New research reports that the Western approach to mindfulness often focuses too much on self-improvement, overlooking its broader applications for reflection and connection.
Feeling overwhelmed with summer childcare duties? Craving a tranquil escape? It might be time to unwind and practice some calming mindfulness.
in recent times, there’s been an escalating curiosity in this practice that promotes taking a moment to be wholly absorbed in the present. It guides individuals in navigating life’s challenges without becoming overly reactive or swamped. Rooted in Eastern philosophy and Buddhism, mindfulness is part of a larger ethical framework.
However, a new review from the unique University of Bath Centre for Mindfulness and Community challenges how the practice has been evolving in the West and how it has, in part, been distorted by the self-help community. It suggests that instead of people using mindfulness to focus on their role in relation to others, more often they focus on themselves and self-improvement.
The analysis, from a team of psychologists and therapists at the Bath Centre for Mindfulness and Community suggests the broader meaning and applications of mindfulness are often lost, and that the true benefits of the practice in developing a deeper sense of reflection and connection are missed. Their review is published in the Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy.
One of the report leads, clinical psychologist Dr Liz Marks has successfully used mindfulness within the NHS as an approach for managing tinnitus and recognises its effectiveness in encouraging people to pause and reflect on busy lives. She thinks people could benefit even more if they used mindfulness to help them think about other people and the natural world.
“There is growing interest in mindfulness around the world, and rightly so. The practice offers an important opportunity in ever-hectic lives to pause and reflect. But too often, this is presented as another tool for self-betterment. We suggest that mindfulness can offer more than this, giving people the chance to ‘look outside themselves’, deepening their sense of place within nature and interconnectedness with their community,” she said.
Dr Marks’ other area of research focuses on environmental psychology, the rise of eco-anxiety, concerns about the planet, and what can be done about this. Instead of seeing the practice of mindfulness as a fix for ‘how to make my life better’, she suggests that it is a supportive practice helping people live well alongside the challenges of modern life, whilst also helping them to think about ‘how can we make the world a better place for all of us?’
Co-author, Dr. Pamela Jacobsen is a specialist in cognitive behavioral therapy and mindfulness and has studied how the practice can be used in acute psychiatric settings to help patients with severe mental health challenges. She hopes the findings can also spur extra interest in testing mindfulness in clinical settings.
“There is a great potential to use mindfulness across a range of health conditions, from chronic pain to depression. In line with growing interest in the practice, there has also been a proliferation of online ‘Mindfulness apps’. We need to ensure these are matched with fully tested and evaluated programs which people can access and benefit from.”
Reference: “Current Tensions and Challenges in Mindfulness Research and Practice” by Ben Ainsworth, Melissa J. Atkinson, Eman AlBedah, Sian Duncan, Julia Groot, Pamela Jacobsen, Amanda James, Tom A. Jenkins, Katerina Kylisova, Elizabeth Marks, Emma L. Osborne, Masha Remskar and Rosalia Underhill, 20 May 2023, Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy.
DOI: 10.1007/s10879-023-09584-9
Be the first to comment on "The True Essence of Mindfulness: New Study Reveals It’s Not All About You"