“Once-in-a-Million-Years” – Scientists Discover Strange Fossils of Duckbill Dinosaurs in Morocco

Minqaria bata

Minqaria bata was around the size of a pony (3-4 meters long) and closely resembles the European species of duckbill dinosaur. Credit: Raul Martin

Fossils of pony-sized duckbill dinosaurs from Morocco have been discovered by an international team of scientists. Their analysis reveals a surprising connection between the dinosaurs of Europe and Africa.

How did duckbill dinosaurs, a group that evolved in North America, end up in Morocco? At the end of the Cretaceous period, 66 million years ago, high sea levels and the breakup of the supercontinent Pangaea left Africa as an isolated island continent. It was surrounded on all sides by water.

Several years ago, remains of a member of the duckbill dinosaur family – a group that evolved in North America – were, however, found in Africa, raising the question of just how they got there.

New Insights from Scientific Reports

Now, a new study published in Scientific Reports reveals that not only did duckbills manage to cross the Tethys Sea, but they became highly diverse once they colonized Africa, with at least three species inhabiting North Africa at the end of the Cretaceous.

The fossils from Morocco reveal a new species of duckbill dinosaur, Minqaria bata, which was around 3-4 meters long and weighed about 250kg, about the size of a pony. Even though the animal was tiny by the duckbill standards, the bones of the skull were tightly knit together, showing it was mature.

Duckbill Braincase Fossil

Duckbill braincase fossil. Credit: Dr Nick Longrich

The anatomy of the new duckbill closely resembles that of European species, suggesting that the duckbills swam or floated across several hundred kilometers of open water to colonize North Africa. Furthermore, bigger bones suggest a third and larger species, about 5-6 meters long.

The study was conducted by Dr. Nicholas Longrich of the Department of Life Sciences and the Milner Centre for Evolution at the University of Bath, Xabier Pereda-Suberbiola of the University of the Basque Country, Nathalie Bardet of the Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle, and Nour-Eddine Jalil, of the Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle and Museum of Natural History of Marrakesh, Universite Cadi Ayyad.

Understanding Minqaria bata and its Ecosystem

The new dinosaur is named Minqaria bata (Arabic for ‘beak’ and ‘duck’ respectively). Minqaria closely resembles the only previously known African duckbill, Ajnabia odysseus, but the shape of the jaws and teeth is distinct, showing it was a different species, and probably occupied a different ecological niche.

Both Minqaria and Ajnabia were part of the subfamily Lambeosaurinae, a group of duckbills known for their elaborate head crests. These crests weren’t purely for show; they housed long nasal passages that could resonate like a horn.

“These were probably loud, vocal animals,” said Dr. Longrich, who led the study. “Modern birds vocalize to find mates, or to declare territories. But they’re especially vocal in flocks – a flock of flamingos or a nesting colony of pelicans is extremely noisy, constantly communicating.

“So it’s likely that like birds, these duckbills were social animals.”

The brain is also large by dinosaur standards, a feature associated with social animals like crows and primates.

Dr Longrich said: “There were probably very loud, noisy herds – or flocks if you prefer – of these little duckbills wandering the coasts of Morocco 66 million years ago.”

Minqaria was a small animal, but the bones surrounding the brain are tightly knit together and partially fused, showing that it was a fully grown adult. The other Moroccan species, Ajnabia, was about the same size. Bigger bones also studied by the team, including an arm bone and a thigh bone, suggest a third, larger species.

“Not only did duckbills manage to reach Africa at the end of the Cretaceous,” said Longrich, “But once they did, they quickly evolved to take advantage of open niches and became diverse.”

The Significance of the Discovery

At the end of the Cretaceous, sea levels were high, flooding much of the continents, and the Earth’s land was fragmented by the breakup of Pangaea and continental drift. That left Africa floating alone in the ocean, an island continent like modern-day Australia. But duckbill dinosaurs, evolving long after the land connections had been broken, somehow managed to get to Africa.

