Shattered Dreams: Scientists Debunk LK-99 Room Temperature Superconductivity Myth

Myth of Room Temperature Superconductivity in Lk-99 Is Shattered

A study from the CAS Institute of Physics has debunked the claims of superconductivity in LK-99, a compound earlier thought to exhibit superconductivity at ambient pressure. The research found that the compound’s observed properties were due to the first-order structural transition of Cu2S impurities, not superconductivity. This conclusion resolves the confusion sparked by earlier claims that had caused a viral sensation among scientists and the public.

New research has disproved the superconductivity claims of LK-99, showing that its properties result from the structural transition of Cu2S impurities, not superconductivity.

In a study published in Matter, researchers led by Prof. Jianlin Luo from the Institute of Physics of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS) have observed that Pb10-xCux(PO4)6O (0.9<x<1.1), known as LK-99, originates from the first-order structural transition of the impurity phase of cuprous sulfide (Cu2S), providing solid evidence that LK99 is non-superconducting and thus disproving such superconductivity claims.

Superconductivity Claims and Viral Sensation

Sukbae Lee and colleagues from South Korea earlier asserted that LK-99 behaves as a superconductor at ambient pressure, with a critical temperature (Tc) up to 127°C (400 K). The groundbreaking news excited scientists as well as people on social media due to its potential impact on technology.

As reported by Nature News, claims about the supposed superconductivity of LK-99 became a viral sensation, prompting numerous replication efforts by scientists and amateurs alike. Several groups have attempted to replicate the results, but none have provided direct evidence of superconductivity. The most puzzling question is what causes the sharp drop in resistivity and why it occurs only in a few samples.

Cu2S and LK-99 Temperature Dependence of Resistivity

Temperature dependence of resistivity of Cu2S, LK-99 including Cu2S. Credit: Institute of Physics

Investigation and Conclusion

In this study, the researchers observed that the LK-99 generated by Lee et al. contained a certain amount of Cu2S impurity, which undergoes a structural phase transition from a hexagonal structure at high temperature to a monoclinic structure at low temperature around 400 K. They found that the resistivity of Cu2S decreased by three to four orders of magnitude around 385 K, close to the transition temperature reported in references.

In addition, they measured the resistivity of the mixture of LK-99 and Cu2S, identifying a sharp resistivity transition at the temperature consistent with the reported findings but without zero resistance.

It is important to note that this first-order structural transition differs significantly from the second-order superconducting transition. The researchers observed thermal hysteresis behavior in the resistivity and magnetic susceptibility measurements, confirming that it is a first-order transition and cannot be a second-order superconducting transition.

Reference: “First-order transition in LK-99 containing Cu2S” by Shilin Zhu, Wei Wu, Zheng Li and Jianlin Luo, 24 November 2023, Matter.
DOI: 10.1016/j.matt.2023.11.001

This study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China, the Ministry of Science and Technology of China, and CAS.

1 Comment on "Shattered Dreams: Scientists Debunk LK-99 Room Temperature Superconductivity Myth"

  1. According to topological vortex gravitational field theory, this is just the tip of the iceberg of pseudo scientific papers in today’s academic community. If the author is truly interested in science, they can browse

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.