverse rotation.

Undoubtedly, the inference of parity violation in weak interaction is pseudoscience.

Yours sincerely,

Bao-hua ZHANG

Here is the Reply from PRL:

Your manuscript has been considered. We regret to inform you that we have concluded that it is not suitable for publication in any APS journal.

An Arduous Project to Fight Against Pseudoscience

Second Open Letter to Physical Review Letters and Reviews of Modern Physics

Dear Editor

The mathematics had clearly told us that the topological vortex gravitational field can evolve into a complex space-time structure from the cusp singularity. From accretion disks to quantum spins, countless facts show that the interaction and balance of topological vortex gravitational fields are indispensable in the formation and evolution of cosmic matter.

However, Physical Review Letters and Reviews of Modern Physics have been insisting on the wrong understanding, developing wantonly towards pseudoscience. Wrong world outlook and scientific outlook may mislead one generation, even several generations.

Topological vortex and its twin anti-vortex exhibit parity conservation (P), charge conjugation (C) and time reversal (T) symmetry. The physical real mirror image of nature can be exist between the topological vortex and its twin anti-vortex, not must be between the high-dimensional space-time matters formed by their interaction.

It is meaningless to discuss the CP of two particles (or things) that are not mirror images of each other. This type of discussion is full of deception and misleading. Its absurd aspect lies in:

1. Firstly, subjectively determine that two particles (or things) are mirror images of each other.

2. Subsequently, experimental detection revealed that the two particles (or things) are asymmetric.

The experiment showed that the previous subjective determination was incorrect. According to common sense, it should be concluded that the two particles (or things) are not mirror images of each other.

However, Physical Review Letters and Reviews of Modern Physics did not do so. Their conclusion is:

The two particles (or things) that are mirror images of each other are asymmetric.

This blatant sophistry and misleading behavior is undoubtedly a desecration to the scientific spirit and public wisdom.

Best wishes to you,

Bao-hua ZHANG

Here is the Reply from Physical Review Letters:

Your letter has been considered. We regret to inform you that we have concluded that it is not suitable for publication in any APS journal.

Here is the Reply from Reviews of Modern Physics:

We judged that manuscript to be unsuitable for consideration by any journal in the Physical Review–Reviews of Modern Physics collection. It does not change our conclusion, and we will not consider it. I now must ask you kindly not to communicate with us further about this matter.

Their position of holding together to keep warm and maintain pseudoscience is clear. The so-called peer review of Physical Review Letters and Reviews of Modern Physics, has become a widely recognized joke. The awards, honors, and so-called scientific events related to them are full of greed and hypocrisy.

Research misconduct has reduced today’s physics to the realm of God, angels, and cats.

According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, the material world is a whole of interactions and connections. The change of symmetry is always the Symmetry-Readjusted, not the Symmetry-Broken. Any physical phenomenon observed in scientific research will not be its entirety, falsifiable is more important than confirmation. Perhaps one day, humans will truly understand the immense power of symmetry.

The following text is generated by the Bing Chat AI.

Topological vortex gravitational field theory is a theoretical framework that attempts to explain the behavior of gravitational fields using topological vortices. Topological vortices are a type of topological defect that can occur in certain physical systems, including superfluids and superconductors. In the context of gravitational fields, topological vortices are thought to arise due to the curvature of spacetime, and they may be responsible for phenomena such as gravitational waves and the formation of black holes. The theory suggests that these vortices can interact and combine in complex ways, leading to the formation of more complex structures in the gravitational field. While still a developing area of research, topological vortex gravitational field theory shows promise for providing a deeper understanding of the fundamental nature of gravity and its interactions with other physical phenomena.

Under the framework of topological vortex gravitational fields, the boundary between science and Pseudoscience is clear at a glance. The so-called academic journals and scientific associations should have a better understanding of shame, hypocrisy, and greed than the public.

An Arduous Project to Fight Against Pseudoscience （Part Two）

One Open Letter to Proceedings of The National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)

Dear Editor

A paper called “Question of Parity Conservation in Weak Interactions”. Which published by Physical Review Letters (PRL) in October 1956. It is pseudoscience. Here’s why.

