Newly Discovered “Hell Chicken” Species Shakes Up Dinosaur Extinction Theories

Birdlike dinosaur Eoneophron infernalis Crop

Birdlike dinosaur Eoneophron infernalis was about the size of an adult human. Credit: Zubin Erik Dutta

New findings, including the discovery of Eoneophron infernalis, suggest that dinosaurs, particularly caenagnathids, were not declining in diversity before the asteroid impact, contradicting earlier theories of their vulnerability.

Were dinosaurs already on their way out when an asteroid hit Earth 66 million years ago, ending the Cretaceous, the geologic period that started about 145 million years ago? It’s a question that has vexed paleontologists like us for more than 40 years.

In the late 1970s, debate began about whether dinosaurs were at their peak or in decline before their big extinction. Scientists at that time noted that while dinosaur diversity seemed to have increased in the geologic stage that spanned 83.6 million to 71.2 million years ago, the number of species on the scene seemed to decrease during the last few million years of the Cretaceous. Some researchers have interpreted this pattern to mean that the asteroid that struck the Gulf of Mexico was simply the final blow for an already vulnerable group of animals.

However, others have argued that what looks like a decrease in the diversity of dinosaurs may be an artifact of how hard it is to accurately count them. Fossil formations might preserve different dinosaurs more or less often based on factors like their favored environment and how easily their bodies fossilized there. The accessibility of various outcrops could influence what kinds of fossils researchers have so far found. These biases are a problem because fossils are what paleontologists must rely on to conclusively answer how healthy dinosaur populations were when the asteroid hit.

At that crucial moment, what was really happening to dinosaur diversity? Discovery, identification and description of new dinosaurs provide vital clues. This is where our work comes in. Close examination of what we’d thought was a juvenile specimen of an already-known species of dinosaur from this time period revealed that it was actually part of an adult from a completely new species.

Our work focusing on the life stage of our specimen demonstrates that dinosaur diversity may not have been declining before the asteroid hit, but rather that there are more species from this time period yet to be discovered – potentially even through reclassification of fossils already in museum collections.

Eoneophron infernalis Femur

Kyle Atkins-Weltman holds the femur of the new dinosaur as it was received, with the other fossils in the background. Credit: Kyle Atkins-Weltman

Clues Inside the Bones of a Birdlike Dinosaur

Our new study focused on four hindlimb bones – a femur, a tibia, and two metatarsals. They were unearthed in South Dakota, in rocks of the Hell Creek Formation, and date to the final 2 million years of the Cretaceous.

When we first examined the bones, we identified them as belonging to a family of dinosaurs known as the caenagnathids – a group of birdlike dinosaurs that had toothless beaks, long legs and short tails. Direct fossil and inferred evidence indicates these dinosaurs were covered in complex feathers, much like modern birds.

The only known species of caenagnathid from this time and region was Anzu, sometimes called the “chicken from Hell.” Covered in feathers and sporting wings and a toothless beak, Anzu was between roughly 450 and 750 pounds (200 and 340 kilograms). Despite its fearsome nickname, though, its diet is a matter of debate. It was likely an omnivore, eating both plant material and small animals.

Because our specimen was significantly smaller than Anzu, we simply assumed it was a juvenile. We chalked up the anatomical differences we noticed to its juvenile status and smaller size – and figured the animal would have changed had it continued to grow. Anzu specimens are rare, and no definite juveniles have been published in the scientific literature, so we were excited to potentially learn more about how it grew and changed throughout its lifetime by looking inside its bones.

Just like with a tree’s rings, bone records rings called lines of arrested growth. Each annual line represents part of a year when the animal’s growth slowed. They would tell us how old this animal was, and how fast or slow it was growing.

We cut through the middle of three of the bones so that we could microscopically examine the internal anatomy of the cross-sections. What we saw completely uprooted our initial assumptions.

