An international team of researchers has developed a fast and economical method of converting methane, commonly called natural gas, into liquid methanol at ambient temperature and pressure. The approach uses visible light to drive the conversion in a continuous flow across a photocatalytic material. The research was led by scientists at the University of Manchester.
To help observe how the process works and how selective it is, the researchers used neutron scattering at the VISION instrument at Oak Ridge National Laboratory’s Spallation Neutron Source.
The method involves a continuous flow of methane/oxygen-saturated water over a novel metal-organic framework (MOF) catalyst. The MOF is porous and contains different components that each have a role in absorbing light, transferring electrons, and activating and bringing together methane and oxygen. The liquid methanol is easily extracted from the water. Such a process has commonly been considered “a holy grail of catalysis” and is an area of focus for research supported by the U.S. Department of Energy. Details of the team’s findings, titled “Direct photo-oxidation of methane to methanol over a mono-iron hydroxyl site,” will be published today (June 30, 2022) in the journal Nature Materials.
An international team of researchers, led by scientists at the University of Manchester, has developed a fast and economical method of converting methane, or natural gas, into liquid methanol at ambient temperature and pressure. The method takes place under continuous flow over a photo-catalytic material using visible light to drive the conversion. Credit: ORNL/Jill Hemman
Naturally occurring methane is a plentiful and valuable fuel, used for stovetops, ovens, furnaces, water heaters, kilns, automobiles, and turbines. However, methane is flammable and combustible and can also be dangerous due to the difficulty of extracting, transporting, and storing it.
Methane gas is also a potent greenhouse gas, making it harmful to the environment when it is released or leaks into the atmosphere. Leading sources of atmospheric methane include fossil fuel production and use, rotting or burning biomass such as forest fires, agricultural waste products, landfills, and melting permafrost.
Excess methane is commonly burned off, or flared, to reduce its environmental impact. However, this combustion process still produces carbon dioxide, which itself is a greenhouse gas.
Industry has long sought an economical and efficient way to convert methane into methanol, a highly marketable and versatile feedstock used to make a variety of consumer and industrial products. Not only would this help to reduce methane emissions, but it would also provide an economic incentive to do so.
Methanol is a more versatile carbon source than methane and is an easily transportable liquid. It can be used to make thousands of products such as solvents, antifreeze, and acrylic plastics; synthetic fabrics and fibers; adhesives, paint, and plywood; and chemical agents used in pharmaceuticals and agrichemicals. The conversion of methane into a high-value fuel such as methanol is also becoming more attractive as worldwide petroleum reserves dwindle.
Breaking the bond
A primary challenge of converting methane (CH4) to methanol (CH3OH) has been the difficulty of weakening or breaking the carbon-hydrogen (C-H) chemical bond in order to insert an oxygen (O) atom to form a C-OH bond. Conventional methane conversion methods typically involve two stages, steam reforming followed by syngas oxidation, which are energy intensive, costly and inefficient as they require high temperatures and pressures.
The fast and economical methane-to-methanol process developed by the research team uses a multicomponent MOF material and visible light to drive the conversion. A flow of CH4 and O2 saturated water is passed through a layer of the MOF granules while exposed to the light. The MOF contains different designed components that are located and held in fixed positions within the porous superstructure. They work together to absorb light to generate electrons which are passed to oxygen and methane within the pores to form methanol.
“To greatly simplify the process, when methane gas is exposed to the functional MOF material containing mono-iron-hydroxyl sites, the activated oxygen molecules and energy from the light promote the activation of the C-H bond in methane to form methanol,” said Sihai Yang, a professor of chemistry at Manchester and corresponding author. “The process is 100% selective – meaning there is no undesirable by-product – comparable with methane monooxygenase, which is the enzyme in nature for this process.”
The experiments demonstrated that the solid catalyst can be isolated, washed, dried, and reused for at least 10 cycles, or approximately 200 hours of reaction time, without any loss of performance.
The new photocatalytic process is analogous to how plants convert light energy to chemical energy during photosynthesis. Plants absorb sunlight and carbon dioxide through their leaves. A photocatalytic process then converts these elements into sugars, oxygen, and water vapor.
“This process has been termed the ‘holy grail of catalysis.’ Instead of burning methane, it may now be possible to convert the gas directly to methanol, a high-value chemical that can be used to produce biofuels, solvents, pesticides, and fuel additives for vehicles,” said Martin Schröder, vice president and dean of faculty of science and engineering at Manchester and corresponding author. “This new MOF material may also be capable of facilitating other types of chemical reactions by serving as a sort of test tube in which we can combine different substances to see how they react.”