1. If we don’t understand how θ & τ was formed, there will be no clear evidence to infer parity violation of them in weak interaction.

2. There is no clear evidence to suggest that two sets of cobalt-60 can be transformed into symmetry by rotating in opposite directions. Similarly, the motion of two hydrogen atoms – electrons around the nucleus – may not necessarily be symmetrical at the same time, even via reverse rotation.

Undoubtedly, the inference of parity violation in weak interaction is pseudoscience.

However, here is an introduction to CP violations by PNAS （Physicists dig deep to seek the origin of matter | https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1908959116.)

If CP-symmetry is not violated, then the matter and antimatter that would have been produced in equal amounts in the early universe would have been annihilated, leaving behind only radiation, whereas theories with CP-violation can explain why, as the universe evolved, a little more matter survived than antimatter, and that makes up the matter we see.

Still, the amount of violation is not enough to explain the excess of matter. So, physicists have begun looking for CP-violation in other classes of particles, such as leptons, the group which includes electrons and neutrinos, among others.

Who told PNAS that a ittle more matter survived than antimatter, is it God?

Yours sincerely,

Bao-hua ZHANG

Here is the Reply from PNAS:

Thank you for submitting your Letter to the Editor for publication in PNAS. This is now the third letter you’ve submitted for consideration to our journal with same title and the same issues we noted to you previously. As we said, letters submitted to our journal must respond to manuscripts published at PNAS in the last six months. Your letter does not respond to any manuscripts published with PNAS in the last 6 months and we must reject your submitted letter for this reason.

We appreciate your interest in PNAS and encourage you to submit in the future. If you have any questions about the submission requirements, please feel free to contact our office.

This reply is very standard and elegant.

PNAS is neither a hypocrite nor a spokesman for the Pseudoscience community, and was just claiming that a little more matter survived than antimatter.

Sorry, your questions are outdated in PNAS’s rules.

Today’s physics has long been in line with theology rather than science, which is the vilest and unforgettable era in the history of human science. It deceives and mocks the wisdom of the public, which can be described as unprecedented.

Topological vortex and its antivortex always appear in pairs. Mathematics does not support that a little more vortex than its antivortex. What is the basis for contemporary physics to believe that vortex and its antivortex must not be matter and its antimatter?

In the scientific research, falsifiable is more important than confirmation.

According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, symmetry is mathematics, a natural creation, and asymmetry is a local manifestation of symmetric in interaction. If there is God’s creation of the world, then symmetry is God.

Topological phase transition can be the indication of parity conservation. It may indicate that”God” is really not”left-handed”. The query, debate, countless attempts and amendments go on and on. Perhaps the day will come after all, in which man can truly understand and realize the great power of symmetry.

https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/269980366.

Planck length and time are Pseudoscience. According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, the essence of time is the rotation of topological vortex, which is both absolute and relative. Therefore, spatiotemporal motion is both continuous and discontinuous.

https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/546430166.

An Arduous Project to Fight Against Pseudoscience （Part Three）

One Open Letter to Science

Dear Editor

I’m sorry to bother you.

Mathematics is known as the language of science. The mathematics had clearly told us that the topological vortex gravitational field can evolve into a complex space-time structure from the cusp singularity. From accretion disks to quantum spins, countless facts show that the interaction and balance of topological vortex gravitational fields are indispensable in the formation and evolution of cosmic matter.

However, contemporary physics has always regarded understanding as muddle headed, starting from the top-level design and developing wantonly towards pseudoscience.

A paper called “Question of Parity Conservation in Weak Interactions”. Which published by Physical Review Letters (PRL) in October 1956. It is pseudoscience. Here’s why.

1. If we don’t understand how θ & τ was formed, there will be no clear evidence to infer parity violation of them in weak interaction.

2. There is no clear evidence to suggest that two sets of cobalt-60 can be transformed into symmetry by rotating in opposite directions. Similarly, the motion of two hydrogen atoms – electrons around the nucleus – may not necessarily be symmetrical at the same time, even via reverse rotation.

Undoubtedly, the inference of CP violation in weak interaction is pseudoscience.

