Researchers Show Homemade COVID Face Masks Work – Effectiveness Varies Depending on Design

Penetration and atomization of cough droplets through single layer homemade mask fabrics. Credit: Bal Krishan

Triple-layer cotton towel fabric masks shown most efficient for blocking aerosolized virus.

Since the spread of virus causing COVID-19 continues, experts recommended wearing homemade facemasks when surgical or N95 masks are not available to prevent the spread of the pandemic. While such makeshift masks are more economical and accessible in low-capita countries, the effectiveness of cloth masks has not been studied in depth.

In Physics of Fluids, by AIP Publishing, researchers from the Indian Institute of Science studied the fate of large-sized surrogate cough droplets at different velocities, corresponding from mild to severe, while using various locally procured fabrics as masks.

“Our results show cotton, towel-based fabrics were most effective among the considered fabrics and must be stitched together as multiple layers for making homemade facemasks,” said author Saptarshi Basu. “A three or more-layered homemade mask is recommended, since it can suppress aerosolization significantly.”

The researchers analyzed the effect of washing on mask effectiveness, and results showed a negligible influence of washing on mask efficacy for up to 70 wash cycles.

Using a piezoelectric-based droplet dispenser, the researchers created surrogate cough droplets that impacted a single layer of different fabric samples at different velocities. The fabrics used in the research included single layers of summer stole, handkerchief, cotton towel, and surgical masks.

The specific cotton-fabric materials were selected based on their daily usage and the propensity of people to cover their face using these cloth materials. The researchers used high-speed imaging to quantify the threshold for penetration and amount of droplet penetration at different velocities.

The researchers looked at how fabric properties, like pore size and porosity, influences droplet penetration through the mask.

The results are relevant for many groups including policymakers investigating how to counter aerosol generation through secondary atomization of cough droplets as they penetrate the mask fabric. For mask fabricators and the general population, it is helpful to know that N95 and surgical masks are most effective, but when those aren’t available, some specific cotton materials or homemade fabrics are suitable for effective makeshift face masks.

The findings also could be applicable in applications ranging from agriculture to medical practices, where placing a wire mesh or perhaps an engineered cellulose mesh of variable porosity can reduce the momentum of incoming spray from a nozzle, thereby ensuring optimal spread of nutrients or pesticides to crops or better disinfection in hospital.

Reference: “Efficacy of homemade face masks against human coughs: Insights on penetration, atomization, and aerosolization of cough droplets” by Bal Krishan, Dipendra Gupta, Gautham Vadlamudi, Shubham Sharma, Dipshikha Chakravortty and Saptarshi Basu, 14 September 2021, Physics of Fluids.
DOI: 10.1063/5.0061007

American Institute of PhysicsCOVID-19Infectious DiseasesPopularPublic Health
Comments ( 2 )
Add Comment
  • rossmpersonal

    Don’t take the risk that a homemade mask is ineffectiveness. Use a well-fitting, authentic surgical N95 respirator. There is no shortage of non-3M surgical N95 respirators at this point. They are highly affordable. For example, https://shop.projectn95.org/gerson-n95-respirators-3230plus-box-of-50/p costs only 80 centers per N95.

    I strongly recommend that all who do not already have surgical N95 respirators go to https://shop.projectn95.org and buy surgical N95 respirators. They are a non-profit and do not make any money off your purchase. They thoroughly vet all sources. In fact at this point, they get nearly all products directly from the manufacturer. I am not affiliated with the organization. They are the only source I know of that you can truly rely on for getting surgical N95 respirators that are not counterfeit. If I were you, I would not trust any other source offering surgical N95 respirators that are not counterfeit or fraudulent. Keep in mind surgical N95 respirators are single-use items. Do not reuse surgical N95 respirators. Please plan your purchase quantity accordingly.

    • G

      That is just not realistic, even at 80 cents.
      Even a home made cloth mask, or the cheap regular masks that people use are hugely better than nothing.