“It’s extremely improbable that dinosaurs could cross water to get to Africa,” said Longrich, “but improbable isn’t the same as impossible. And given enough time, improbable things become probable. Buy a lottery ticket every day, and if you wait long enough, you’ll win.

“These ocean crossings might be once-in-a-million-year events but the Cretaceous lasted nearly 100 million years. A lot of strange things will happen in that time – including dinosaurs crossing seas.”

Modern animals, he noted, have sometimes been seen making unusual ocean journeys. Iguanas swept offshore by a hurricane in the Caribbean washed up on another island, hundreds of kilometres away. A tortoise from the island of Aldabra was washed out to sea and drifted ashore in Tanzania, 700 kilometers away. Deer, elephants, and hippos swam out to the island of Crete during the ice age.

“These duckbills are maybe the most surprising find of my career,” said Longrich. “If you asked me what kind of dinosaurs we’d find in Africa, then a duckbill is the last thing I would have imagined, let alone three species.

“There’s still so much unknown in the fossil record, but if there wasn’t, we wouldn’t need to keep collecting fossils.”

Dr. Nour-Eddine Jalil of the Natural History Museum in Paris and the Université Cadi Ayyad, said: “The phosphates of Morocco offers new images on past biodiversity in a key period of the history of life, the last moments of the dinosaur age followed by the diversification of mammals, announcing a new era.

Minqaria and its relatives are players that a few years ago we would never have supposed to be on the African continent at that time.

“Despite their marine origin, these phosphates of Morocco also contain remains of vertebrates that lived on land. They constitute one of the only windows on the terrestrial ecosystems in Africa. The dinosaur remains suggest a great diversity, all the three major groups of dinosaurs are represented, the abelisaurid carnivores and the sauropod and ornithischian herbivores.”

Reference: “A new small duckbilled dinosaur (Hadrosauridae: Lambeosaurinae) from Morocco and dinosaur diversity in the late Maastrichtian of North Africa” by Nicholas R. Longrich, Xabier Pereda-Suberbiola, Nathalie Bardet and Nour-Eddine Jalil, 13 February 2024, Scientific Reports.
DOI: 10.1038/s41598-024-53447-9

The study was funded by the European Regional Development Fund and the Ministry of Science and Innovation.

4 Comments on "“Once-in-a-Million-Years” – Scientists Discover Strange Fossils of Duckbill Dinosaurs in Morocco"

  1. Patricia Dillavou | March 20, 2024 at 12:58 pm | Reply

    A map of Africa in the time period discussed would have been a wonderful addition to the article.
    Maps are routinely absent from nearly all such articles for some reason.
    Do you want a more educated, involved audience? People seriously interested in your research and subject matter?
    Give us the f***ing maps.

    • Torbjörn Larsson | April 10, 2024 at 11:00 am | Reply

      It’s a university press release that has a wide public including scientists, who can be assured to look up maps if they need it. If you don’t want to do that you can wait for a popularizer of science to rewrite press releases or papers to a more inviting format.

  2. I bet a single specimen hasn’t been found of the supposed billions ones that must have existed in the evolution from a proto-lizard to a duck-billed dinosaur.
    Like with all other animals of enough distinct shape for their evolution to be easily tracked through the fossil record.

    • Torbjörn Larsson | April 10, 2024 at 11:08 am | Reply

      The estimate that has stand since Darwin’s days is that on average one specimen of every species becomes a discoverable fossil for every thousand species or so.

      It is inconvenient but it doesn’t matter for such discoveries as above. And nowadays we can observe evolution not only through fossils of biogeography of plate tectonic drift or island migration but through genomes. Anyone can visit the NCBI genome site (say) and learn how to observe evolution in a few hours through video lectures, then use the genome databases and the softwares and make their own tests at a rate of one (small) tree every 30 minutes or so. It is very educational to see biology as it happened!

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.