The author had written multiple letters to so-called academic journals such as Proceedings of The National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), Physical Review Letters (PRL), Reviews of Modern Physics, etc, pointing out that the CP violation is a pseudoscience. They all have been persistently refusing and avoiding this topic.

symmetry is mathematics, a natural creation, and asymmetry is a local manifestation of symmetric in interaction. If there is God’s creation of the world, then symmetry is God.

Science must seek truth from facts and not tolerate any falsehood. The violation of CP symmetry enables physicists to make an absolute distinction between matter and antimatter, which is a pseudoscience misled by the superficial phenomena of facts. The misconception poses a huge dilemma for today’s physics. That make the origin of the asymmetry of matter and antimatter come one of the most challenging problems in particle physics and cosmology.

The inference of CP-violation can explain why a little more matter survived than antimatter. Which leads to many established and ongoing research projects are destined to have no expected results or end up via interpreting it in an incorrect way. The Nobel Prize and some scientific association were misled by the fallacies, so that many awards were awarded to pseudoscience.

Scientific research can be to imagine and guess, but it should not be reckless so as to seriously deviate from nature and the essence of science.

If physical science misrepresents and deviates from mathematics seriously, can it still be called science?

Science must accept being questioned and debated in order to progress and develop. Science is a member of important impact academic journal. The author hope that Science will take on the responsibility corresponding to its own name, guide the public to debate whether local asymmetry can indicate CP violation.

In the development and progress of science, falsification is more important than confirmation.

Best wishes for you,

Bao-hua ZHANG

Here is the Reply from Science:

Thank you for submitting your manuscript “Three Open Letters to Science” to Science. Unfortunately, this is not the sort of work that we publish and we are thus not considering it for publication. We appreciate your interest in Science.

The popularization of scientific knowledge has a long way to go. It is an arduous project to fight against pseudoscience. In particular, so-called academic journals, such as Proceedings of The National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), Physical Review Letters (PRL), Reviews of Modern Physics, Science, etc, should not be kidnapped by pseudo-academic groups, and are not only the spokesman of Pseudoscience, but also the guardian.

https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/574723221

The physical phenomena observed in scientific research are often not complete. Symmetry-Broken is pseudoscience misled by the local manifestation in interactions of symmetric. In the scientific research, falsification is more important than confirmation.

According to the gravitational field theory of topological vortices, the interaction and balance between topological vortices are the adjustment of system symmetry, not system symmetry breaking. Symmetry-Readjusted is more in line with natural laws than Symmetry-Broken.

It is vital for scientific research to explore and understand how the symmetry of the system is adjusted and causes local symmetry changes (so-called Symmetry-Broken).

In the scientific research, falsifiable is more important than confirmation.

Space is unbounded forever, meaning that any point in space is the center of space. Topological vortex is the point defect in space. According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, with the perfect fluid as the background, spatiotemporal motion is the interaction of countless topological vortex fields.

Therefore, the essence of time is the rotation of topological vortex, it is a circular arrow, although it has only one direction, any point on the ring can be the beginning and end.

Each topological vortex field has its own spin period. As a result, time is both absolute and relative in the interaction of topological vortices.

Perfect fluid does not actually exist in nature, but sometimes used research for fluid flow problems.

The material world is a whole of interactions and connections. Any physical phenomenon observed in scientific research will not be its entirety.

The reason why humans are great is because they are good at creating wealth with their thoughts. In the face of ideas and wealth, compared to humans, lower animals always see only physical objects and bread. Fighting against Pseudoscience is related to the fate of human society in the future world.

Physical Review Letters and Reviews of Modern Physics sing in unison, and practice the most blatant shamelessness in the history of physics through practical actions.

Physics must face up to the problem of gravity, otherwise, it is easy to fall into the quagmire of Pseudoscience.