Using neutrons to picture the process
“Using neutron scattering to take ‘pictures’ at the VISION instrument initially confirmed the strong interactions between CH4 and the mono-iron-hydroxyl sites in the MOF that weaken the C-H bonds,” said Yongqiang Cheng, instrument scientist at the ORNL Neutron Sciences Directorate.
“VISION is a high-throughput neutron vibrational spectrometer optimized to provide information about molecular structure, chemical bonding and intermolecular interactions,” said Anibal “Timmy” Ramirez Cuesta, who leads the Chemical Spectroscopy Group at SNS. “Methane molecules produce strong and characteristic neutron scattering signals from their rotation and vibration, which are also sensitive to the local environment. This enables us to reveal unambiguously the bond-weakening interactions between CH4 and the MOF with advanced neutron spectroscopy techniques.”
Fast, economical, and reusable
By eliminating the need for high temperatures or pressures, and using the energy from sunlight to drive the photo-oxidation process, the new conversion method could substantially lower equipment and operating costs. The higher speed of the process and its ability to convert methane to methanol with no undesirable byproducts will facilitate the development of in-line processing that minimizes costs.
Reference: “Direct photo-oxidation of methane to methanol over a mono-iron hydroxyl site” by Bing An, Zhe Li, Zi Wang, Xiangdi Zeng, Xue Han, Yongqiang Cheng, Alena M. Sheveleva, Zhongyue Zhang, Floriana Tuna, Eric J. L. McInnes, Mark. D. Frogley, Anibal J. Ramirez-Cuesta, Louise S. Natrajan, Cheng Wang, Wenbin Lin, Sihai Yang and Martin Schröder, 30 June 2022, Nature Materials.
Funding and resources were provided by the Royal Society; the University of Manchester; the EPSRC National Service for EPR Spectroscopy at Manchester; the European Research Council under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program; the Diamond Light Source at the Harwell Science and Innovation Campus in Oxfordshire; the U.S. Department of Energy’s Spallation Neutron Source at Oak Ridge National Laboratory and the Advanced Photon Source at Argonne National Laboratory; and the Aichi Synchrotron Radiation Centre in Seto City. Computing resources at ORNL were made available through the VirtuES and ICE-MAN projects funded by ORNL’s Laboratory Directed Research and Development program and Compute and Data Environment for Science.
What isn’t mentioned is whether the energy required to produce the aqueous product stream, extract the methanol, and refurbish the catalyst, exceeds the energy available in the methanol. Just because something CAN be done doesn’t mean that the economics of the process will lead to its widespread adoption. The ‘free’ energy from the sun may cover the energy costs of the process, but that isn’t made clear. Burning the methanol will produce CO2, just as with methane. It might be energetically more efficient to just burn the methane and use the heat of combustion to drive other chemical processes — or power vehicles. Once again, the entire process isn’t examined in a beginning-to-end holistic approach.
What is mentioned, but not the exact, precise amount of energy is that it works at room temperature and is far more efficient. Additionally, methanol is a very powerful and highly needed basic feedstock for uncountable uses throughout many industries. If we can capture and remove this 84 times more potent GHG than CO2 gas AND replace the millions of tons of petroleum feedstock that will always be vital to humanity, I read this news as nothing less than a miracle invention up there with polio, smallpox, electric arc steel mills, Nikola Tesla and his A/C electricity, absolutely game changing.
I love seeing the incredible diversity of the scientists, and hopefully something that will be available for licensing to all the companies and NGO’S who cannot sleep at night, worried sick and desperate for additional ways to save the planet, dealing with both human and natural solutions before we see the Thwaites Glacier break up in three years and start a radically shortened road to a three foot sea water rise.
“… but not the exact, precise amount of energy …”
That is very important! Despite this being an improvement, if the net energy isn’t positive, or at least superior to present methods of obtaining methanol, then it is unlikely to be adopted.
Imagine that you have inflexible monthly bills of $3,000, but only earn $2,000 after taxes. You will quickly fall behind on your payments, and start paying penalties, which will exacerbate the situation. It won’t be long before you have to go into bankruptcy, and lose everything. You can’t applaud an improvement unless the improvement is great enough to make something that was formerly impossible, possible. There is a critical threshold — profitability — that must be exceeded. Just getting close, but not exceeding, just means that you lose money more slowly, but the end result will be the same.
Grail-er if they got ethanol or even a trans butyl ester, but hooray for a kind of bore fixup. Stop those methane superemitters!