Probing the Abyss: Fermilab’s Dark SRF Experiment Illuminates the Search for Dark Photons

Scientists have demonstrated remarkable sensitivity in searching for hypothetical dark photons through the Dark SRF experiment. They used superconducting radio frequency (SRF) cavities to trap regular photons and investigate their transformation into dark photons. This study has created the most stringent limitation yet on the existence of dark photons within a specific mass range. (Artist’s concept.)

The Dark SRF experiment at the Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory has achieved unprecedented sensitivity in the search for hypothetical dark photons. By innovatively employing superconducting radio frequency (SRF) cavities, researchers can now explore different potential mass ranges for these elusive particles, pushing the boundaries of our understanding of dark matter.

Scientists working on the Dark SRF experiment at the U.S. Department of Energy’s Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory have demonstrated unprecedented sensitivity in an experimental setup used to search for theorized particles called dark photons.

Researchers trapped ordinary, massless photons in devices called superconducting radio frequency cavities to look for the transition of those photons into their hypothesized dark sector counterparts. The experiment has put the world’s best constraint on the dark photon existence in a specific mass range, as recently published in Physical Review Letters.

“The dark photon is a copy similar to the photon we know and love, but with a few variations,” said Roni Harnik, a researcher at the Fermilab-hosted Superconducting Quantum Materials and Systems Center and co-author of this study.

The Dark SRF experiment demonstrated unprecedented sensitivity by using two SRF cavities as the key components for experiment. Credit: Reidar Hahn, Fermilab

Light that allows us to see the ordinary matter in our world is made of particles called photons. But ordinary matter only accounts for a small fraction of all matter. Our universe is filled with an unknown substance called dark matter, which comprises 85% of all matter. The Standard Model that describes the known particles and forces is incomplete.

In theorists’ simplest version, one undiscovered type of dark matter particle could account for all the dark matter in the universe. But many scientists suspect that the dark sector in the universe has many different particles and forces; some of them might have hidden interactions with ordinary matter particles and forces.

Just as the electron has copies that differ in some ways, including the muon and tau, the dark photon would be different from the regular photon and would have mass. Theoretically, once produced, photons and dark photons could transform into each other at a specific rate set by the dark photon’s properties.

Innovative use of SRF cavities

To look for dark photons, researchers perform a type of experiment called a light-shining-through-wall experiment. This approach uses two hollow, metallic cavities to detect the transformation of an ordinary photon into a dark matter photon. Scientists store ordinary photons in one cavity while leaving the other cavity empty. They then look for the emergence of photons in the empty cavity.

Fermilab researchers in the SQMS Center have years of expertise working with SRF cavities, which are used primarily in particle accelerators. SQMS Center researchers have now employed SRF cavities for other purposes, such as quantum computing and dark matter searches, due to their ability to store and harness electromagnetic energy with high efficiency.

Standing around the Dark SRF experiment from left to right are SQMS Center Director Anna Grassellino, SQMS Science Thrust Leader Roni Harnik and SQMS Technology Thrust Leader Alexander Romanenko. Credit: Reidar Hahn, Fermilab

“We were looking for other applications with superconducting radio frequency cavities, and I learned about these experiments where they use two copper cavities side-by-side to test for light shining through the wall,” said Alexander Romanenko, SQMS Center quantum technology thrust leader. “It was immediately clear to me that we could demonstrate greater sensitivity with SRF cavities than cavities used in previous experiments.”

This experiment marks the first demonstration of using SRF cavities to perform a light-shining-through-wall experiment.

The SRF cavities used by Romanenko and his collaborators are hollow chunks of niobium. When cooled to ultralow temperature, these cavities store photons, or packets of electromagnetic energy, very well. For the Dark SRF experiment, scientists cooled the SRF cavities in a bath of liquid helium to around 2 K, close to absolute zero.

At this temperature, electromagnetic energy flows effortlessly through niobium, which makes these cavities efficient at storing photons.

“We have been developing various schemes trying to handle the new opportunities and challenges brought in by this ultra-high-quality superconducting cavities for this light-shining-through-wall experiment,” said study co-author Zhen Liu, an SQMS Center physics and sensing team member from the University of Minnesota.

Researchers now can use SRF cavities with different resonance frequencies to cover various parts of the potential mass range for dark photons. This is because the peak sensitivity on the mass of the dark photon is directly related to the frequency of the regular photons stored in one of the SRF cavities.

“The team has done many follow-ups and cross-checks of the experiment,” said Liu, who worked on the data analysis and the verification design. “SRF cavities open many new search possibilities. The fact we covered new parameter regions for the dark photon’s mass shows their successfulness, competitiveness, and great promise for the future.”

“The Dark SRF experiment has paved the way for a new class of experiments under exploration at the SQMS Center, where these very high Q cavities are employed as extremely sensitive detectors,” said Anna Grassellino, director of the SQMS Center and co-PI of the experiment. “From dark matter to gravitational waves searches, to fundamental tests of quantum mechanics, these world’s-highest-efficiency cavities will help us uncover hints of new physics.”

Reference: “Search for Dark Photons with Superconducting Radio Frequency Cavities” by A. Romanenko, R. Harnik, A. Grassellino, R. Pilipenko, Y. Pischalnikov, Z. Liu, O. S. Melnychuk, B. Giaccone, O. Pronitchev, T. Khabiboulline, D. Frolov, S. Posen, S. Belomestnykh, A. Berlin and A. Hook, 26 June 2023, Physical Review Letters.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.130.261801