Gravitation is the beginning of all things, and is the most raw power for maintaining and connecting the world. According to the modern discoveries in physics, fundamental forces and elementary particles can be written in terms of a pair of physical and virtual fields. The topological vortex gravitational fields perfectly reflect the exact symmetry under the simultaneous transformation of parity conservation (P), charge conjugation (C) and time reversal (T). They may be the gravitons that physics has been looking for. Topologically trivial (N=0) graviton pairs undergo Kelvin motion, while nontrivial (N=±1) graviton pairs behave a rotational motion around a fixed guiding center. The point defects in the bifurcation processes of the graviton pairs generate or annihilate at the limit points, and encounter, split or merge at the bifurcation points of the 3-dimensional vector order parameter, and form unstable point defects system.

According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, no particle can be independent from the world. The particles observed in scientific research activitys are never all of them. Asymmetry is a local manifestation of symmetric and its interaction. Symmetry is a fundamental part of geometry, nature, and shapes. It creates patterns that help us organize our world conceptually. If there is God’s creation of the world, then symmetry is God.

Pseudoscience is very popular in academic circles, there are not many experimental results that can receive scientific evaluation.

An Arduous Project to Fight Against Pseudoscience （Part Four）

One Open Letter to Nature

Dear EditorA paper called “Question of Parity Conservation in Weak Interactions”. Which published by Physical Review Letters (PRL) in October 1956. It is pseudoscience. Here’s why.

1.If we don’t understand how θ & τ was formed, there will be no clear evidence to infer parity violation of them in weak interaction.

2.There is no clear evidence to suggest that two sets of cobalt-60 can be transformed into symmetry by rotating in opposite directions. Similarly, the motion of two hydrogen atoms – electrons around the nucleus – may not necessarily be symmetrical at the same time, even via reverse rotation.

Undoubtedly, the inference of CP violation in weak interaction is pseudoscience.

The author had written multiple letters to so-called academic journals such as Physical Review Letters (PRL), Reviews of Modern Physics, Science, etc, pointing out CP violation is pseudoscience. They all have been persistently refusing and avoiding this topic.

Science must accept being questioned and debated in order to progress and develop. Nature is one of the important impact academic journal. The author hopes Nature can guide the public in debating to the CP violation, so as to set the record straight.

Yours sincerely,

Bao-hua ZHANG

Here is the Reply from Nature:

In the present case, while CP violation is pseudoscience may well prove stimulating to others’ thinking about such questions, we are unable to conclude that the work provides the sort of firm advance in general understanding.

Today’s science has long been in line with pseudoscience and theology rather than science, which is the vilest and unforgettable era. It deceives and mocks the wisdom of the public, do cheekiness things openly and unscrupulously, which can be described as unprecedented in the history of human science.

The so-called peer review of the pseudo-scholarship journal (such as Physical Review Letters, Reviews of Modern Physics, Science, Nature, etc) had become a widely recognized joke. They unite to ban scientific ideas, which highlights the dirty soul inherent in these Pseudo-scholarship journals. The awards, honors, and so-called scientific events related to them are full of greed and hypocrisy.

Principles of the Theory of Vortex Gravitation.

The developed theory proves that a universal vortex motion, along with the pressure variation in a space continuum called ether, is actually the source of the universal gravitation and creation of celestial bodies and their motion in the Universe. Calculations of the gravitation forces are carried out on the basis of the laws of mechanics of continua and (or) aerodynamics with the use of the Navier-Stokes equations. As a result of the solution, an algebraic formula for the gravitation forces is obtained. The reliability of this formula is supported by its conformity to the astronomical data, and also to the Newton empirical formula for universal gravitation. The main advantage of the proposed theory is that, on the basis of it, it is possible to explain all the phenomena and laws observed in the cosmic space, viz.: motion of celestial bodies; mutual closing and moving away of galaxies; an origin of celestial bodies, black holes, and the Universe as a whole; the nature of gravity; the speed of gravitation; the strengths of magnetic fields of celestial bodies, etc.

https://arxiv.org/ftp/astro-ph/papers/0410/0410365.pdf.

Perfect fluid (such as ether, it was assumed to be weightless, transparent, frictionless, undetectable chemically or physically, and literally permeating all matter and space) does not actually exist in nature, but sometimes used research for fluid flow problems.

Mathematics describes the principles of vortex gravitation. Topology reveal that vortices are created by symmetry.

Topological vortex batteries are the direction of future energy for human society. Whoever has mastered the vortex battery may have mastered the future of human society.

