“Astonishing” 500-Million-Year-Old Fossilized Brains Prompt a Rethink of the Evolution of Insects and Spiders

Stanleycaris hirpex

Stanleycaris hirpex. Credit: Sabrina Cappelli © Royal Ontario Museum

An ancient radiodont predator with three eyes reveals key information about the evolution of the arthropod body plan.

New research based on a cache of fossils that contains the brain and nervous system of a half-billion-year-old marine predator from the Burgess Shale called Stanleycaris has been revealed by the Royal Ontario Museum (ROM). Belonging to an ancient, extinct offshoot of the arthropod evolutionary tree called Radiodonta, Stanleycaris is distantly related to modern insects and spiders. These results shed light on the evolution of the arthropod brain, vision, and head structure.

“The details are so clear it’s as if we were looking at an animal that died yesterday.”

Joseph Moysiuk

The findings were announced in the research paper, “A three-eyed radiodont with fossilized neuroanatomy informs the origin of the arthropod head and segmentation,” published on July 5, 2022, in the journal Current Biology.

Stanleycaris hirpex Fossil Specimens

Pair of fossil specimens of Stanleycaris hirpex, specimen ROMIP 65674.1-2. Credit: Photo by Jean-Bernard Caron, © Royal Ontario Museum

What has scientists most excited is what’s inside Stanleycaris’ head. The remains of the brain and nerves are still preserved after 506 million years in 84 of the fossils.

“While fossilized brains from the Cambrian Period aren’t new, this discovery stands out for the astonishing quality of preservation and the large number of specimens,” said Joseph Moysiuk, lead author of the research and a University of Toronto (U of T) PhD Candidate in Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, based at the Royal Ontario Museum. “We can even make out fine details such as visual processing centers serving the large eyes and traces of nerves entering the appendages. The details are so clear it’s as if we were looking at an animal that died yesterday.”

Turntable animation of Stanleycaris hirpex, including transparency to show internal organs. Credit: Animation by Sabrina Cappelli © Royal Ontario Museum

The new fossils reveal that the brain of Stanleycaris was composed of two segments, the protocerebrum, connected with the eyes, and the deutocerebrum, connected with the frontal claws.

“We conclude that a two-segmented head and brain has deep roots in the arthropod lineage and that its evolution likely preceded the three-segmented brain that characterizes all living members of this diverse animal phylum,” added Moysiuk.

In present-day arthropods like insects, the brain consists of protocerebrum, deutocerebrum, and tritocerebrum. While the difference in a segment may not sound game-changing, it in fact has radical scientific implications. Since repeated copies of many arthropod organs can be found in their segmented bodies, figuring out how segments line up between different species is key to understanding how these structures diversified across the group.

“These fossils are like a Rosetta Stone, helping to link traits in radiodonts and other early fossil arthropods with their counterparts in surviving groups.”

Reconstruction of Stanleycaris hirpex

Reconstruction of a pair of Stanleycaris hirpex; upper individual has transparency of the exterior increased to show internal organs. Nervous system is shown in light beige, digestive system in dark red. Credit: Illustration by Sabrina Cappelli © Royal Ontario Museum

In addition to its pair of stalked eyes, Stanleycaris possessed a large central eye at the front of its head, a feature never before noticed in a radiodont. “The presence of a huge third eye in Stanleycaris was unexpected. It emphasizes that these animals were even more bizarre-looking than we thought, but also shows us that the earliest arthropods had already evolved a variety of complex visual systems like many of their modern kin” said Dr. Jean-Bernard Caron, ROM’s Richard Ivey Curator of Invertebrate Palaeontology, and Moysiuk’s PhD supervisor. “Since most radiodonts are only known from scattered bits and pieces, this discovery is a crucial jump forward in understanding what they looked like and how they lived,” added Caron, who is also an Associate Professor at the U of T, in Ecology & Evolution and Earth Sciences.

