Highly Efficient Eco-Friendly Perovskite Solar Cells With Enhanced Stability

Solar Cell Function Testing

A researcher tests the function of the solar cells inside the glove box. Credit: City University of Hong Kong

While the power conversion efficiency of perovskite solar cells (PVSCs) — a future of solar cells — has already greatly improved in the past decade, the problems of instability and potential environmental impact are yet to be overcome. Recently, scientists from City University of Hong Kong (CityU) have developed a novel method which can simultaneously tackle the leakage of lead from PVSCs and the stability issue without compromising efficiency, paving the way for real-life application of perovskite photovoltaic technology.

The research team is co-led by Professor Alex Jen Kwan-yue, CityU’s Provost and Chair Professor of Chemistry and Materials Science, together with Professor Xu Zhengtao and Dr Zhu Zonglong from the Department of Chemistry. Their research findings were recently published in the scientific journal Nature Nanotechnology, titled “2D metal-organic framework for stable perovskite solar cells with minimized lead leakage.”

Currently, the highest power conversion efficiency of PVSCs has been on par with the state-of-the-art silicon-based solar cells. However, the perovskites used contain lead component which raises a concern for potential environmental contamination. “As the solar cell ages, the lead species can leak through the devices, e.g. through rainwater into the soil, posing a toxicity threat to the environment,” explained Professor Jen who is an expert in PVSCs. “To put PVSCs into large-scale commercial uses, it requires not only high power conversion efficiency but also long-term device stability and minimized environmental impact.”

Lead Ions Captured MOF layer

Over 80% of the leaked lead ions are captured in the top MOF layer to mitigate the potential environmental impact. Credit: DOI: 10.1038/s41565-020-0765-7

Collaborating with Professor Xu whose expertise is materials synthesis, Professor Jen and Dr Zhu led the team to overcome the above challenges by applying two-dimensional (2D) metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) to PVSCs. “We are the first team to fabricate PVSC devices with minimized lead leakage, good long-term stability, and high power conversion efficiency simultaneously,” Professor Jen summarised their research breakthrough.

Multi-functional MOF layer

Metal-organic framework (MOF) materials have been previously applied as scaffolds to template the growth of perovskites. Scientists have also used them as additives or surface modifiers to passivate (to reduce the reactivity of the material’s surface) the defects of perovskites for enhancing the device performance and stability.

However, most of the 3D MOFs are quite electrical insulating with low charge-carrier mobility, hence unsuitable to be used as the charge-transporting materials.

But the MOFs prepared by Professor Xu is different. They are honeycomb-like, 2D structure equipped with numerous thiol groups as a key functionality. They possess suitable energy levels, enabling them to be an electron-extraction layer (also called “electron-collection layer”) where electrons are finally collected by the electrode of the PVSCs. “Our molecular engineered MOFs possess the property of a multi-functional semiconductor, and can be used to enhance the charge extraction efficiency,” explained Professor Xu.

Trapping the lead ions to prevent contamination

More importantly, the dense arrays of thiol and disulfide groups in the MOFs can “capture” heavy metal ions at the perovskite-electrode interface to mitigate lead leakage.

Lead Concentration Aged M PVSCs

The lead concentration in the aqueous extracted from the aged M-PVSCs (PVSCs with MOF) decreased drastically compared to r-PVSCs (PVSCs without MOF). This is attributed to the chemical reaction between the dense array of thiol and disulphide groups in the MOF with leaked lead ions. Credit: DOI: 10.1038/s41565-020-0765-7

“Our experiments showed that the MOF used as the outer layer of the PVSC device captured over 80% of the leaked lead ions from the degraded perovskite and formed water-insoluble complexes which would not contaminate the soil,” Professor Jen explained. Unlike the physical encapsulation methods used in reducing lead leakage in other studies, this in-situ chemical sorption of lead by the integrated MOF component in the device was found to be more effective and sustainable for long-term practical applications.

Long-term operational stability achieved

Moreover, this MOF material could protect perovskites against moisture and oxygen while maintaining high efficiency.

The power conversion efficiency of their PVSC device modified with MOF could reach 22.02% with a fill factor of 81.28% and open-circuit voltage of 1.20 V. Both the conversion efficiency and the open-circuit voltage recorded are among the highest values reported for the planar inverted PVSCs. At the same time, the device exhibited superior stability in an ambient environment with the relative humidity of 75%, maintaining 90% of its initial efficiency after 1,100 hours. In contrast, the power conversion efficiency of the PVSC without MOF dropped significantly to less than 50% of its original value.

Also, their device retained 92% of its initial efficiency under continuous light irradiation for 1,000 hours at 85°C. “Such level of stability has already met the standard for commercialization set by the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC),” said Dr Zhu.

“This is a very significant result which proved our MOF method is technically feasible and has the potential in commercializing the PVSC technology,” added Professor Jen.

Highly efficient PVSCs for clean energy applications

It took the team almost two years to accomplish this promising research. Their next step will be to further enhance the power conversion efficiency and explore the ways to lower the production cost.

“We hope in the future the manufacturing of this type of PVSCs would be like ‘printing out’ newspapers and easily scaled up in production, facilitating the large-scale deployment of highly efficient PVSCs for clean energy applications,” concluded Professor Jen.

Reference: “2D metal–organic framework for stable perovskite solar cells with minimized lead leakage” by Shengfan Wu, Zhen Li, Mu-Qing Li, Yingxue Diao, Francis Lin, Tiantian Liu, Jie Zhang, Peter Tieu, Wenpei Gao, Feng Qi, Xiaoqing Pan, Zhengtao Xu, Zonglong Zhu and Alex K.-Y. Jen, 21 September 2020, Nature Nanotechnology.
DOI: 10.1038/s41565-020-0765-7

Professor Jen, Professor Xu and Dr Zhu are the corresponding authors of the paper. The first author of the paper is CityU PhD student Wu Shengfan. Other CityU research team members are Li Zhen, Li Mu-Qing, Diao Yingxue, Francis Lin, Liu Tiantian, Zhang Jie and Qi Feng. The collaboration also involves fellow researchers from Xi’an Jiaotong University, University of Washington, and the University of California-Irvine.

The study received various funding support, including CityU, Hong Kong Research Grants Council, Guangdong Major Project of Basic and Applied Basic Research, and the National Science Foundation.

5 Comments on "Highly Efficient Eco-Friendly Perovskite Solar Cells With Enhanced Stability"

  1. what happens to the lead when the solar cell is retired from service?

    • It seems that little thought has been given to the potential for increased lead in the environment from mining, smelting, and refining of the lead, and subsequent fabrication of the devices.

  2. “… their device retained 92% of its initial efficiency under continuous light irradiation for 1,000 hours at 85°C.”

    That is equivalent to about 83, 12-hour days, or one Summer. What is needed is retention of efficiency for decades, not days!

  3. Michele Ferraro | September 27, 2020 at 2:37 pm | Reply

    I think they are experimenting this on my truck.

  4. A solar panel with lead that only last one season. Looks like we’re going backwards into the pre ban on lead era.
    Wouldn’t it be better to do what Tesla does and completely redesign the factory process – of good ole silicon panels?

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.