According to the topological vortex gravitational field theory, gravitation is the source of all things and the most essential force to maintain and connect the world. Symmetry is only shown between topological vortices and their twin anti-vortices, not between the high-dimensional spatiotemporal matter formed after their interaction.

It is unrealistic to find symmetry between high-dimensional spatiotemporal matter. topological vortex gravitational fields perfectly reflect the exact symmetry under the simultaneous transformation of parity conservation (P), charge conjugation (C) and time reversal (T). They can be the gravitons that physics has been looking for. CP violation is the most magnificent farce created by Physical Review Letters in the history of science.

Science will eventually return to the right track, and it will not change due to the misleading nature of the Physical Review Letters.

Dao Lang’s new song “Luochahai City” has become popular, and can the lyrics be understood by today’s physics? Can the academic community understand the implied meaning that the Mahu is also a bird is a fundamental problem for us humans (at the end of the song) ? The ugliness and chaos conveyed by the lyrics are worse in academia than in the entertainment industry.

Under the framework of topological vortex gravitational field, everything described by quantum mechanics will no longer be mysterious. Schrödinger’s cat essentially used high-dimensional spatiotemporal matter to analogize low-dimensional spatiotemporal matter, which is extremely wrong and irresponsible. This behavior can easily lead physics towards theology and pseudoscience.

Low dimensional spatiotemporal matter is the foundation of high-dimensional spatiotemporal matter. Topological vortices are point defects in two-dimensional spacetime. Point defects do not only impact the thermodynamic properties, but are also central to kinetic processes. According to the topological vortex gravity field theory, vortex gravity is the source of all things and the most essential force that maintains and connects the world.

Vortex gravity can exist or not. When vortex gravity does not exist, it can be accurate to zero. If vortex gravity exists, it can be infinitely large or infinitely small depending on the speed of rotation or the number of turns

Only by specifying specific field points and conditions, and obtaining constants under specific conditions through experiments, can it be possible to balance the influence of hidden vortex variables and obtain specific values of gravity. Any act or attempt to obtain accurate values of all gravity from nature is extremely absurd and ridiculous.

In today’s physics and so-called science, the understanding of microscopic particles is mostly limited to spheres. However, mathematics does not tell us that the basic structure of matter must be spherical, but it can be two-dimensional. Topological vortices are point defects in two-dimensional spacetime. Point defects do not only impact the thermodynamic properties, but are also central to kinetic processes. According to topological vortex gravitational field theory, the interactions and balances of topological vortex fields cover all short-distance and long-distance contributions, and are the basis of the formation and evolution of cosmic matter. Understanding how topological vortices interact with each other is more conducive to a scientific understanding of the so-called symmetry breaking.

Symmetry is essential for solving problems or delving further into research. It is hard to imagine that much progress could have been made in deducing the laws of nature without the existence of certain symmetries in the irregular initial conditions. Symmetry principles dictate the form of the laws of nature.

Mathematics is known as the language of science. Any assumption or speculation that deviates from mathematics, regardless of who or what institution it comes from, is considered pseudoscience.

The most absurd aspect of contemporary physics and so-called science lies in imagining elementary particles as spheres and analogizing quantum with cats.

Mathematics does not tell us that the basic structure of matter must be spherical, but it can be a point defect. Point defects do not only impact the thermodynamic properties, but are also central to kinetic processes. Topological vortices are point defects in two-dimensional spacetime.Understanding how topological vortices interact with each other is more conducive to a scientific understanding of the Low dimensional spatiotemporal material structure that can be the basic understructure of microscopic particles.

Low dimensional spatiotemporal matter is the basic underlying structure of high-dimensional spatiotemporal matter. So far, relativity and quantum mechanics are the most successful theories for describing the essence of spacetime. If the so-called elementary particles and microscopic particles are high-dimensional spatiotemporal matter, rather than low-dimensional spatiotemporal matter, then using relativity and quantum mechanics to explain certain characteristics of elementary particles and microscopic particles may confuse people and potentially fall into the quagmire of pseudoscience.