Nervous System From Fossils of Stanleycaris

Paper summary, showing the interpretation of the nervous system from fossils of Stanleycaris and implications for understanding the evolution of the arthropod brain. The brain is represented in red and the nerve cords in purple. Credit: Photo by Jean-Bernard Caron © Royal Ontario Museum

In the Cambrian Period, radiodonts included some of the biggest animals around, with the famous “weird wonder” Anomalocaris reaching up to at least 1 meter in length. At no more than 20 cm long, Stanleycaris was small for its group, but at a time when most animals grew no bigger than a human finger, it would have been an impressive predator. Stanleycaris’ sophisticated sensory and nervous systems would have enabled it to efficiently pick out small prey in the gloom.

Stanleycaris hirpex Reconstruction

Reconstruction of Stanleycaris hirpex. Credit: Art by Sabrina Cappelli © Royal Ontario Museum

With large compound eyes, a formidable-looking circular mouth lined with teeth, frontal claws with an impressive array of spines, and a flexible, segmented body with a series of swimming flaps along its sides, Stanleycaris would have been the stuff of nightmares for any small bottom dweller unfortunate enough to cross its path.

About the Burgess Shale

For this research, Moysiuk and Caron studied a previously unpublished collection of 268 specimens of Stanleycaris. The fossils were primarily collected in the 1980s and 90s from rock layers above the famous Walcott Quarry site of the Burgess Shale in Yoho National Park, B.C., Canada, and are part of the extensive collection of Burgess Shale fossils housed at ROM.

The Burgess Shale fossil sites are located within Yoho and Kootenay National Parks and are managed by Parks Canada. Parks Canada is proud to work with leading scientific researchers to expand knowledge and understanding of this key period of earth history and to share these sites with the world through award-winning guided hikes. The Burgess Shale was designated a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1980 due to its outstanding universal value and is now part of the larger Canadian Rocky Mountain Parks World Heritage Site.

Fossils of Stanleycaris can be seen by the public in the new Burgess Shale fossil display in the Willner Madge Gallery, Dawn of Life at ROM.

Reference: “A three-eyed radiodont with fossilized neuroanatomy informs the origin of the arthropod head and segmentation” by Joseph Moysiuk and Jean-Bernard Caron, 8 July 2022, Current Biology.
DOI: 10.1016/j.cub.2022.06.027

Major research funding support came from the National Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada, via a Vanier Canada Graduate Scholarship to Moysiuk and a Discovery Grant (no. 341944) to Caron.

9 Comments on "“Astonishing” 500-Million-Year-Old Fossilized Brains Prompt a Rethink of the Evolution of Insects and Spiders"

  1. Another day, another ‘revolutionary’ discovery, but never any actual proof. Welcome to the whacky world of the atheist creation myth.

    • Christopher Ducey | July 9, 2022 at 1:42 pm | Reply

      New knowledge and human advancement evil, ancient myths and superstition good.

    • I’ve been to the Mt Stephen fossil bed site, in the Burgess Shale deposits mentioned, and seen some of these fossils with my own eyes. Can you provide the same proof for your imaginary sky friend?

  2. I found the article interesting but only towards the end it mentioned the creature’s size was 20 centimeters. I was thinking some milimiters. IMHO this info should come right at the beginning of the article and also on the photo caption. Thanks for listening.

  3. Michael Reichwein | July 10, 2022 at 6:37 pm | Reply

    Here is what I do not understand. They claim 500 million years ago. But I just learned that plant life started only 50 million years ago. What did these animals live on for 450 million years?

    • they were sea creatures and probably ate fish and chips

    • Maybe check your numbers on that? Some of the dinosaurs were around as much as 165 million years ago, and the Devonian era land animals (and others) are even older than that. I only vaguely recall the details, but I’m pretty sure that plant life spread from the sea to land well before any animal life did. And even so, plant life existed in the oceans for many hundreds of millions of years before that.
      Are you thinking perhaps about modern flowering plants only appearing about 50 million years ago?

    • A living ecosystem STARTS with plant life. And being that the dinosaurs died out roughly 65 million years ago, after having been around in some form for millions of years themselves, it is impossible to assert that plants started 50 million years ago.

  4. Darren z burns | July 12, 2022 at 4:10 am | Reply

    I always thought spiders where from Mars;? (Sorry, sad David Bowie plug there, don’t shoot me please, I have so much more to give LOL!)

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.