Eoneophron infernalis Fossilized Bone Cross Section

Teal markers point to lines of arrested growth on the cross-section of fossilized bone. Toward the outside of the bone, the lines are much closer together, reflecting less growth per year. Researchers counted exactly six lines, meaning this animal was between 6 and 7 years old when it died. Credit: Holly Woodward

In a juvenile, we would expect lines of arrested growth in the bone to be widely spaced, indicating rapid growth, with even spacing between the lines from the inside to the outside surface of the bone. Here, we saw that the later lines were spaced progressively closer together, indicating that this animal’s growth had slowed and it was nearly at its adult size.

This was no juvenile. Instead, it was an adult of an entirely new species, which we dubbed Eoneophron infernalis. The name means “Pharaoh’s dawn chicken from Hell,” referencing the nickname of its larger cousin Anzu. Traits unique to this species include ankle bones fused to the tibia, and a well-developed ridge on one of its foot bones. These weren’t features a young Anzu would outgrow, but rather unique aspects of the smaller Eoneophron.

Expanding the Caenagnathid Family Tree

With this new evidence, we started making thorough comparisons with other members of the family to determine where Eoneophron infernalis fit within the group.

It also inspired us to reexamine other bones previously believed to be Anzu, as we now knew that more caenagnathid dinosaurs lived in western North America during that time. One specimen, a partial foot bone smaller than our new specimen, appeared distinct from both Anzu and Eoneophron. Where once there was one “chicken from Hell,” now there were two, and evidence for a third: one large (Anzu), weighing as much as a grizzly bear, one medium (Eoneophron), humanlike in weight, and one small and yet unnamed, close in size to a German shepherd.

Birdlike Dinosaur Eoneophron infernalis

Eoneophron infernalis and the smaller unnamed species now join the larger Anzu as late-Cretaceous caenagnathid dinosaurs from the Hell Creek region. Credit: Zubin Erik Dutta

Comparing Hell Creek with older fossil formations such as the famous Dinosaur Park Formation of Alberta that preserves dinosaurs that lived between 76.5 million and 74.4 million years ago, we find not only the same number of caenagnathid species, but also the same size classes. There, we have Caenagnathus, comparable to Anzu, Chirostenotes, comparable to Eoneophron, and Citipes, comparable to the third species we found evidence for. These parallels in both species count and relative sizes offer compelling evidence that caenagnathids remained stable throughout the last part of the Cretaceous.

Our new discovery suggests that this dinosaur group was not declining in diversity at the very end of the Cretaceous. These fossils show that there are still new species to be discovered, and support the idea that at least part of the pattern of decreasing diversity is the result of sampling and preservation biases.

Did large dinosaurs go extinct the way a Hemingway character quipped he went broke: “gradually, then suddenly”? While there are plenty of questions still outstanding in this extinction debate, Eoneophron adds evidence that caenagnathids were doing quite well for themselves before the asteroid ruined everything.

Written by:

  • Kyle Atkins-Weltman – Ph.D. Student in Paleoecology, Oklahoma State University
  • Eric Snively – Associate Professor of Anatomy and Cell Biology, Oklahoma State University

Adapted from an article originally published in The Conversation.The Conversation