Today’s physics and so-called science have been racing along this path, and they are unrepentant. This strange appearance sounds grand, but in fact, it is shameless.

It’s really heartbreaking.

It is shameless or shameful. I don’t know. Perhaps, as the Luochahai City sings, the ugliness and dirtiness of academia may be worse than those of the entertainment industry.

According to topological vortex gravitational field theory, many things are unobservable by humans. Humans should accept the fact that scientific experiments are limited by nature.

The task of particle physics is to use two-dimensional topological vortices to construct high-dimensional spatiotemporal structures that are beneficial for human society’s production, life, and survival, rather than searching around for so-called God particles.

Low dimensional spatiotemporal matter is the basic underlying structure of high-dimensional spatiotemporal matter. Topological vortices are point defects in two-dimensional spacetime. Point defects do not only impact the thermodynamic properties, but are also central to kinetic processes.

According to topological vortex gravitational field theory, quantum entanglement is the radiation effect of particles based on topological vortex interactions. This effect can occur simultaneously, in multiple places, and at multiple points.

One of the tasks of today’s science is to use these point defects to construct high-dimensional spatiotemporal structures that are beneficial for human production, life, and survival, rather than searching around for so-called God particles.

The dirty body beneath the glamorous appearance of contemporary physics should have been treated thoroughly long ago.

Relativity and quantum mechanics are the most successful theories to date in describing spacetime. Low dimensional spatiotemporal matter is the foundation of high-dimensional spatiotemporal matter. Topological vortices are two-dimensional spatiotemporal point defects. Point defects do not only impact the thermodynamic properties, but are also central to kinetic processes. It is extremely absurd and shameless to use a cat in high-dimensional spacetime to compare low dimensional spacetime point defects. The email response from the so-called peer review to me is even more absurd and shameless. When appropriate, I will comment one by one on my blog.

From the cosmic accretion disk to quantum spin, the vortex field is evident to all. The interaction and equilibrium of topological vortices cover all long-distance and short-distance contributions to spatiotemporal motion. Balance is the foundation of the evolution of the motion of matter in the universe.

Symmetry is essential for solving problems or delving further into research. It is hard to imagine that much progress could have been made in deducing the laws of nature without the existence of certain symmetries in the irregular initial conditions. Symmetry principles dictate the form of the laws of nature.

According to the theory of topological vortex gravitational field, strictly speaking, quantum mechanics describes one of the ways in which topological vortices interact with each other, rather than being limited to the interactions of so-called quantum, light, etc. For example, the Schrödinger equation is also applicable to describing the motion of certain celestial bodies, which is one of the forms of long-range topological vortex interactions.

One comment questioning, “Topological vortex can be infinitely large or infinitely small”, how does this assertion cohere with the “Topological vortices are points with spin in 2D fields.”?

The meaning of these two sentences is that topological vortices are points with spin in 2D fields, and the range involved in spinning around this point can be infinitely large or infinitely small. The topic involves the formation and superposition of topological vortices.

There is an interesting article. There is a description in it. There’s a spinning field, and that field is what gives rise to particles. Sebens asserts, in a way, Pauli and Lorentz were half-right: there isn’t a spinning particle.

They are all only half right. Because, according to topological vortex gravitational field theory, the spin field generates particles, celestial bodies, or physical structures through interactions, where the particles, celestial bodies, or physical structures can be rotating or non rotating.

If readers are interested, the article may be helpful for you to think about spin.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/quantum-particles-arent-spinning-so-where-does-their-spin-come-from/.

Although my English is poor, I think my expression that topological vortex can be infinitely large or infinitely smallis already very clear.

The statement is based on facts. Topological vortices may exist, or may not exist. If a vortex exists, its rotational speed and range may be infinitely large or infinitely small. If a vortex does not exist, its rotational speed and range can be precise to zero. The topic involves the formed environment and superposition of vortex formation.

If you are really interested in science, you can browse

https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/390071860.

If you are like so-called academic journals (such as PRL, PNAS, Sciences, etc) firmly believe in:

1. Even without understanding how θ & τ were formed, it can be concluded that they are CP violations.

2. Even if two objects (such as cobalt-60) that rotate in opposite directions are asymmetrical, they are still two objects that mirror each other.

