Replacing Animal Products With a Plant-Based Diet Leads to Weight Loss, Finds New Analysis

Young Man Weight Loss Before After Concept

A study reveals that overweight adults who replace animal products with plant-based foods experience significant weight loss and improved health, regardless of the healthfulness of the plant-based foods consumed.

Switching from animal products to plant-based foods, regardless of whether these plant-based items are considered healthy or unhealthy as per the plant-based diet index, leads to weight loss in overweight individuals, lowers cholesterol and fat consumption, and boosts fiber intake according to a new analysis by the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine published in the European Journal of Clinical Nutrition.

“While a low-fat vegan diet rich in fruits, vegetables, grains, and beans is the gold standard for weight loss and improved health, the good news is that a plant-based diet that eliminates animal products and minimizes the consumption of oil can help with weight loss in people who are overweight,” says study co-author Hana Kahleova, MD, PhD, director of clinical research at the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine.

Analysis and Results

The findings are from a secondary analysis of a Physicians Committee study in which 244 overweight adults were randomly assigned to a vegan group that followed a low-fat vegan diet or a control group that made no diet changes for 16 weeks. Calorie intake was not limited for either group, and neither group was given diet quality instructions.

The new analysis assessed the association of a plant-based diet index (PDI), healthful plant-based diet index (hPDI), and unhealthful plant-based diet index (uPDI) with weight loss. The PDI measures adherence to a plant-based diet in general, the hPDI includes more fruits, vegetables, grains, and beans, and the uPDI includes more foods such as refined grains and fruit juices. The scores of all three indexes are higher with increased consumption of plant-based foods and reduced consumption of animal products.

In the analysis, all three scores increased for participants following a vegan diet, which was significantly associated with an average weight loss of about 13 pounds, due primarily to the reduction in fat mass and visceral fat. Increased consumption of whole grains and legumes and reduced consumption of meat, vegetable oil, and sweets in the vegan group was associated with weight loss. There was no change in scores in the control group.

Reference: “Does diet quality matter? A secondary analysis of a randomized clinical trial” by Hana Kahleova, Haley Brennan, Tatiana Znayenko-Miller, Richard Holubkov and Neal D. Barnard, 28 November 2023, European Journal of Clinical Nutrition.
DOI: 10.1038/s41430-023-01371-y

3 Comments on "Replacing Animal Products With a Plant-Based Diet Leads to Weight Loss, Finds New Analysis"

  1. Stupid propaganda.

    For thousands of years humans have eaten meat and not had weight problems.
    These “scientists” should be ashamed to bring illegitimacy to their profession.

  2. Charles G. Shaver | January 18, 2024 at 8:53 am | Reply

    As mentioned near the conclusion of the original article, the study is “limited;” fatally flawed in my senior lay opinion. Too typically, it did not factor-in nearly subclinical non-IgE-mediated food allergy reactions to mostly animal proteins (e.g., Dr. Arthur F. Coca, by 1935), it did not factor-in officially (FDA in the US) approved allergy aggravating food poisoning for profit (e.g., added MSG, 1980; US obesity/diabetes epidemic presented by 1990, CDC/NCHS data), it did not factor-in how there are some micronutrients not found in a plant based diet which are found in animal based diets and it was years to decades too brief to be of any practical value. Can’t anything dietary coming out of Washington, DC, be trusted?

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.