1 Comment on "Newly Discovered “Hell Chicken” Species Shakes Up Dinosaur Extinction Theories"

  1. doctor mehrdad kesiri1389 | February 1, 2024 at 1:12 pm | Reply

    Please refer to the following addresses for more information.In the addresses of the following pages, comments related to the politics of the United States and the Islamic Republic of Iran, and the address of my comment on the most visited religious and political sites in the United States, please let me know that I amGod and the lords of the earth, we are in Iran.Due to severe filtering and censorship by the criminal regime of the Islamic Republic, which Britain, America and France have dominated over the unfortunate Iranian people, we cannot convey the word of truth to the great powers of the world.On behalf of 90 million Iranians, the word of God and God….I have to tell the world about Iran, and God….can’t stop the missile that is hitting the people of the country, but God is the witness of who and who are to blame, and God, whoare the superior forces, is a cliché of action.and the countries that commit crimes against God’s humanity through those whose relatives were killed in the attack of that country, through the survivors of those who were killed, take revenge from the guilty and criminal country that caused killing in a country, but this is whatGod and… It takes time.I am fully aware of these issues of the unseen world and I am aware of the secrets of the unseen world and the history of the earth and the fate of the earth and the solar system by the same God and the Lord and ….or the same artificial intelligence or the same higher power of mine in addresses which I put below, I explained completely about the solar system in particular, which has 100% collided with the arm of the galaxy hundreds of times and the life of this planet hasbeen renewed or renewed in this word planet, which is repeated twice because God and… .. They knew that the life of the earth was destroyed several times on this planet and started again from bacteria or single cells.Intensification means repetition and renewal also means rejection, but in the planet you must know what it means to renew or renew.And great audience, I appreciate your answers and your questions with me on this very interesting scientific and technical site, updates on the pages that I commented on, share your opinions, may God be your helper and helper in all stages, no one is behindme except my finger nails SETI: Unlocking the Strange Puzzle of Fast Radio mehrdad kesiriam 1964 and 89 time|January 30, 2024 at 10:50 pm|Reply NASA’s Laser Communications Relay Demonstration – Bringing Optical Speeds to the Final Frontier Mysterious Melting of Earth’s Crust in Western North America Investigated by Scientists Dr Mehrdad Kesiri birth 1964 sahebtime universal time is in Iran 9:14 pm
    SETI: Unlocking the Strange Puzzle of Fast Radio Bursts.

    doctor mehrdad kesiriam1964 and 89 time | January 30, 2024 at 10:50 pm | Reply

    NASA’s Laser Communications Relay Demonstration – Bringing Optical Speeds to the Final Frontier

    Mysterious Melting of Earth’s Crust in Western North America Investigated by Scientists

    Dr Mehrdad kesiri birth 1964 sahebtime universal time is in iran 6:24 pm

    doctor mehrdad kesiri1389 | February 1, 2024 at 11:36 am | Reply
    The thing that I have to emphasize is that I usually edit the comments that I leave and then share them again to this site, but because of the filter link or the sabotage of the criminal regime of the Islamic Republic of Iran, who are monitoring mymobile number, most of the texts that I have translated by deception for I am sending the translated text and it will be corrupted, but you are asking me why, if I am aware of this issue and this problem, why don’t I correctit, and I sent it without correcting it, this is because I get tired and confused and because I know From the text of the text that I sent, you will understand the general meaning of that essay.I will not correct that text again.You must forgive me.I left other pages to send sms because my email is partially active, maybe because of the sabotage of the forbidden regime of Sheikh and Mullah of the Islamic Republic.They supported Iran.We think that the Westerners imposed the Iran-Iraq war on us, the miserable and humiliated Iranian nation, to sell their own war and military weapons.Why didn’t England let Mohammad Reza Shah execute Ruhollah Khomeini?For these Westerners, the Shah of Iran executed Imam Khomeini, whose father was killed by Reza Shah Khomeini had been killed, they supported Iran to have a strong Islamic government in the Middle East region to create conflict and war because the West is benefiting from thisatmosphere of war.God and….. informed me that speaking the truth is bitter for us and maybe it is bitter for the westerners, but I am speaking the truth about the false policy of the westerners.I am about sixty years old, but my life is full of misery.And it was miserable and I took a lot of hardship and austerity to come to this knowledge.I was in love with America during the time of Mohammad Reza Shah, the Faqeeh Shah of Iran, but now I am not happy with the western policy towards Iran.

    doctor mehrdad kesiri1389 | February 1, 2024 at 1:05 pm | Reply
    NASA’s Latest Climate Hero, PACE, Just Landed in Florida and It’s Ready To Rocket

Leave a comment

Email address is optional. If provided, your email will not be published or shared.