Please stay away from here. Science is no longer with you. Stupid and stubborn had made you unaware of dirt and ugliness.

A comment questioning，“Topological vortices are points with spin in two-dimensional field. They are the natural gravitational field.” What does the Author intended to convey?

The expression of this sentence is already very clear. Rotation and spin are two different concepts. Rotation can be active or passive. However, spin is an active behavior and an inherent behavior of topological vortices. The only way to terminate and change the rotation of topological vortices is by superposition.

A vortex centered around the sun is not defined by the presence of planets in the solar system. Even if you remove all the planets in the solar system, vortices centered around the sun still exist.Ignorance and foolishness had made so-called peer reviews almost unaware of dirt and ugliness.

If you are really interested in science, you can browse

https://arxiv.org/ftp/astro-ph/papers/0410/0410365.pdf.

A comment questioned, in this manuscript, the authors are trying to investigate the interactions between topological vortices. However, I don’t see any experiments, theories or simulations. The images are just screenshots.

My manuscript discussed the synchronization of two-dimensional topological vortices. Please tell me which image you see in the manuscript is not two-dimensional. The essence of screenshots is freeze frame. The physical essence of freeze frame is synchronization. Each image in the manuscript is a synchronous of a model, a theory, and several entity two-dimensional vortices.

How do you determine that the vortices you see in a three-dimensional spatiotemporal simulation experiment must be the result of two-dimensional material interactions? Humans must accept the fact that scientific experiments are limited by nature. Just as the physical essence of the speed of light in Relativity is the synchronization of two events in a rigid body. There is no time difference in synchronization. In today’s physics, any observed speed of light with time difference in experiments is not the physical essence of the speed of light described by Relativity.

How do you ensure that the speed of light you measure is not disturbed by dark matter or dark energy between two points? How do you understand that the speed of light described by Relativity is independent of the reference frame?

Physics must synchronize with mathematics in order to scientifically understand the physical essence of natural phenomena, rather than blindly imagining them. If you are like so-called academic journals (such as PRL, PNAS, Sciences, etc) firmly believe in:

1. Even without understanding how θ & τ were formed, it can be concluded that they are CP violations.

2. Even if two objects (such as cobalt-60) that rotate in opposite directions are asymmetrical, they are still two objects that mirror each other.

Please stay away from here. Science is no longer with you. Ignorance and foolishness had made so-called peer reviews almost unaware of dirt and ugliness.

Mathematics is definitely a science. However, the so-called facts observed in physics experiments may not necessarily be scientific. Facts may make you believe in God, but mathematics does not.

Please tell me. Which of the two-dimensional materials you observed in the experiment or the two-dimensional images in mathematics is the true two-dimensional?

Humans must accept the fact that scientific experiments are limited by nature.

An Arduous Project to Fight Against Pseudoscience （Part Five）

Here is a Reply from a so-called academic journal.

Thank you for your submission to my journal. Our team has decided it does not meet the criteria for publication.

Any work published in my journal must be of a high standard and of scientific interest. It is also necessary for your manuscript to make a contribution to the literature. On this occasion, we did not feel that this was the case.

Comment

Topology is a science that truly describes nature. Topological figures not only show the beauty of mathematics, but also change the way people understand nature. Research on it can greatly expand the boundaries of human cognition.

“Everything should be made as simple as possible, but no simpler.” This is great quotes in science. It comes from Albert Einstein. It suggests that the movement of fundamental understructure in cosmos should be simpler and simpler. Point can be the most concise physical structure in cosmos.

Topological vortices are point defects in spacetime. Although the spin of topological vortex is beyond doubt, the so-called academic journal team still firmly believe in topological vortex cannot form gravitational forces centered around point defects.

The high standard and scientific interest of them are that they can imagine without mathematics, and can delude without facts. Just as the so-called academic journals (such as PRL, PNAS, Sciences, etc) firmly believe in:

1.Even without understanding how θ & τ were formed, it can be concluded that they are CP violations.

2.Even if two objects (such as cobalt-60) that rotate in opposite directions are asymmetrical, they are still two objects that mirror each other.

