New research highlights the health and environmental benefits of substituting animal proteins with plant-based alternatives in Canadian diets, finding significant gains in life expectancy and reductions in carbon footprint, especially when replacing red and processed meats. Benefits vary by the type of animal protein replaced and show a sex difference in health outcomes.
Researchers at McGill have discovered that substituting plant protein foods for red and processed meats can extend life expectancy and reduce the impact on climate change.
The latest Canada’s Food Guide presents a paradigm shift in nutrition advice, nixing traditional food groups, including meat and dairy, and stressing the importance of plant-based proteins. Yet, the full implications of replacing animal with plant protein foods in Canadians’ diets are unknown.
New research at McGill University in collaboration with the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine provides compelling evidence that partially substituting animal with plant protein foods can increase life expectancy and decrease greenhouse gas emissions. Importantly, it also suggests that benefits depend on the type of animal protein being replaced.
The study, published in Nature Food, drew data from a national nutrition survey to analyze Canadians’ dietary records. The study modeled partial replacements (25% and 50%) of either red and processed meat or dairy with plant protein foods like nuts, seeds, legumes, tofu, and fortified soy beverages, on a combination of nutrition, health, and climate outcomes.
Small dietary changes, big impact on carbon footprint
Red and processed meat and dairy are the primary contributors to Canada’s diet-related greenhouse gas emissions, as evidenced in a previous study. Remarkably, this study found a person’s diet-related carbon footprint plummets by 25% when they replace half of their intake of red and processed meats with plant protein foods. On the other hand, dairy substitutions showed smaller reductions of up to 5%.
“We show that co-benefits for human and planetary health do not necessarily require wholesale changes to diets, such as adopting restrictive dietary patterns or excluding certain food groups altogether but can be achieved by making simple partial substitutions of red and processed meat, in particular, with plant protein foods,” explains Olivia Auclair, first author and recent PhD graduate in McGill’s Department of Animal Science.
Sex gap in plant-based health benefits
Diets high in animal products are known to increase the risk of heart disease, diabetes, and certain cancers. In this study, researchers estimated that if half of the red and processed meat in a person’s diet was replaced with plant protein foods, they could live on average, nearly nine months longer, stemming from a reduced risk of chronic disease.
When broken down by sex, males stand to gain more by making the switch, with the gain in life expectancy doubling that for females. In contrast, partially replacing dairy with plant protein foods led to smaller gains in life expectancy and was accompanied by a trade-off: an increased calcium inadequacy by up to 14%.
“I hope our findings will help consumers make healthier and more sustainable food choices and inform future food policy in Canada,” says senior author Sergio Burgos, Associate Professor in McGill’s Department of Animal Science and scientist at the Research Institute of McGill University Health Centre.
As more people seek sustainable and health-conscious diets, the study’s findings serve as a guide, empowering individuals to make informed choices that benefit both personal well-being and the planet.
“Increasing the consumption of plant-based foods alongside reductions in red and processed meat would have considerable benefits for health and the environment and would involve relatively small changes in diets for most people in Canada,” says Patricia Eustachio Colombo, co-author and Honorary Research Fellow at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine’s Centre on Climate Change & Planetary Health.
Reference: “Partial substitutions of animal with plant protein foods in Canadian diets have synergies and trade-offs among nutrition, health and climate outcomes” by Olivia Auclair, Patricia Eustachio Colombo, James Milner and Sergio A. Burgos, 16 February 2024, Nature Food.
DOI: 10.1038/s43016-024-00925-y
“…, researchers estimated that if half of the red and processed meat in a person’s diet was replaced with plant protein foods, they could live on average, nearly nine months longer, …”
In other words, one’s life-sentence to an impoverished range of tastes and textures gets extended by nine months. No thank you.
Personally, I doubt the claim. It is all too easy to find the results one is looking for when doing research on subjective topics. I find it unlikely that highly processed vegetable foods — essentially factory manufactured meat — will produce less CO2 than that produced by animals that can feed themselves and take themselves to water, and are simply cut up and distributed to consumers. If there is a problem with red meat, it is that consumers have a taste for fat and cattle are sent to feed lots to fatten them on — hold it — vegetable matter like corn. If people want their steaks marbled, it is unlikely that they will willingly change over to synthetic meat.
Next up “how eating raw vegetables reduces life expectancy and contributes to climate change, eat more boxed foods”