Stupid and stubborn had made the so-called academic journal team almost unaware of dirt and ugliness.

Today’s physics deceives and mocks the wisdom of the public, do cheekiness things openly and unscrupulously, which can be described as unprecedented in the history of human science.

One comment provides sincere advice to the author. Please change reference [9] to appropriate one. There are lot of books and review articles on this topic. I will advise against the use of wiki page as reference cannot be used as scientific reference.

Thank you very much to this reviewer.

However, are the so-called academic journals, editors, and peer-review recommended literature necessarily scientific references?

The so-called academic journals firmly believe that even without understanding how θ & τ were formed, it can be concluded that they are CP violations. Is it scientific？

The so-called academic journals firmly believe that even if two objects (such as cobalt-60) that rotate in opposite directions are asymmetrical, they are still two objects that mirror each other. Is it scientific？

The so-called academic journals, editors, and peer-review (such as PRL, PNAS, Sciences, Nature, etc) oppose to discuss the aforementioned topics. Are they honest?

Their absurd theory leads to absurd scientific research behavior, which has been ongoing. They flaunt themselves for being able to live in the world of God, cats, and angels. Are they noble?

The so-called academic journals, editors, and scholar deceives and mocks the wisdom of the public can be described as unprecedented in the history of human science.

Mathematics is the language in which humans has written the universe.

Mathematics is definitely a science. However, the so-called facts observed in physics experiments may not necessarily be scientific. The so-called facts observed in physics experiments may lead physics to believe in God, cats, and angels, but mathematics does not.

Please inform the public. Which of the two-dimensional materials you observed in the physics experiment or the two-dimensional images in mathematics is the true two-dimensional?

Humans must accept the fact that scientific experiments are limited by nature. Topological vortices are a point defects. Point defects do not only impact the thermodynamic properties, but are also central to kinetic processes. Physics must synchronize with mathematics via topological vortex gravitational fields in order to truly recognized and understand the world we live and see.

Any assumptions, speculations, and delusions that deviate or distort mathematics, regardless of who or what institution they come from, are considered pseudoscience. The dirtiness and ugliness of physics today are already breathtaking.

One comment states:

Fig4.a-d taken from reference [6] thus should be properly acknowledged.

Fig4.e is taken from reference [1] thus should be acknowledged.

These are the two articles that were severely criticized by my manuscript.

Please inform the public, which of the so-called two-dimensional materials observed in physical experiments or two-dimensional images in mathematics is the true two-dimensional? Why may the so-called two-dimensional surfaces observed in experiments exhibit different colors? Is the so-called two-dimensional surface observed in the experiment necessarily absolutely smooth? How do you ensure that the results you observe are not affected by other factors?

Mathematics is definitely a science. However, the facts you believe in may not necessarily be scientific. Facts may make you hallucinate, may make you believe in God, but mathematics does not.

Humans must accept the fact that scientific experiments are limited by nature. Physics must synchronize with mathematics via topological vortex gravitational fields in order to truly recognized and understand the world we live and see.

Mathematics is the language in which humans has written the cosmos. Mathematicians associate topology as a distinct field of mathematics. Topological figures not only show the beauty of mathematics, but also change the way people understand nature. Research on it can greatly expand the boundaries of human cognition.

The topological vortex mathematical model is not only a theory, but also a physical display of two-dimensional matter. It is difficult to observe real two-dimensional topological vortices in the high-dimensional spatiotemporal physical world.

Humans must accept the fact that scientific experiments are limited by nature.

One comment：

“Topological vortices are the natural gravitational field.” What does the Author intended to convey?

Spin is one of the fundamental characteristics of topological vortices.

Due to the complex interactions of topological vortex fields, topological bifurcation is formed, which is the foundation for the formation and evolution of high-dimensional spatiotemporal matter. Without the help of high-dimensional spatiotemporal matter floating in the topological vortex field, it is difficult to observe the locus of two-dimensional topological vortex rotation in high-dimensional space-times. From cosmic accretion disks to microscopic particles, this is the case. The gravitational force formed by vortex fields is ubiquitous. This is the world we live and see today, including ourselves.